Hi Anniemarie:
Thank you for your detective work. It is possible that this is he. I'm just so confused because of the following:
I know for sure that he had a sister Johanna who preceded him to NYC and who married Edwin Jones and lived on Long Island NYC, but I know nothing more about them. So from my prowling around the records on RootsIReland (which is very expensive!) , I can tell there is a family from Waterford (William Ruth and Mary Phelan Ruth) who gave birth to both a Johanna and a Richard Cornelius Ruth. They lived in Trinity Without and in the Waterford family, Richard Cornelius was born Sept 2, 1883. Johanna was born April 10, 1881. This would seem like the right family BUT, he told everyone he was from Limerick and he never mentioned Waterford. Yet I suppose he could have made his way around Ireland yes? Or that this Limerick family is related to the Waterford people?
I do know that he had been married before he married my grandmother Catherine Gibbons. I don't know of any children they had together but she died in a tenement fall, hanging laundry on line outside in Brooklyn. But they must have married by 1905 or so, because my Nana Catherine gave birth to my Aunt Dede (Bridget or Edith, depending on the census you consult) in 1908 and my father James Francis, in 1909.
He never made it to Pittsburgh once here, at least I don't think so. But as you point out, people may have wandered around. By 1910, my grandfather is most definitely on the US Census below.
So, what you suggest is very possibly true, but this does raise the question about Johanna. Who or where was she? I never met my grandfather and grandmother and my much old siblings recall her as his sister, but perhaps she is a cousin?
On othe tidbit: my father said his father was a "Lot older than he let on" when he died. I am having trouble getting the NYC death certificate on him.
More importantly, how will I ever find out?
Thank you for trying on my behalf. Any additional information is most welcome including any suggestions of where to look. I don't want to bother anyone, but if we knew of some Ruths in Limerick or Waterford who had done their own trees, it might really help.
Thank you very much!
Betty J Ruth
Name:Richard RuthAge in 1910:32Birth Year:abt 1878
[1878] Birthplace:IrelandHome in 1910:Brooklyn Ward 12, Kings, New YorkRace:WhiteGender:MaleImmigration Year:1892Relation to Head of House:Self (Head)
[Head] Marital Status:MarriedSpouse's Name:Catherine RuthFather's Birthplace:IrelandMother's Birthplace:IrelandNeighbors:View others on pageHousehold Members:NameAgeRichard Ruth32Catherine Ruth34Bridget Ruth2James Ruth0
[11/12]