Back to Message Board

Too many Patrick Callahans

The only place of origin I have for my GGF is "Ireland" from several US Census records. I am not aware of any old family documents that mention him, and his origin is not mentioned in local histories of areas where he lived. All my research has been done on line and through local genealogical societies where he lived. Without some credible record in the US linking him to a locality in Ireland, there are too many people with similar names and ages for me to claim that any of them is my relative.
His name was Patrick Callahan, born about 1825 (most common inference in US census records, but nothers are seen, too); to parents Denis and Ellen (no maiden name given) according to his 1881 death record information given by one of his sons. If correct, this father's name is at odds with naming traditions because my GGF's first son was named Eugene, not Denis.

In one US census the family name is shown as O'Callahan, but it is just Callahan before and after that. This oddity might have been a census taker's mistake, and Patrick could not have corrected it because he was illiterate. There is a clear example of this in another census where the family name is recorded as Kielleham.

In my online seach of Irish records I have come across just one christening with the right combination of given names and a date near the 1825 seen elsewhere;this one in 1819 in Ballvourney, Cork, with the family name Callaghan and the mother as Ellen Donohue. But the online records are not exhaustive, the year is different, and I have nothing else to confirm or disprove it.

Searches of Irish christening records for other children of a Denis and Ellen in the 1815 to1835 period have turned up a son Jeremiah christened in Ballyvourney and then a family living a few miles away in Clondrohid patrish, maybe Garranagapul per one christening record;with10 children, the oldest two being Patrick and Jeremiah. If she was from Ballyvourney and he had property in Clondrohid, this would be consistent with what I have read about new mothers often going back to their birth homes for the birth (and christening) of their first one or two children, and thenhaving the rest at their marriage homes.

I don't know where or when my GGFarrived in North America (too many with same name and similar age), nor whether he migrated alone or with a group.

Working backwards through US census and state birth records, the earliest confident* record I have for him is his Catholic marriage in 1853 in Chicopee, Hampden, Massachusetts, to Margaret Sweeney.No ages ar given in the image of the marriage record, but she was born in Ireland about 1830 per later censuses. It was his first marriage and her second.Presumably she was a young widow, not a divorcee, because this was a Catholic wedding andthey were also buried in a Catholic cemetery.

  • I don't know if Sweeney was her birth name or the name of her first husband. At the time of the marriage she already had a daughter, Johanna, who was born in 1849 in New York state. I have not found any trace of this combination of mother and daughter names and ages with any surname in 1850 censuses in New York or Massachusetts.
  • * There also is an 1850 census record for a Patrick Callahan, age 25 (doesn't match the Ballyvourney christening), living in a boarding house in a town very near Chicoppee, and two of the other four boarders are Jerry Callahan, 30 (the Clondrohid Jeremiah was younger, not older than his brother Patrick), and Eugene Callahan, 21 (no Eugenes in the family in Clondrohid). But other than the naming of his first son Eugene, I have not seen anything in Patrick's life to connect him to these other Callahans. All this means that if this Patrick is the one who married Margaret in 1853, he is NOT fromthe family in Clondrohid.

Patrick and Margaret had several more children, all sons: Eugene in 1854, John A. in 1856, Joseph Luke (my GF) in 1860, William H. in 1863, and Dennis in 1865. If Patrick's father's name really was Denis, then the family was not following naming traditions.

Patrick and his family migrated from Massachusetts to Wisconsin in about 1855, and then on to Minnesota in about 1865. This can be seen in the birthplaces of the children in census data and in land records.
Another researcher cites this migration to claim that there must be a family relationship between my Patrick Callahan and this researcher's ancestor, Anthony Callahan, born about 1830 in Ireland. He bases the claim on the fact that his Anthony has some family connection to and spends several years before his marriage living with a family of Linnihan's who made the same migrations as my Callahans, and that the families lived within a few miles of each other from the 1850s onward. These Linnihans come from Donaghmore, Cork. He feels that his conclusion is reinforced by the fact that Anthony has a Eugene Callahan as best man at his wedding in 1877, but the age difference in 1877 (his Anthony 47 and my Patrick's son Eugene 24) make me wonder if this is the Eugene in my family, or perhaps the Eugene (age 52 in 1877) seen livivng with a Patrick in that 1850 census.
I find all this researcher's conclusions curious but not convincing, and include it in case it is useful to you.

colojoe

3 replies

colojoe:

Welcome to Ireland Reaching Out!

Almost 40% of the Callaghans (this was the predominant spelling) in the mid-19th century Griffiths Valuation were found in Co. Cork. Co. Cork church records are split between two sites: www.irishgenealogy.ie (Diocese of Cork and Ross) and Roots Ireland (Diocese of Cloyne). I did not find any other Patrick Callahan/Callaghan records with denis and Ellen as parents after looking at those sites. As you indicated, not all churches have records back to the 1820s.

You may want to consider autosomal DNA testing. Possibly you will match someone who has Callahan/Callaghan connections and has moe specifics on the origins of the family.

Roger McDonnell

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Disappointing but interesting to hear so quickly that someone else has looked and not found anything.

I have done DNA testing at Family tree DNA and uploaded the results to GEDmacth.com - full mtDNA, Family Finder atDNA and 67 marker Y-DNA, the last of which led to the correct suggestion that I try for terninal SNP R1b...CTS4466...A923. That Y haplogroup has only eight other people on GEDmatch so far, and none are Callahans. Only a couple of the possible autosomal matches have trees for comparison with names, and those ony one surname even close to any of mine.

Thanks for the feedback,

Joe Callahan

colojoe

I have some Donegal Callahans and also some Donegal Callaghans.

My ggrandmother was Annie Callahan, daughter of James and Mary Doherty Callahan.  James was a mason from Tirargus.  He'd have been born between 1830 and 1850.  Annie, the oldest (as far as we know) was born in 1868.  She said she was from Letterkenny.  Her youngest sister Mary married John Callaghan, a butcher in Letterkenny.  John was the son of Henry, also a butcher, and Julia McLaughlin.  James died in 1873, registered in Millford. 

Annie had 2 other sisters, Bridget and Hannah, but no brothers.  We know nothing about James' family, or Mary Doherty's either. 

Just wanted to let you know that there were a few Calla(g)hans in Donegal.

Meg

MegMS

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.