Stacy,
OK. That information is all very helpful. Turning to Griffiths Valuation, I can see Hugh Logan?s farm in Creagh in 1862. He had plot 3 which was a farmhouse, outbuildings and just over 8 acres of landed, which he rented from the O?Neill estate at Shane?s Castle in Randalstown. That?s in a V formed by the modern Whitesides Rd and Glebe Rd, a couple of miles north of Randalstown, between Randalstown and Ahoghill. Looking at the follow on revaluation records, Hugh was replaced by a Thomas Hill in 1880. (There?s a death that might be Hugh regd in Ballymena 2nd May 1884, aged 71).
http://www.askaboutireland.ie/griffith-valuation/index.xml
http://applications.proni.gov.uk/dcal_proni_val12b/ImageResult.aspx
In 1998 a William Logan arrived nearby on plot 10 (a 15 acre farm), but whether he is connected to Hugh is not something I can immediately say. More research would be required to find out. Looking at the 1901 census, here?s that later famr:
http://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/pages/1901/Antrim/Clohogue/Creagh/925025/
And in 1911, when Francis has replaced Hugh:
http://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/pages/1911/Antrim/Cloghogue/Creagh/116138/
Likewise, in Griffiths I can see Andrew Nicholl listed in Procklis. He had plot 8 which was a farmhouse, outbuildings and 16 acres. Procklis and Creagh share a common boundary and so it?s easy to see how John & Margaret met. They obviously lived within a few hundred yards of each other. Procklis is situated around Whitesides Corner, where the Glebe and Whitesides Rd intersects. The exact location of both the Logan and Nicholl farms is not shown on-line. However it is possible to find them using other copies of the townland maps held in the local studies section at Ballymena Library, should you ever wish to do so.
The revaluation records show that Andrew Nicholl left in 1867 when he was replaced by John Small. I can see tow Andrew Nicholl deaths regd in Ballymena, which might refer to your Andrew. 1796 to 1873 and 1798 to 1877. (I?d try the earlier one first).
John Nicholl?s house isn?t listed in Griffiths but that is probably because as a weaver, he?d be staying in a property too small to be listed. I would expect him to have been somewhere on his father?s farm.
In 1901 there were these two Nicholl households in the townland:
http://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/pages/1901/Antrim/Clohogue/Prockles/925104/
http://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/pages/1901/Antrim/Clohogue/Prockles/925109/
There?s also this gravestone in Ahoghill 1st Presbyterian church graveyard, which looks to relate to your family, and which gives you John & Margaret?s dates of death, as well as the fact that two of their sons died young.:
?Erected by Margaret Jane Nicholl, Prockless, in memory of her father John Nicholl died 20th July 1910 aged 85 years Also her mother Margaret died 10th March 1910 aged 82 years Also her brothers William died 23rd Feb 1870 aged 9 years Alexander died 24th April 1873 aged 9 years?.
Although the address given for John and Margaret is Procklis, the 1901 census makes it clear they weren?t actually living there. In fact, this seems to be them in 1901:
http://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/pages/1901/Antrim/Clohogue/Ballymacilroy/924957/
This is Margaret Jane, living alone in 1911. She?s in Creagh:
http://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/pages/1911/Antrim/Cloghogue/Creagh/116140/
John Nicholl didn?t leave a will (or again not one that was probated anyway). I have no idea what happened to Margaret Jane. There was a Mgt Jane who died on 12.8.1962 aged 80 who might be her. (The age is out but the age on a death certificate was often incorrect, being just the informant?s best guess). She died intestate, in Craignageeragh. Probate abstract:
Nicholl, Margaret of Craignageeragh Ahoghill county Antrim spinster died 12 August 1962 Administration Belfast 7 May to Isabella Nicholl spinster. Effects ?59.
I noted this family in Craignageeragh in 1901, whom I suspect may be linked to yours in some way. It?s a John & Margaret Ann with a son named David Logan Nicholl.
http://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/pages/1901/Antrim/Ahoghill/Craignageeragh/923939/
I know from your initial post that you are hopeful of finding living descendants. There may be some in the area. Your problem is really that most people here aren?t that interested in their ancestry and if you ask them about it, they can only go back 3 generations and that?s about it. So they get back to their grandparents c 1910 and then they are stuck. They might be related to John Nicholl or Mgt Logan but they won?t know. Bridging the gap between your ancestors departure and more modern relations can be difficult.
Andrew Nicholl seems to have died in the 1870s, or thereabouts. He doesn?t appear to have left a will 9 or at least not one that was probated). I can?t find a gravestone for him. So apart from your John, I don?t know of any of his family. John?s surviving children in Ireland seem to have consisted of John b c 1873 and Mgt Jane who was evidently still alive and unmarried in 1911.
Elwyn