Fáilte to the IrelandXO Roscommon Community!
That you know the Gormelys came from the townland of Bellanagare, is fortunate. (Bellanagare as an address could also mean the wider Electoral District OR the town as well.)
In 1749, a Lawrence Gormely & wife, servants, (with 4 children under the age of 14: Thomas, Edward ...) were recorded in the townland Carrowreagh, Kilcorkey just south east of the town of Bellanagare [Census of Elphin].
In 1777, a Thomas Gormly erected a memorial to his father, Lawrence Gormley (1711-1777), interred at Kilcorkey cemetery. This Thomas Gormely, born circa 1745, to afford a gravestone for his father, had a stronger source of income than most.
In 1830, a Thomas Gormley had 3 titheable acres in the townland of Balliagare ... all the signs of poverty, until you discover he was a freeholder ...
In 1832, Thomas Gormly of Ballenagar (parish of Kilcorkey, barony of Ballintobber, Co. Roscommon) farmer (with a house and land at Ballinagare) freeholder (annual value of £10) applied to the voters' register.
Source: Roscommon Journal, and Western Impartial Reporter - Friday 14 December 1832
In 1843, Thomas Gormely of Bellanagare applied for a Poverty relief loan of £2 at Frenchpark Loan Fund Society. His guarrantors were Edward Gormely of Bellanagare and Paul Casserly of #1a Kilcorkey (8 acres). Earlier that year Edward had twice applied for loans at Frenchpark, his guarrantors being the same Thomas Gormely (signed "X - his mark") and Paul Casserly.
In 1853, Thomas Gormely is recorded in the Village of Bellanagare at house #19 (& yard) "rent free - an old lease" and as the leaseholder of house #20. This too would suggest this man had been around for some while.
In 1857, this house (value £1 5s) and land (3 acres), can be found in the name of Thomas Gormely [Griffith's Valuation]. We can see he was residing at the crossroads in the Village of Bellanagare (house #19) and held the lease to two additional houses, adjoining (# 20 and # 21) which he sub-let to other tenants. His farmland, at #6, was just north of the village, opposite Bellanagare Castle.
There are no civil death records for this Thomas Gormely, presumably deceased in the late 1850s.
To track what became of the Gormely holdings here (to whom the lease was passed on, e.g. a son-in-law) check out the Griffith's Valuation Cancellation Books in Dublin [to avoid having to visit, e-mail: VALOFF who can post you photocopies for a nominal fee].
This will help you determine the date of Thomas's death and if you had any cousins (along a married daughter's line) appearing in the 1901 Census in Bellanagare.
COSTELLO + GORMLY
For surname spelling variations, click here for Costello (e.g. McCostelloe) and here for Gormley (e.g. Grimely)
By 1857 (Griffith's Valuation), there is no apparent crossover of the Costello & Gormly surnames in this area. (There were 3 Costello household(s) in Tibohine parish (Frenchpark) in 1857. And no similar result for Gormly).
What I do know is that there were Costello blacksmiths in a neighbouring parish, and as these tradesmen often migrated by invitation across parishes (so you might keep 'blacksmith' in the back of your mind). However, it seems that the 2 forges in Kilcorky parish were run by Maxwell (in Peak) and Tigue.
CEMETERIES
For Kilcorkey Parish cemeteries see: Kilcorkey cemetery; Bellinagare Old Church (opened 1819); and Bellanagare/Drummin. (Ballincool burial ground is no more thn 3 mounds of earth).
For Costello, I think you may have to cast your net wider. (See Tithe Records 1825-30)
For others cemeteries further afield, check out this handy map by Roscommon County Council.
A great many cemetery headstones have been added to the IGP online heastone repository, so you can at least get some groundwork done before you go (you can search the records by text file for your chosen surname).
You might also find these surnames mentioned if you dig through the Ballinagare local history and folklore records at Duchas.
ORIENTATION
You will find Bellanagare north-east of the town of Castelrea, near Frenchpark, in the parish of Kilcorkery. The Barony for Bellanagare is now "Castlereagh" but in the early 19th Century Ballinagar fell under Ballintobber.
For Catholic Parish Records look to what is now called the Catholic Parish of Frenchpark (mapped here). Before your trip it will be helpful to get familiar with the possible townland names your ancestors may also appear on record in.
You may wish to contact the Bellanagare Parish priest to find out what local records may be available (in terms of offline parish records and/ or burial sites) beyond this list.
There's a chance that Ballinagar Tidy Towns group may also have member(s) well up on the local history of this town. Moraghan's Bar in Bellanagare is steeped in local history and may also be a source of contacts.
For more on orientation, check out leitrim-roscommon.com
OFFLINE REPOSITORIES
Do contact Roscommon County Library to find out what may be available to you only there or at local branches. There you can access Roscommon newspaper archives and a range of material not available online. They should be able to tell you, by e-mail, if records have survived for the period and area pertinent to you.
ESTATE RECORDS
Naturally, a visit to the house of your ancestors' landlord will be something you will want to do. Lucky for you, Clonalis House is open to the public for day visits. The tenancy / estate records for landlord Charles Owen O'Connor Don of Ballinagre might also be accessible there (why not e-mail them to see if that is possible?)
Also, don't miss a visit to Strokestown House for more insights.
Last, but not least, I strongly recommend you join IrelandXO's Kilcorkey civil parish group in addition to the surrounding parishes. Also, edit (or consolidate) all your previous messages here to include the parish of Kilcorkey.
Best of luck!