Am following your suggestions one by one, although I have done most of them before--wish my family had been more creative with names! WE still aren't.
And I appreciate your comments on my ggrandfther's picture--I consider him quite handsom. The eyes were passed down to my father, brother, and my son!
The first I knew of Waterford was in checking RC records here for my grandfather's baptism. It was with the first child, born 1866 that Nicholas was listed as being from Waterford. That information is repeated in other records. As for connecting the other individuals, RC records show all acting as witnesses or sponsors for marrieages and baptisms. The US Census shows all three either living in the same residence, or very close to each other. John is finally listed as "superannuated" and 74 yo, living with Michael in the 1870 Census.
Castle Garden Records do have 1 Nicholas, and it indicates the correct time and age. Michaels and Johns are abundant. On no record is there any additional information.
BTW, incas you did not know, Ellis did not open until the 1890's Many Americans are under the false assumption that all our ancestors came in there--but that would be wrong. During the Great Hunger era, ports such as Baltimore were equally active with New York--and no , I have had no luck there.
The Irish Times list 16 Fogarty households ih Waterford in the mid century period--I would presume this information comes primarily from Griffiths.
There was a John listed in Griffith's as living in Inishlounaught--I, however, do not know what year Waterford was valuated--could you tell me that?
Have not checked the Tithe Applotments.
Nicholas's children were Emma, twins John and James, Mary (Mamie), and Philip--my grandfather.
And I did repost my message in the Tipperary board.
thank you for all your help
Kathleen