Thank you for investigating our possible Philbin connection. Sarah Philbin is still a possibility but some of my recent research has pointed me to another Sarah - Sarah Ryan of Roscrea.
According to the 1910 U.S. Census John and Sarah Devlin responded that they were married for 18 years. That would put their date of marriage in 1892, not in 1899 as the John Devlin/Sarah Philbin Philadelphia record indicates.
Also in the 1910 Census Sarah lists her age as 43 making her date of birth sometime between 1866-67. I recently came across a birth record for a Sarah Ryan in 1866. I am going to try to attach it to this email.
After John's first wife Anne Short died from complications from childbirth in December, 1884 I suspect that he may have returned back to Roscrea. While there he may have meet Sarah Ryan.
John first immigrated to the States in 1880, I am not sure of the date of his second trip. Sarah Ryan immigrated in 1888. John and Sarah first successful birth was to a girl named Nora in 1895. The census indicates that Sarah has a total of eight children, only five survived. I have indentified one of deceased children as Jeremiah (Jeremy) Devlin who died in 1900 around one year of age.
I am hoping a death record of Jeremy Devlin may shed light on who Sarah actually may be - Philbin or Ryan.
Thank you again for your insights. Any new thoughts are always welcomed.
Jeff