Hi Derwin,
I’m not aware of any other records that directly link Christianna to a Cottom family, but the available evidence suggests she is the sister of my ggg grandfather George Cottom (age 68 in the 1851 census for Kitley Township). He emigrated from Wexford with his family in 1848. I believe that Willimina and George Cottom, listed with Christianna in the 1851 census, are children of this George Cottom and Mary Sutton.
There are baptismal records from the Church of Ireland at Adamstown (Co. Wexford) for some of George and Mary’s children.
Child / Date of birth / Date of baptism
Jane / 21 Oct 1813 (probably 1823) / 14 Jul 1833
Not given / 21 Sep 1826 / 14 Jul 1833
Not given / 5 Jun 1831 / 14 Jul 1833
Maria / 15 Apr 1833 / 14 Jul 1833
William / 23 Jan 1829 / 1 Sep 1833
George / 1 Feb 1834 / 7 Jun 1835
Samuel / Not given / 8 Oct 1837
Caesar / 1 Jan 1939 / 7 Apr 1839
Willimina is not listed. Nor is my great, great grandmother Sarah (see Augusta Township census records for James and Sarah Reynolds starting in 1851), but her death record lists George and Mary as her parents, so I know she belongs. She and Willimina could be the two unnamed children. The two oldest sons (Sutton b.ca1818 and Richard b.ca1821) are also not listed, nor is John G., another known son. However, George, b.1834 is a fit for George in the 1851 census, and Willimina is almost certainly his sister based on residency in 1851. That there was a sibling named Willimina is reasonable as the name is common in the family. Sarah and Sutton both had daughters named Wilhelmina. As you suggested, Christianna would most likely be an aunt or cousin of George and Willimina. Her age suggests she is the sister of George (b.ca 1782), hence their aunt.
In the late 18th and early 19th centuries the Cottoms in Wexford can be divided based on their residence in the townlands of either Brownstown or Newbawn. The Brownstown Cottoms, descended from Samuel Cottom and Hannah Sealy, are very well defined based on records in the Chancery Court of Virginia, related to the Will of Samuel and Hannah’s son Richard Cottom. If Christianna was part of this family she should appear, but she doesn’t.So by elimination she is probably part of the Newbawn branch. Our knowledge of the Newbawn Cottoms, descended from Richard Cottom and Sarah Sealy (m. 1769), is incomplete, but George was their son and I would suggest that Christianna was a daughter. If not proven, I think it’s at least strongly suggestive.
If Christianna had multiple children and you know their names and birth order, you might be able to get her parents names if she followed the traditional Irish naming convention (oldest daughter named after maternal grandmother, second oldest son named after maternal grandfather) and confirm her placement that way.
I have attached a revised version of the chart that accompanied my 2015 article in the Journal of the Wexford Historical Society. Note that the chart and article title refer to the parish of Newbawn, which contains the townlands of Newbawn and Brownstown.
Thanks for posting. I thought Christianna might be a Cottom but didn’t know the details.
John