Hi Keith
I have just been going back over the information I have and also rereading Elwyn's replies to your query. On the 1831 census there are three Brooks families living in Carmean, as you noted in your initial query. Although the National Library of Island site has two transcriptons for Carmean. One under Carmean and the other under Carmane. Andrew Brooks does not appear on the Carmean transcription only Margaret and John in houses 5 and 6 respectively. On the Carmane transcription Margaret is in house 5, John in house 6 and Andrew in house 7. Which is correct I don't know.
Assuming the Carmane one to be the correct one, my reply continues as follows:
Elwyn only mentioned Andrew Brooks, who presumably is your gt gt grandfather. There is also John Brooks who I believe is my 3 xgt grandfather and father of my Andrew. The third family consists of two females and the head is a Margaret Brooks. Margaret is listed as W Margt, I am guessing this is actually Widow Margaret Brooks. So I have supposed Margaret Brooks, widow, is the mother of Andrew and John and that she is living with an unmarried daughter. or perhaps one of the granddaughters next door to her sons and their families. Perhaps there are several houses on the one farm.
I have been looking at Google Earth to see if there was a cluster of buildings on the land listed as being occupied by Elizabeth Brooks on the Griffiths Valuation. Assuming of course this is the same land that the three Brooks families were living on, on the 1831 census. Unfortunately the land seems to now be mostly taken up by the Carmean Limestone Quarry and any buidlings that may have been there are now under a slurry pond.
The townland of Carmean was and is farm land (except for the quarry). There are no villages just a whole lot of farms then and now. So the fact that there are three Brooks families in houses 5, 6 and 7 on the 1831 census suggests they are definitely on the same farm and part of the same family.
The Drapers Company which owned the townland of Carmean gave leases to Andrew Brooks and Margaret Brooks in November 1820. What detail those lease documents hold I don't know and we won't be able to find out as the access to those documents is closed for some reason. Another lease document occurrs in 1854 to an Eliza (Elizabeth?) Brooks who is presumably the one who appears on the 1859 Griffiths Valuation.
When you say that you found the baptismal records for Andrew and Esther's children on RootsIreland, does this mean that RootsIreland has the Presbyterian church records?
There are fourteen Brooks on the 1831 census in Carmean. It would be good if we could work out who they all were.