Chris,
A problem that you face is that there are almost no records for Loughguile for the mid 1700s and so tracing this family will be difficult.
The oldest comprehensive records for that parish are the 1803 agricultural census. It lists 3 Speer (or variant spellings) households. William Speer in Ballyportery, Widow Spere in Lavin and Adam Sper in Turnagrove. The 1803 agricultural census is on Bill McAfee’s website: http://billmacafee.com
I next searched the tithe applotment records for 1832. They were compiled for taxation purposes and list all folk with land, so that’s mainly farmers. If there was a Speer in Loughguile still farming in the 1830s they ought to be listed. There is just one farm. There were no Speers farming in Lavin or Ballyportery by 1832 but Adam Spiers was still farming in Tournagrove (more commonly spelled Turnagrove):
http://www.irishgenealogyhub.com/antrim/tithe-applotments/loughguile-parish.php
Moving forward to Griffiths Valuation in 1861 there was just 1 Spears farm in that townland. That was John Spears who had plots 14 & 15 which was 36 acres of farmland plus some bog. That property today is up a lane off the A44 Drones Rd, a few miles south of Armoy. You can see exactly where it is using the maps on the Griffiths website:
http://www.askaboutireland.ie/griffith-valuation/index.xml?action=nameSearch
There was 1 Speers family farming there in 1901:
http://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/pages/1901/Antrim/Castlequarter/Turnagrove/944211/
1911:
http://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/pages/1911/Antrim/Castlequarter/Turnagrove/127821/
I cannot say that this family is connected to your family. Merely that it’s the only one I can find in the Loughguile area in the 20th century. The two other families, in Lavin & Ballyportery, clearly had either left or died out in the early 1800s.
The Turnagrove family were Presbyterian. The nearest Presbyterian church is probably Ballyweany. Their baptism records only start in 1862 and marriages in 1845. Presbyterians don’t generally keep burial records.
Ballyweaney Presbyterian graveyard’s gravestones have been transcribed. I searched the database but did not find any Speers graves there. So either the family didn’t have a gravestone or they were buried in a different graveyard. (Many Presbyterians were buried in Church of Ireland graveyards, for example).
I searched the internet and found reference to John Speers of Turnagrove being buried in Kilraghts Presbyterian graveyard. He died in 1881. So maybe that’s the place to search. Kilraghts 1st Presbyterian church has records from 1831 onwards.
http://www.arborealis.ca/resources/biographies/speer/speer-antrim/