Hello Janet,
After posting the reply dated 13 January 2019, I did some further research into your O’Keefe/Keefe and Connell ancestors, and can say with some certainty that the Daniel O’Keefe and Hannah Connell who were married in the Ballymacoda Catholic Church in 1859, are not your ancestors, as you’ll see when you go through all the information below, and access the enclosed attachments.
As you know your O’Keefe and Connells are recorded in the 1880 census in Boston with their four children, including 12 year old John, 10 year old Mary, 5 year old Daniel, and 3 year old Hannah.
Moving forward to the 1900 census, the mother Hannah Keefe is shown to be a widow. In the household with her are two of her children, 25 year old Daniel and 22 year old Hannah. The 1900 census also shows that the mother Hannah had given birth to 4 children, with the 4 children still living. Her year of immigration is 1865, though you can’t always trust that immigration years recorded in these old census returns were accurate.
Going back to Irish records I found what I believe is the marriage for a Daniel O’Keefe and Hannah Connell. They were married on 26 January 1869 in the Ballymacoda Ladysbridge Catholic Parish. I believe you have this record. I initially found a transcription of the marriage at the free Find My Past website. The transcription spells Daniel’s last name as, “O’Keeffe,” and Hannah’s first name as, “Hanna.” I haven’t included the Find My Past marriage transcription in this reply as it is under copyright. But attached to the transcription is a link that takes you to a copy of the original Ballymacoda and Ladysbridge marriage record held by the National Library of Ireland located on Kildare Street in Dublin.
You can access the marriage record at: https://registers.nli.ie//registers/vtls000632384#page/18/mode/1up
You’ll see two facing page of the marriage register The marriage for Daniel and Hanna is on the right-hand page, 8th entry up from the bottom of the register. You can enlarge the page by means of round icons in the upper center/ right of the screen. The icons are white with green backgrounds. You can also access the full-screen function by clicking on the last icon on the right with the two arrows pointing northeast and southwest.
The witnesses to the marriage appear to be Js. (James) Connell and Hugh Hannan. J. Eagar would have been the priest who married Daniel and Hannah. Marriages traditionally took place in the bridge’s parish, though the bride and groom did not necessarily come from either the towns of Ballymacoda or Ladysbridge, but may have lived in one of the surrounding towns. More on this later.
A Google Map shows there are Catholic Churches in both Ballymacoda and Ladysbridge. They are 4.8 miles from each other along the R633 secondary Road. You can view the map at: https://is.gd/YiZWHR
The marriage record for Daniel and Hanna isn’t clear as to the church that Daniel and Hanna were married in. They could have been married in the Ballymacoda Catholic Church or the Catholic Church in Ladysbridge, called St. Mary’s. Based on evidence you’ll see later, I suspect they may have been married in the St. Mary’s Catholic Church in Ladysbridge .
An Ordnance Survey Map from the GeoHive website shows the location of the R.C. Chapel in Ballymacoda. This map is from the 1837 to 1841 time period. See the map at: http://bit.ly/2AQEZkA
Another Ordnance Survey Map from the 1837 to 1841 time period also shows the location of an R.C. Chapel in Ladysbridge. This map also comes from the GeoHive website: http://bit.ly/2ASxWrN
Next I found the baptism records for three children of Daniel Keeffe and Hanora/Hanagh/Hannah Connell. These children, and their years of baptism are:
Mary Keeffe, 1859
James Keeffe, 1864
Hannah Keeffe, 1867
____
The three children were baptized in the Imogeela Catholic Parish, which borders on the Ballymacoda and Ladysbridge Catholic Parish. You can see the location of both Catholic Parishes at the National Library of Ireland link at: https://registers.nli.ie/parishes/0059
The Imogeela Catholic Parish was also called Castlemartyr. Castlemartyr is only 1.1 miles north of St. Mary’s Catholic Church in Ladysbridge: https://is.gd/XWBgTY
Mary Keeffe was baptized on 17 November 1859. Her baptism record is the 3rd entry up from the bottom of the left-hand baptism register page at: https://registers.nli.ie//registers/vtls000634049#page/106/mode/1up
Mary’s godparents are Jas. Connell and Eliza, whose last name is blurred. To the right of Liza’s blurred last name you’ll see the abbreviation, “CMart,” which means the Keeffe family were living in Castlemartyr at the time Mary was baptized.
