Dear Miriam
Once again, I know that you are quite right—you can’t tell with a high degree of certainty whether the relationships that you ASSUME exists between 3rd or 4th cousins are necessarily tied to the common ancestors you think they are, but I have tried to “stack the deck” using as much available evidence as much as possible (please don’t laugh—I am an amateur!):
I have been building my family tree for many years now, and have found relatively closely related cousins the old-fashioned way: that is, I know the names of my grandparents and g-grandparents from family sources (that is, from my own parents and grandparents), and have managed to find cousins who have these same folks in their ancestry trees. I then have written to these folks and have been fortunate in that I’ve gotten many responses—not a PERFECT response rate, but enough—confirming the information from their own family knowledge, so that I know that these relationships are correct.
From there, I eventually submitted to a DNA test and have found that many of these same people were also tested: seeing that the matches I imagined were solid confirmed by DNA “hits” has given me a sense of confidence that I am on the right track.
I have created groups for each of the g-grandparents, which include members of these confirmed DNA matches. Ancestry.com is constantly identifying new matches: once a relatively close new match that is unfamiliar to me is tagged, I look to see the “shared matched” that exist. For example, if new match John Smith matches matches from my Dad’s side of the family—specifically also sharing common matches with his father’s mother (McGinnis)—I will then go into John Smith’s family tree to see if I can find the surnames that I believe could be our common point of connection. Understand, of course, that this occurs in a very small percentage of the identified connections—ther matches to date include something like 30,000 distant relatives and more like 500 relatively close relatives: my confirmed group is probably on the order of 100 individuals.
What I discovered with this system is that there are many people who SHOULD have matched through McGinnis ancestry, but don’t. Looking over the family trees for many, many of these, I eventually noticed that Lafferty was a common thread. I remembered the death record for Catherine McGinnis Keogh (which had “Brigid Caverty” listed as her mother), and came up with a new theory that this must have been Brigid Lafferty.
The ancestry DNA also suggests a relatively strong Donegal connection—I happen to know my Dad’s OTHER side as well as my mom’s entire ancestry (they are all from the center and West of Ireland), so my theory was that these McGinnis/Lafferty folks must’ve been from the North.
Again, not a perfect chain of logic, but this gave me a place to start. As I noted before, I was aware of this McGinnis family in NY that had precisely the same names as my grandfather’s siblings: it HAD to be the right one. What confused me terribly is that I couldn’t find any kind of paper trail for this family earlier than that 1860 record.
Of course you were able to discern that a marriage record did exist between Charles McGinnis and Biddy Lafferty dating from 8 Feb 1853, in Culdaff, Co. Donegal
Taken with all of this other evidence, I believe that Brigid Lafferty and Charles McGinnis are the parents of Catherine McGinnis, again, due to Catherine's death certificate.
However, I am not sure which of the the later children of Charles McGinnis--Mary (1858), John (1859), Charles (1860), Rose (1863), Agnes (1867) and a baby boy who perished--were the children of Charles McGinnis' second wife, Margaret Dougherty. The death records of Agnes and Mary indicate that they were the daughters of Charles McGinnis and Margaret Dougherty.
With your help, Irish records for the baptisms for the following children of Brigid Lafferty and Charles McGinnis have been identified:
Grace (baptised Nov 1860, residence Poenagh)
Margery (baptised Jan 1859, residence Bredagh Glen)
Mary (baptised Mar 1857, residence Poenagh)
Roseann (baptised Dec 1855, residence Bredagh Glen)
Catherine (baptised Jan 1854, residence Poenagh)
It’s odd that the baptism addresses go back and forth: I wonder whether this could have been two different families.
There is also this troublesome June 15 1860 NY census record for Charles McGinnis and whom I thought was his second wife, Margaret Dougherty--the family then consisted of Catherine (listed as 6), Mary (3) and John (10 months old)
This DOES appear to be the same family that appears in multiple census forms as Catherine, Mary (1857), Charles (1860), Rose (1863), Agnes (1867): the question is whether Grace, Margery and Roseann perished, whether John could have been the son of Margaret Dougherty (that is, that they were a blended family), and whether baby John perished as well.
[This June 1860 census is schedule 1 of the 2nd Division of the 13th ward of NY City, page 35].
An odd coincidence I discovered on my wife’s side of the family is that her grandfather Oskar was actually the second baby (from a large family) given that name: in other words, a baby named Oskar died, and the next male baby—“Our” Oskar—was given the same name as his deceased sibling. I suppose that it is possible that Brigid Lafferty and Charles McGinnis’ children Grace, Margery and Roseann could have died and Margaret Dougherty and Charles gave Roseann’s name to a subsequent newborn, but it doesn’t seem….likely?
Again, I do appreciate your perspective—may I ask how, based upon your experience investigating Irish families, you would put the pieces together?
Best, Ray