Search for James McSharry born ca. 1839

Roger:  Thank you so much for clarification about the parish and it's recorded years, since Edward was younger than at least some of his siblings.  I too found and was amazed at the overlap with Denis and Mary and played with possibility that father had accompanied older family to US and mother stayed home with younger.  BUT, our aunt made no mention of younger siblings or of his father in US, and since she had other correct info from non-digital sources, I decided to trust her story.  Also, I found parish entry for an Edward born of parents with identical names on 11 July 1868.  Unfortunately, I carelessly didn't record which parish.  So, since he wouldn't have been baptized twice, I'm accepting as a hypothesis that not only were there two boys of almost same age with same name, but they also had identically named parents.  What do you think?  I have observed in the records that McSharry, Gallagher, and McNulty seemed to circle around each other in the whole general area, often with the same first names used throughout line, although James, Michael and John are much more common than Edward.  I assume they were a similar class/culture of farmers in the larger area and were part of a long established community there.  Edwards's siblings per our aunt with birth years from US censuses were: Mary, b August 1859; Anne/Annie b April 1864; John born in 1870; Michael, whose identify I can't confirm from number of possibilities; and James, who went off to England and became a policeman, whom I'm assuming was either first born of all or oldest son at least.  I did find a James in Griffiths but wasn't sure if same family; and if so, if we're their father or grandfather.  Was Sligo done in early or later years of Griffith?  Also, do you know anything about the settlement of the large number of McSharries in what seems to be the lower mountainous portion of Rossinver.  I've read a few references to their possibly having Gallowglass origins and wondered if that was where their "aristocratic employer" originally gave them land if this is true? Also forgot to mention that either once in US or before, Edward changed his surname to Foley, although family tradition knew he was originally a McSharry.  Will try to locate the July parish entry to see if it dovetails with where Mary and Denis lived. Will continue to share anything I find.  Appreciate,  Jude

Roger:  Sorry I posted response twice.  Still learning site.  Just went back and looked again at the copies I have on my computer and I realized I'm conflating the two Edwards and I think my aunt did too.  But how did she know???  Anyway, it's the July 11 Edward who was baptized in Glenade.  And the August Edward is not a parish register, but the civil recording. And the latter is the entry that has their home location, carney, Sligo, Ireland. And that this is accurate is also family tradition.  Some cousins actually traveled there about a decade ago.  Yet, our aunt picked up the grandparents from the 11 July baptism.  Would the birth possibly have been officially registered later than the actually birth and baptism?  Could these to sets of child/parents with identical names actually be the same people?   Baptized in July.  Registered with government in August?  Is such a thing common?  Also found that Ancestry now brings up a number of summary only entires for McSharries born in Carney in the 1860s so their may have been a number of families there then, although by the 1901 census I think only Gallaghers remain of family names.  I think I'm confused. J

Roger:  Thank you for clarifying that the competing dates for Edward's birth could be for the very same child.  They have been troublling me for a long time.  Good to have that settled.

Now, about Denis.  I looked at our sources again.  The birth record that shows he is my great uncle indicates February 1871 as his birth in Carnay.  But the 1901 and 1911 Census for the Denis living with Mary, and later Patrick, in Murranfad do not correspond with this.  They both indicate that his birth was in approximately 1875. I tend to trust this estimate  since the same appropriate age for this birth year was on censuses ten years apart.  So I think I've learned that there was at least one additional child, Denis, born in 1871  a year or so after another son, John who is in the US censuses.  I can not find a death record for this Denis yet, but that's my best guess.  That our Denis died.  And that the slightly younger Denis who remained alive was born to another McSharry who remained in Mullanfad.  What do you think of this?

Roger:  I don't quite understand.  Are you saying that the Denis in Mullanfad tis likely the 1874 birth in Killargue with a Mary mother?