Monty21,
Peter’s birth pre 1864 may be on the nli site. (The irishgenealogy site has some RC baptism records but none for Co Tyrone and adjacent counties). The problem with the nli site is that you need to know the parish and roughly when the person was born. Ancestry also has the records but you need a subscription to access them and there are some transcription errors.
Statutory birth and death registration started in Ireland in 1864. I searched for the death of a Peter Toal 1864 – 1887 and there’s none in the Dungannon registration area. So either he died before death registration started or he lived in a different part of Ireland. That combined with the fact that he’s not in Griffiths either (which I would expect for a farmer) makes me wonder if he was born elsewhere. If he came from Armagh then there are 2 deaths there that might fit. One in 1873 for someone aged 98 (a bit old perhaps) and another in 1865 for someone aged 64.
You can view the original certificates on-line on the GRONI website, using the “search registrations” option:
https://geni.nidirect.gov.uk
You will need to open an account and buy some credits. It costs £2.50 (sterling) to a view a certificate.
You haven’t said when Patrick was born exactly but I searched all statutory births for Patrick Toal 1864 – 1871, anywhere in Ireland. There were 11 but none had a father named Peter. I then searched RC baptisms on Ancestry and found 2 Patrick Toals born to a father named Peter. One was baptised in Dundalk on 17.11.1956 to Peter Toal and Anne Callan. The other was baptised 8.1.1865 in Upper Killevy, Co Armagh to Peter Toal and Ann Crowning. That latter birth should also have been registered but it wasn’t, so there’s no birth certificate. (About 10% of births weren’t registered in the early days of statutory registration in Ireland).
I think this might be your Peter because it’s in the right sort of area. (John Toal was born in Kilmore, Co Armagh).
I assume you have got Patrick’s mother’s name from a Scottish death certificate. If so, the information on there is only as complete as the informant’s knowledge. If he didn’t know Mary Ann’s maiden name, then it won’t be shown. It doesn’t necessarily mean they weren’t married. And her forenames might also be wrong. The informant may just have guessed.
Check all the Scottish censuses that Patrick appears in, particularly the 1911, as sometimes you get a specific location for place of birth as opposed to just “Ireland.”
You ask whether I think the family might be Scottish. No. The name Toal is pretty Irish to me. It’s common in Counties Antrim, Londonderry, Armagh and one or two other locations eg Co. Louth. I’d say they were Irish people who moved to Scotland for work, as tens of thousands from this area did at the time. Scotland was particularly popular because there was plenty of work there, it was cheap and easy to get to and you could come home to Ireland very easily in a way that you couldn’t if you went to the USA or Australia.
You ask about Bridget McCusker and who she was and where the birth took place. John was born at home in Kilmore. No maternity hospitals for poor folk then, and the majority of births were at home. Sometimes for a first child that might be the mother’s parents house (and that might well be the case here if Patrick was away working in Scotland). Bridget was a local nurse, and her townland was Keenaghan. Here she is in the 1901 census:
http://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/pages/1901/Armagh/Charlemont/Keenaghan/1012135/