7 replies
BJG:
Welcome to Ireland Reaching Out!
I don't think there is much we can do without more info on Edward Swinney. Sweeney is a very common surname in Ireland and is found in large numbers in Co. Cork and Co. Donegal and in smaller numbers in other counties.
You may want to consider autosomal DNA testing.
Roger McDonnell
I have tested with 23 and Me, but do not believe their gene pool is as large as perhaps the one on Ancestry.com, so I am considering being tested there also. Is there a more "popular" testing site for the Irish?
BjG:
Not aware of a more popular site for Irish descendants. You should also upload your raw DNA data to Gedmatch www.gedmatch.com Gedmatch is a volunteer run site where you can upload your DNA data and see if you match someone who tested with another company (and also loaded their data to Gedmatch).
Roger
BjG,
Roger's advice is very sound. Anecdotally I have been told that though Ancestry has massive database, a large percentage of their participants live outside Ireland so though you get lots of matches, they are mostly with others in the US, Canada or wherever. Family Tree DNA supposedly has more participants from Ireland, but I would suggest you verify that, if you can. I don’t have an authoritative source for that.
It’s probably worth bearing in mind that the level of interest in DNA testing in Ireland is not as great as that in other parts of the world (we know where our ancestors came from), and that no matter which company you go with, the number of matches in Ireland may not be that great.
Another thing is that people in Ireland and the British Isles weren’t static. They didn’t always live in the same place. The tests that supposedly tell you your ancestors were X% Irish & Y% English or whatever, are nonsense. There has been a huge amount of internal migration around the British Isles over the past 5000 years and so DNA tests are likely to produce matches all over the place. Taking Sweeney as a specific example, some of the Sweeneys in Ireland are known to have come from the Western Isles of Scotland in the 1300 and 1400s as gallowglass (mercenaries). They were given land by Irish tribes in Donegal and adjacent counties in return for fighting as required. That’s just one example, but a DNA test might therefore produce matches with people in Scotland and elsewhere, depending on where the Scots Sweeneys descendants moved to.
Elwyn / Roger,
Thanks for the input. Yes... the Scots are in the pipeline. Unfortunately, my Grandmother's Bible disappeared which had been past down through the ages. I suspect it was tossed and forever lost. I only wish I'd written down her many stories.
As far as posting to Gedmatch I'd have to handjam the data as there (to date) isn't an upload for 23 and Me. So I'm having to rely on old documentation, which does lead back to the 1600's, but from there I can't seem to make the jump. Therefore, I shall continue my search, and in 2018 my daughter and I plan on making the jump across the pond, and explore Ireland.
Again, kindly thanks for your replies.
BjG:
Keep us posted on yout trip.
Roger
The trip will be early July, landing in Dublin around the 6th. We'll spend 2-3 days there then strike out and about.
