Deb,
I live quite near Bellaghy and I too don?t know of any townland that would fit ?Rosegift?. (There?s only about 26 townlands in the parish and none even begins with the letter R). Can?t help with that I am afraid. Scullion is a very common name in the area and so it wouldn?t be at all surprising if he did come from Bellaghy. Kearney is found in the area too, with, in Griffiths Valuation 1859, households in Ballymacombs More, Ballydermot, Mullaghboy and Castledawson Main St.
If James Scullion was from Bellaghy and born c 1834, then the bad news is that that RC parish (Ballyscullion) only has baptism records from 1844 onwards, so you are unlikely to trace his birth that way. (Likewise Sarah?s if she is from the same parish). The baptism & marriage records are on-line, on the rootsireland site, but as Roger says, there?s no trace of this marriage.
RC marriages weren?t entered into the statutory marriage records until 1864, and so the only way of tracing the marriage is via church records. If it?s any consolation, RC marriage records from that era don?t normally contain much information anyway. Usually just the couples names, the date of the marriage and their 2 witnesses. (No parents names). You occasionally get a townland but not always. (I have seen the Ballyuscullion RC records in the past and my vague recollection is that there are townlands shown for the marriages.) It might be worth double checking them when the records come on-line later this year in case the marriage has been mistranscribed or omitted from the rootsireland site).
Elwyn