Back to Message Board

Seeking any help with info about John Crow

I only know what my aunt found in her genealogy search...John and Ellen Crow (nee Mahoney) are my 3rd great grandparents. John was born in 1846, Ellen in 1849, and they married about 1867. John immigrated to the US in 1868 and Ellen followed him one year later in 1869. They had one child prior to immigrating - Morris, born about 1868.

I have tried to do a bit of research through the National Archives website and found Crow families in the 1851 census. There is a John Crow as a 5yo, which would be the right age. It shows this boy's parents would be John, 26, and Jane, 25,with 2 younger brothers, James,2, and Patrick,2 months. Their family ID is 3...not sure what this means, though... This family is from Inshamph, Barony Kilconway, Parish Dunaghy, Co. Antrim.

Also shown is another Crow family (their Family ID is 1) with them being from the same Town, Barony, Parish, and County as the above family, so I thought maybe John, Sr's parents and siblings. The head of the household is Patrick and his wife is Bridget (both 65), with their childrenBarnard, 28, Ann, 26 (maybe John's twin?), and Catherine, 18.

This is all I could find searching the name John Crow in the census available prior to the immigration, and absolutely nothing came up when searching Mahoney.

I know this isn't much...not even sure these are my ancestors, but if anything can help and shed some light on anything, it would be greatly appreciated. :)

Mary

Mary Grogan

12 replies

Mary:

Welcome to Ireland Reaching Out!

I searched the free site www.irishgenealogy.ie which has civil birth records from 1864-1916 and found young Maurice's record in Co. Waterford. See sixth record on this link.Looks like the family was living in Kilduane townland in Monksland civil parish in south central Co. Waterford. We will need to wait and see where they were married.

https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/birth_retur…

We do not have civil marriage records until 1870 so I can't see a record at this time. There are index records pre-1870 for Crowes but none in the Kilmacthomas registration district. I also searched the subscription site Roots Ireland and did not find a church record for a Crowe/Mahoney marriage.

Let me know what questions you have.

Roger McDonnell

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Mary, you said you found a John Crow about the same age as your ancestor on 1851 census in County Antrim. What you need to know about 1851 census and all others taken in Ireland in 19th century is that very little of the information collected exists. A reason why you found 2 families called Crow on 1851 census in Antrim is that Antrim is one of the few counties where census records for a sizeable number of people survived. A search of 1851 census results in thousands of individuals in Antrim but only 6 in County Armagh for instance. A search for any surname on 1851 census might be more likely to find it in Antrim than most other counties.  A search of 1851 census for  Waterford turns up only 20 individuals in 2 houses in 1 parish. I know where 2  sets of my great-grandparents were in 1851 but they don't show up in any census records.and neither do any of their relatives or neighbours because records survive for only 6 people in their county.  People with your surname were living in Mayo and Roscommon but you probably won't find them on a census in those counties until 1901.

A substitute for 1851 census is a census search request application which some  people who wanted to claim old age pensions in early 20thC submitted to ascertain their age. Not every elderly Irish-born person applied for a pension and of those who did only some needed a census search to prove age. 

Another set of records sometimes referred to as a "census substitute" is Griffiths' Valuation but this was about property and listed only people who held property. 

 

questor37@gmail.com

Roger, thank you for doing that research for me.  Seems like this would be my ancestors...how coincidental would it be to have more than one John Crow(e) marry a gal named Ellen (nee Mahoney)?  My aunt noted their first-born's name as Morris, so Maurice is quite similar.  I know last names were often changed when families came to the US, but could first names have been "Americanized", as well?  Or maybe whatever document my aunt found showing their son's name as Morris may have been our (American) understanding when the name Maurice was said...accents and all...  There is a city directory I found showing my paternal grandparents and my dad.  My dad's name was Irwin, but they have him down as Ivan - my Russian grandmother's accent would sound like that when she said Irwin. ;)

Maggie, I read the info on the National Achives site about the lack of records, which I figure is why I was unable to find anything for Mahoney.  I'm not sure if you are saying that if my family actually came from the Waterford area that Co. Antrim would still have had their records noted?  That's quite a distance from Waterford, but still possible since what Roger found was from John and Ellen's adulthood, so they could have traveled from Co. Antrim to Waterford area.

Greatly appreciat this help from both of you...I'm such a beginner when it comes to genealogy.

Mary Grogan

Hello Mary.

