Not all Presbyterian records are on-line on the pay to view sites like rootsireland. They porbably only have about 25% of the available Presbyterian records. And not all churches records go back to the period you need. So the picture ins patchy. The most complete sets of Presbyterian records are in PRONI (the public record office) and the Presbyterian Historical Society, both in Belfast. They are not on-line. A personal visit is required to go through them all, but there are probably 100 Presbyterian churches in Co. Derry so it’s a fair bit of work if you can’t narrow the search area in some way.
Usual advice in these circumstances is to search all Scottish sources (wills, gravestones, death notices, military records etc) in the hope that a more definite place of origin appears. Also look for families from the same area in Ireland living next door to your family in censuses. People often lived near relatives and others they knew from home. Sometimes by researching them you can trace your family.
If you think the family might ever have claimed under the Poor Law in Scotland then their records are worth searching as they usually record the parish of origin in Ireland, and often details of next of kin. If the family lived in Ayrshire, I think the Poor Law records are in Ayr County record office.
http://publicrecordsearch.co.uk/scotland/ayrshire-county-public-records/
If searching all the Presbyterian records, I’d start with those for the town of Londonderry and then move to the rural ones. But you may need a day or so to go through them all.