James Keeffe was baptized on 12 June 1864. His baptism is the 5th entry down from the top of the right-hand baptism register page at: https://registers.nli.ie//registers/vtls000634049#page/123/mode/1up
James’s godfather is John Hemming or Flemming. The first name of the godmother is Mary. Her last name appears to be Gould, but I could be wrong. The address of the family is Castlemartyr.
Hannah Keeffe was baptized on 25 March 1867. Her baptism is the last entry on the left-hand register page at: https://registers.nli.ie//registers/vtls000634049#page/132/mode/1up
The first name of Hannah’s godfather is Michael, whose last name may be Newman. The godmother’s name appears to be Prudence Coleman.
I then found that Daniel and Hannah had a son named William who was baptized in the Ballymacoda and Ladysbridge Catholic Parish. William was baptized on 28 March 1870. In the baptism record William’s first name is abbreviated as, “Wm.” His baptism record is on the right-hand register page, 7th entry down from the top of the page at: https://registers.nli.ie//registers/vtls000632385#page/89/mode/1up
The names of William godparents appear to be Daniel Walsh and Margaret Flynn. The parish priest who baptized William was A. Ahern.
Also Janet I uncovered the civil registration birth records for three of the four children of Daniel and Hannah named above. These records were found at the irishgeealogy.ie website. Civil Registration of births, marriages, and deaths for all religious denominations began in Ireland in 1864. There isn’t a birth record for Mary, who was born in 1859, five years before the implementation of Civil Registration.
The birth record for the three O’Keefe children are attached to this reply.
I’ll go over each birth record with you below:
James O’Keeffe was born on June 4, 1864 in Castlemartyr. His father is Daniel O’Keeffe, a bootmaker. James’s mother is Hannah O’Keeffe, formerly “O Connell.” Daniel OKeeffe, “father of child,” residing in Castlemartyr, reported the birth to the local registrar, Thomas Sandiford, who recorded the birth in the Middleton Registration District on June 20, 1864. James’s birth is entry number 49 on the birth register.
Earlier, you saw that James was baptized on 12 June 1864.
You also saw that his younger sister Hannah was baptized on 25 March 1867. Her birth record shows she was born in Castlemartyr on March 22, 1867. In the birth record her first name is recorded as “Honora.” Her father is Daniel O’Keeffe, residing in Castlemartyr. Daniel’s occupation is shoemaker. Honora’s mother is “Johanna” O’Keeffe, formerly “O Connell.” Mary Keefe of Castlemartyr was present at the birth and reported the birth to the local registrar. Mary may have been Johanna’s sister, mother, or perhaps cousin. The Registrar, Thomas Sandiford recorded the birth in the Middleton Registration District on March 28, 1867. Honora’s birth record is item number 364 on the birth register.
You also saw earlier that William was baptized on 28 March 1870. In the birth record his last name is recorded as “Keeffe.” He was born in Castlemartyr on March 28 1870, the same day as his baptism. His father is Daniel Keeffe, a shoemaker who had lived in Castlemartyr, but who was deceased when William was born. William’s mother is Hannah Keeffe, formerly Connell. Ellen Day, of Ladysbbridge, was present at the birth and reported the birth to the local registrar, Thomas Sanndiford. Thomas Sandiford recorded William’s birth in the Middleton Registration District on March 31 1870. William’s birth is item number 213, which is the last birth recorded on the register.
Janet, based on the civil registration birth records above, especially the 1870 birth record for William, which notes that his father Daniel was deceased, I would say that the Daniel O’Keefe and Hannah Connell who
Lived in Boston, and who were your direct ancestors, were not the same Daniel and Hannah who married in the Ballymcoda and Ladysbridge Catholic Parish in 1859, and who had lived in nearby Castlemartyr. Then again too, the 1900 U.S. census shows that Hannah Keefe had four children, and as we know, all four children were born in the U.S. based on the 1880 census.
If however, you still think that your ancestors Daniel O’Keefe and Hannah Connell were the same people who had married in the Ballymacoda and Ladysbridge Catholic Church, I hope you have a fantastic and memorable time time visiting Ballymacoda and Ladysbridge in County Cork. For a Google Street View of the Catholic Church in Ballymacoda, go to: https://is.gd/jP3DUX
For a Google Street View of St. Mary’s Church in Ladysbridge, see: https://is.gd/tKWci7
If you are renting a car in Ireland you may also want to consider visiting the west coast of County Cork, where I think you’ll see fantastic views of the coastline. Many of the coastline views can be seen at: https://is.gd/xCGKjb
With best wishes for a great trip to Ireland,
Dave