Back to Message Board

DNA Connection

 I am looking for help trying to connect with a DNA match. His 3x gr. grandfather was Nicholas Crawford b. abt. 1799 in Queen's Co. (Laois), and my 2x gr. grandfather was John Crawford b. abt. 1799 in King's Co. (Offaly). Alternatively, his 3x gr. grandmother was Catherine Holmes b. abt.1801 in Offaly and my 3x gr. grandmother was Ann Holmes b. 1755 in Offaly. Neither he nor I have been able to find birth or marriage records for parent's names. Any help would be greatly appreciated.

ron_oakley

11 replies

Ron:

I presume your ancestors were Church of Ireland. I searched the subscription site Roots Ireland for baptismal records for then four individuals mentioned but did not find a possible lead. I also looked for a Crawford/Holmes marriage in either Laois or Offaly with no success.

Roots Ireland has a few C of I parishes with records back to the late 1700s or earlier so your ancestors were not from those parishes. Many of the C of I parish records were destroyed in the 1922 Public Records Office fire in Dublin. Some parishes have maintained their records locally while other parishes have their records at the Representative Church Body Library in Dublin, however, at this time those records are not integrated into a searchable data base.

I also checked the Tithe listings from the late 1820s but did not find a lead.

Roger McDonnell

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Hello Ron

Do you have a Gedmatch kit number by any chance, if so there is a group Offaly DNA you could join.

If you have kit number I could run it for you on the group and give you the results.

My email is rahan@irelandxo.com

Geraldine

Geraldine Buckley-Smith, Ireland XO VolunteerIrelandXO Volunteer

I am also looking for a DNA match to confirm the parish my 3x great grandfather was from. His name was Michael Connor born 1783 in Queens County. He died Jan 12, 1868 in North Brant, Bruce County, Ontario, Canada.His wife was Mary Murphy born July 1799 also in Queens County and died Feb16, 1880 in North Brant, Bruce County, Ontario, Canada. I have a picture of their gravestone in Canada with this information. I have no record of when either emigrated to Canada or if they were married in Canada or Ireland. I also do not have any proof of their parents names but I did find a baptism record for a Mary Murphy from Ballinakill, Laois, Ireland on July 11, 1799 from “Ireland, Select Catholic Birth and Baptism Registers, 1763-1917”. The parents of this Mary Murphy are listed as Michl Murphy and Mary Glennan. I also have info from the Catholic Parish register, 1655-1915 for the same Mary Murphy, July 11, 1799 with the same parents but the baptism place is now listed as Ballynakill, Laois not Ballinakill and,

The Parish Variants are Ballenakill, Ballyroan, Abyleix and Knocgordegur, Ballinakill, Dusart Galen, and the

Diocese is Kildare and Leighlin. 

Due to the fact that both of my ancestors have very common Irish names I am hoping for a DNA match to confirm which Parish is actually theirs before I travel to Ireland. 
Thank you for any help you may have.

Richard Knibbs

Alberta, Canada

 

Richard Knibbs

Has anyone had any luck with my request from Feb 2923? I have DNA results from Ancestry.ca and I have uploaded my results to GENmatch also. This Brick wall has plagued me for over 4 years so any help would be much appreciated. I am 70 years old and do not have any knowledge on how to match DNA with Irish DNA so help in this would be awesome.

Richard Knibbs

Okotoks, Alberta, Canada

Richard Knibbs

Richard:

The percentage of people in Ireland taking DNA tests is at a lower rate than Canadians/ Americans etc. However, they are testing with the same companies that are available in Canada or the USA. They also have the opportunity to upload their data to Gedmatch.

Any DNA matches with your Connor/Murphy lines would likely be a fourth or fifth cousin or even more distant.

Roger

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Hello Richard

So you have done your DNA with Ancestry and uploaded the results to Gedmatch - so Gedmatch then issue you with a Kit Number

Have you got that number and I will try and help you to run your kit in different DNA groups here in Ireland

Hope that is of help

Geraldine

 

P.S. Richard if you do not want to put your kit number here then send it to me on email rahan@irelandxo.com

Geraldine Buckley-Smith, Ireland XO VolunteerIrelandXO Volunteer

Geraldine and Roger: Thanks for the reply. This is exciting information and very helpful. Fingers crossed that I will finally find out their parish. Happy New Year.

(Richard) “Kevin”

Richard Knibbs

Hi Richard,

I appreciate that it is difficult to get into DNA if you have no previous experience and those that do have exerience often talk Greek when it comes to explanations.

What you need to do with your matches is to put them in order on the website. Using the top match look to see if it has a tree or origins that are of interest to you and see what they have discovered? - and work down the list... boring and...

...this can be a bit tedious but if you are up for it a very simple method uses the same list and takes the top match to you - then look for joint matches which are on your list. The top match and the joint match all belong to the same branch of your tree. No great technical knowledge needed, just some patience and organisation (I speak from experience). Give all the people in this new list a label like the letter A or Blue.

Then take the next biggest match on your original list and do the same thing - looking a tjoint matches.

Each of these groups will have no info or lots of info and you can norrow down and see where their origins are? Also who to contact and reach out to? It saves a lot of time and effort and any new match can easily be compared by finding out which joint matches you have. Although the main DNA websites do not provide this assitance (why?) it is used by every well known and commercial genealogist. Myself, I worked in DNA twice but I still had to do this manual grouping for each company my DNA is with, so you will be in good company :)

Seamus Crowe, IrelandXO Volunteer ☘IrelandXO Volunteer

This is a great start for me. Hopefully I will not have any questions while I work on this method. Thanks. "Kevin" (Richard)

Richard Knibbs

I posted this to the DNA forum too but no harm in duplicating this?

I wrote it because so many people do the test but are not helped by the companies to get traction. My opinion, is that the companies want to sell you their products and laying out a simple but tedious method is not in their interests? Some do give you clusters but only for large matches they do not try to connect the smaller matches that we use every day. hey-ho :)

Feel free to paass on the document attached? I wrote it for myself to give to others and save repeating myself but this was particularly designed with IrelandXO cooperation. I am told it is on the site but IrelandXO's main aim is not DNA analysis...... : )

In my opinion, unless you are blessed with definbite knowledge of your origins and / or locations in Ireland DNA is the one sure possibilty to find connection and proof?

Good luck but message me about any problems - the protocol may need fine tuning?

best wishes

Shay

Seamus Crowe, IrelandXO Volunteer ☘IrelandXO Volunteer

Thanks ever so much Shay. It is so great that you are open to helping all of us reach our goal of finding the parish our ancestors came from.

Richard Knibbs

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.