Dear Mr. Roger McDonnell,
Thanks for getting back to me so quickly. I'm not sure if this is my grandfather but I believe it may be him. I have his birthday on a union membership card as July 30,1885, born in Valencia Ireland. But that was when he was 57 years of age after living a long time in New York City, so memories can change. I looked at the 1901 Irish census and it lists a Timothy as 17 years of age, which, as you say, would make his birth year as 1884. I notice in the 1901 census that the house is listed as 36 in Reenard (Caher,Kerry). Would this location be near Valencia Island? I see in the 1911 census that it appears the mother and father and one son (William) had moved to 17 in Reenard (Caher, Kerry). Again, would people refer to these locations as Valencia Island? On the records of Ellis Island, New York there is a Timothy O'Neill, who arrived on the Adriatic on May 16th 1907 at the age of 23. It is listed that his last place of residence was Valencia Harbour, Ireland. Again that goes back to the 1884 date. Technically he would not have been 23 until July. However, I'm not so sure things were that precise on Ellis Island in 1907. Another interesting note, I did see another Timothy O'Neill, age 23, arriving in Ellis Island two weeks earlier on April 27th, 1907 on the Lucania. This Timothy O'Neill listed his last place of residence as Cahersiveen, Ireland, I believe this is very close to Valencia, so I don't know. If my grandfather did arrive in 1907, that would agree why he wasn't listed on the 1911 census in Reenard.
Thank you again for your time, quick response and your help. My ultimate goal would be to apply for Irish citizenship, which would be a very proud moment for me and my family. Any assistance is greatly appreciated. Sincerely yours, Tim O'Neill