Margie:
Welcome to Ireland Reaching Out!
I checked Roots Ireland and a Find My Past RC parish register data base and the only record I can find is an 1847 John McDonnell born to Michael McDonnell and Mary Nelson in the Clonrush/Mountshannon/Whitegate RC parish. See below. Here is a link to the register http://registers.nli.ie/parishes/0773 This parish is mostly in Co. Clare with a small portion in Co. Galway. Roots transcribed the townland as Kilrateera which is in Inishcaltra parish.
I would treat this record as a lead. There are some parishes in Clare that do not have records back to this period.
Do you have any other information on the family?
Roger McDonnell
D
First name(s)JohnLast nameMcdonnellBirth year-Baptism year1847Baptism date23 Jul 1847ParishClonrushAlternative parish namesMountshannon, WhitegateDioceseKillaloeCountyClare, GalwayCountryIrelandFather's first name(s)MlFather's last nameMcdonnellMother's first name(s)MaryMother's last nameNolsonRepositoryNational Library of IrelandNational Library of Ireland linkhttp://registers.nli.ie//registers/vtls000634685#page/1/mode/1upRegisterBaptism