Back to Message Board

Two sisters both called Mary?

Cornelius HEALY & Mary ENRIGHT, who married in Rathkeale Co. Limerick in 1855, were my great great grandparents. Cornelius is most likely the one born to Thomas HAILY (the variant spelling is in keeping) & Catherine COSGROVE in Ballyhea Co. Cork in 1834. A Mary ENRIGHT was born in nearby Charleville to Thomas & Catherine TROY in 1831. This fitted very well with the known age of Mary, and when I discovered a brother, John, known to have been born in Charleville and also of the right age, I thought I was home and dry. All the pieces seemed to fit and fall neatly into place.

However, I've recently made a discovery that has blown this tidy theory right out of the water, with nothing else at all on the horizon. Another Mary seems to have been born to the same couple in 1844. This would be far too young for my Mary. The only explanation I can think of is that the earlier Mary must have died, and couldn't possibly have been the Mary who married my Cornelius. Or can anyone think of some other explanation to keep my theory afloat?

Chris Power

9 replies

Chris:

I can't come up with another obvious explanation for the two Marys other than your explanation about the death of the first Mary. I did look at Roots Ireland and there are many Mary Enright baptismal records in Limerick and Cork including five in Rathkeale RC parish between 1834-1836. 

Roger McDonnell

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Chris, I have come across a few instances in my family where a younger child died and then a later addition to the family was given the same name.  So very possible.

 

Maria Smyth

maria.smyth

Thanks Roger - I have looked at many of the possibilities for Mary Enright but no-one seems to fit so neatly with the right age, a younger brother John, and some connection to either Rathkeale or Charleville. But I guess there must be another Mary somewhere and I'll have to reassess the "facts" of the case.

And thanks too for your reply, Maria. I have several instances in my own family also of names of dead siblings being recycled. What I was hoping for were instances where both children survived, perhaps as a result of the older sibling leaving home or being brought up by someone else. But perhaps that's too far-fetched, and I'm striving too hard to keep my former theory alive!

Anyway, thanks again for you help.

Chris Power

Chris:

You may want to consider autosomal DNA testing.

Roger

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Yes, Roger, I did that a few years back. It led to a major breakthrough on one branch, more questions than answers on others, and nothing at all on this particular branch. But I think you're right and I'll have to let this Mary Enright go. It's hard to lop off a part of my tree that had seemed done and dusted. Ah well ... back to the spreadsheets!

Chris Power

Thanks for that glimmer of hope Lilly. That's very interesting. I went back and checked the original images but there was no second name at birth. Even that doesn't necessarily rule it out because my father's family had a tendency to be known by anything but their birth names, even though those names never appeared on any certificate. However, I think I'm stretching my theory beyond its limit of plausibility, and I'll have to look elsewhere ... although the prospects do look a bit bleak.

Chris Power

hi Chris, I have 2 sisters named Margaret.  It was so important to name the first girl after the maternal grandmother Margaret (as was always Irish Tradition.........1st son after paternal grandfather, 1st daughter after maternal granddaughter, 2nd son after maternal grandfather and 2nd daughter after paternal grandfather.....then you start working on the aunts and uncles.  My first sister Margaret died in an accident and my mother could not wait to get another baby girl to call her Margaret.    I had a friend once who also had two sisters named Margaret.......her Mum was not aware that Rita and Margaret were the same name.       Another big reason that there might be 2 Marys in a family is if the mother was failing to produce babies she might pray to the Virgin Mary and promise to call the baby after her if she did have another little girl, and one would be called Mary and the other might have been called May, Molly or the Irish version of Mary which is Maire....................hope this helps...........Graiguegirl

IrelandXO member

sorry Chris............forgot 2 other reasons I know of.........my mother sent someone up to register her baby girl as Kathleen...but a note on the birth certificate reads....CALLED CHILD MARY AS MOTHER ALREADY HAS A KATHLEEN .....and was signed by the registrar.   The other thing to know is that children of emigrants and those who were illegitimate were often reared by aunts and grandparents.  I once knew a family to have two Bettys.    a lot of information to take in but useful I hope..............Graiguegirl

IrelandXO member

Thanks Graiguegirl - yes, a lot to take in. My grandmother was named Margaret Daly in 1889, and I have never fathomed why the next baby, who was born dead the following year, was also baptised as Margaret, with the other Margaret only a year old and still living. I also know that my grandfather delayed registering my mother's birth until after the permitted period and so adjusted her birthday accordingly. Throughout her life she had to remember the false date for all official documents, as I did myself on her death certificate. And my other grandfather, who had assumed a double-barreled surname, Conyngham-Power, included this when registering some of his children but not others, I suppose as the mood took him. Some children were then filed under "C" and others under "P". So, yes, there are many reasons why the birth registrations may not tell the whole story.

But in my scenario, Mary One was born a year after the marriage, so no obvious reason for being given a transfer; and there were already three girls in the family, so no desperation for another. Mary One would have been 13 when Mary Two was born - perhaps old enough to have left home and be working away, but not something I could assume without good reason. What is frustrating is that Mary Two did not show up at all on the Ancestry search. This was because of sloppy transcription, which I'm afraid is very prevalent on the Ancestry site. But she is there on the RootsIreland search, so there is no getting away from it.

Anyway, thanks for those interesting anecdotes.

(By the way, I live in Wales and my mother-in-law is called Mair, and "graig" is the word for "rock".)

Chris Power

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.