Roger, Miriam, and Margot
Thank you for the quick and informative reply!
Roger, Is headquarters in Galway? My scheduled has me visiting there a few days after I will be in Co. Tipperary.
I will make a point to try to pinpoint Glingaden and Gortnaskehy (Gornaskeha) during my visit. This is very exciting for me. I appreciate any geographical coaching as the parishes and townships are foreign to me. Miriam, thank you for the address hint.
You mentioned Nathanial Pennefather Sadlier but that seems to be a middle name which may suggest his mother may have had a Pennefather surname, perhaps.
You wouldn't have found an Ireland death record for my Nathanial Pennefather because he emigrated with his wife and children to the US in 1850. We know his wife as Eliza but the ship "Albert Gallatin" records and New York Immigration records list his wife as Elleanor (35). I've also seen Mary Eleanor. His children were listed on the ship register as John (14), Johanna (12), Anne (10), Thomas (7), and an infant but I show their youngest as Catherine who would have been 5 yrs in 1850.
Margot, thank you for the research and direct links to the Griffith Valuation maps. I don't know how to reference the map number noted on the Valuation record; I did noticed one record has Nathanial Pennefather, Esq. as an "occupier" to the immediate Lessor Viscount Hawardin (map 2) and another line has Nathanial as a "lessor" of occupier Thomas Dwyer (map 1); what does this mean? Do you know exactly what year that particular record in the Griffins Valuation was recorded? I want to make sure it wasn't after 1850; then we would know if it is for a different Nathanial Pennefather.
The MARLOW reference on my Ancestry tree I believe was from another person's tree so I cannot speak for that accuracy. I will search for a source of that and the Clonoulty 5319 reference.
I saw a Pennefather history in Co. Tipperary at the link below and see a Marlow reference there so maybe that lead to an assumption by someone on their tree on Ancestry.com. I do not yet have a traced connection to the Pennefathers note below but it seems likely given the surname and county.
http://landedestates.nuigalway.ie/LandedEstates/jsp/family-show.jsp?id=2536
Finaly, Johanna Pennefather's husband, Dennis Whelan, was supposedly baptized in Laois, Ireland. Where would I look for records for that? I have June 10, 1832 as his date of birth. I have no information so far regarding his parents or siblings.
Sincere gratitude to all!