William O'Connor - NZ to Youghal, Cork
I have been searching for the Irish origins of my great-grandfather William O'Connor (d 1918), of Le BonsBay, Canterbury, New Zealand for 30 years, and believe thatI may have found his origins in Youghal, Cork. Unfortunately, the NZ records only give hisplace of origin as "County Cork". My reasoning for identifying Youghal as his place of origin is detailed below. I would be grateful if someone would review my reasoning and the evidence I have gathered, and let me have any comments on whether my conclusions are reasonable.
Many thanks, Robert O'Connor
_________________
WILLIAM O'CONNOR, of Le Bons Bay, Canterbury, New Zealand., Bapt. 18 Oct. 1851 at Youghal, County Cork recorded in the Catholic Church register as William Connors, son of Michael Connors & Bridget [sic thought to be an error for Mary] Callaghan, Back Street; sponsors Thomas Callaghan & Johanna Meade. That the William Connors who was baptised at Youghal in 1851 was the same person as William OConnor (d 1918) of Le Bons Bay, New Zealand is evidenced by the following: (1) It was reported in the Lyttelton Times after the death of William OConnor in 1918 as follows Deceasedwas a native of Cork, went to sea in his early youth, & came to New Zealand in 1874, settling at Le Bons Bay; (2) In Ireland the Registrar-General of Shipping & Seamen was responsible for keeping the records of the Irish merchant navy, & those records from 1860 to 1921 survive & are held by the National Archives of Ireland. Every Year, each ship registered in Ireland had to submit a report to the Registrar-General & the records kept were extensive & provide detailed information concerning each crew member, including their ages & places of birth. Five Irish seamen named William Connor(s) were recorded as having served on Irish merchant ships in the period between 1860 & 1874 (the latter date being when William OConnor (d 1918) was known to havearrived in New Zealand) & as being born in County Cork in the period between 1847 & 1857 (from the age William OConnor gave when he was admitted to hospital in Akaroa immediately before his death in 1918 he was born in either 1851 or 1852). Of those five, three (William, born between 1847 & 1854 at Kinsale; William, born between 1847 & 1851 at Cork City; & William, born 1847 at Whitegate) were all recorded as serving on Irish merchant ships sailing from Ireland after 1874 & thus could not be the same person as William OConnor (d 1918) who arrived in New Zealand in that year. The remaining two were: (a) William Connor(s), who was recorded as being born in 1851 or 1852 at Youghal, County Cork, & as sailing on his first ship when aged 15 in 1866; & (b) William Connor, who was recorded as being born in 1847 at Castletownshend, County Cork, & as sailing on his first ship when aged 16 in 1863. Given that William OConnor (d 1918) was recorded as aged 66 at his admission to Akaroa Hospital immediately before his death in Nov. 1918 (& thus was born in 1851 or 1852), it is concluded that he was,therefore, the same person as the merchant seaman William Connor(s) recorded in the Irish Registrar-General of Shipping & Seamen records as being born at Youghal, County Cork in 1851 or 1852, & not the William Connor born in 1847 at Castletownshend; (3) The baptism for William Connors recorded at Youghal in Oct. 1851 as son of Michael Connors & Bridget [sic] Callaghan substantially accords with the record of the parents of William OConnor (d 1918) in his 1883 marriage certificate as Michael Connors & Mary Callaghan, with the exception that his mother is named as Bridget in the baptismal register rather than as Mary in the marriage certificate; & (4) The DNA test taken in 2018 by Robert OConnor, a great-grandson of William OConnor (d 1918), has established DNA matches for Robert with persons (Sarah OShea & Sheila Kenny) related to him via William OConnor (d 1918) whose immediate ancestors were born at Youghal.