Apologies for not making myself clear. I wasn't aware if you knew that only fragments of 1851 census survived for most Irish counties. Antrim was a rare exception.  What I meant regarding Waterford was that because records for only 2 households exist for the entire county, your John and Ellen might well have been in County Waterford in 1851 but their records didn't survive. We don't know if they were in Waterford or not. Absence of proof is not proof of absence.

I've since looked for the Crow(e) surname on Griffiths' Valuation. There were 4 entries in County Waterford. So there were definitely people called Crow(e) holding land in County Waterford within a few years of 1851. There were also some in neighbouring counties.

The birth registration of Maurice in Monksland parish in County Waterford, found by Roger, is your one piece of solid evidence. You need to begin by focussing your research in County Waterford. Those Crow households which you found in County Antrim in 1851 may be red herrings.

There was no standard spelling of names at the time Maurice was born. As today, parents could spell their child's name how they wanted. Same went for surnames. Were John and Ellen able to read and write? Many of their Irish contemporaries couldn't. Ellen might be Helena in church registers if she was Catholic and if the registers were in Latin. 

Roger had no luck finding a marriage. Some random thoughts:

Did John or Ellen have another forename? 

Ellen may have come from somewhere else and the marriage was in her home parish.

They may have married when one or both were living away from home.

They may have met/married in Britain and returned to Ireland later. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

questor37@gmail.com

Maggie,

First, I want to let you know I see no need for you to apologize for the manner in which you provided info in your first post...it never came across as anything other than you being helpful and making sure I realized that several years worth of census' are incomplete, 1851 being one of them.  Every bit of info you and Roger have provided is more info than I had before...and very appreciated! :)

Thank you for checking the Griffiths' Valuation for me...this sounds like it could be a bit more confirmation that my family was from the Co. Waterford area.

Although the info I found for Co. Antrim may not be my ancestors, I will keep the info, just in case there is a connection. ;)

I have no idea if John and Ellen were able to read and write, but since Maurice's birth record and other US records indicate John was a Laborer, my wild guess is no.  I have seen some US records that show Ellen as Helen(a), and it would make sense for them to be Catholic.  These ancestors were from my mother's side of the family, and she was raised Catholic, so it seems logical that this religion would have been followed through the generations.  I see information on Maurice's birth record that may be another "clue" for me...it looks like Mary Mahoney was the informant because she was present at the birth.  My thought is that this would be Ellen's mother (as opposed to a sister).  If I'm on the right track, this means that I just learned the forename of my 4th great-grandmother. :)  I also would love confirmation on Maurice's birthdate...looks like 14 (?) Aug 1868.

In response to your random thoughts: 

As far as I know, neither John nor Ellen had another forename.

Another avenue to consider - Ellen possibly being from another parish.

Food for thought that one or both could have been living away from the family home when they married, or even happened to be in Britain when they married.

Again, thank you for all your help!  It is "crystal" clear that I should now focus my search in Co. Waterford. (Sorry, just couldn't help myself :P )

Mary Grogan

Mary:

The day of birth was badly written but it must be "Fourteenth"  I can't come up with a better date.

Below is the baptismal record for Maurice form the subscription site Roots Ireland. That record shows Knockmahon rather than Kilduane. Monksland is a very small civil parish and there were only six townlands plus Knockmahon which is likely a samll village.

Roger

Name:Maurice CroweDate of Birth:
Date of Baptism:01-Aug-1868Address:KnockmahonParish/District:KILLGender:
CountyCo. Waterford
Denomination:Roman Catholic
Father:John CroweMother:Ellen MahonyOccupation:
Sponsor 1 /
Informant 1:Patrick Mahony Sponsor 2 /
Informant 2:Brigid Crowe 

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Mary, I was going to ask you if you had information about religious denomination. The question is answered. As Maurice had a godparent from each side of his family we can assume both parents were Catholic.

Another thought I had about marriage was whether Ellen may have been a widow when she married John Crow and marriage record is under 1st married surname.

questor37@gmail.com

Observations about birth registration for Maurice.

I'm not sure about date of birth  -  could be fourteenth or twentieth?  Either way, unless August was a mistake, date of baptism pre-dates date of birth! It wouldn't be the only case of an Irish baby baptised before official birthday. 

Place of birth has been crossed-out and another one written. Was original Knockmahon?

Qualification of the informant was "Present at birth". She was not necesarily Ellen's mother. The only things we know about her is her name and that she was in the house when Maurice was born. She may have been Ellen's mother, grandmother, step-mother, aunt, sister, sister-in-law, cousin, niece. She may have been no relation  -  Mahoney surname may have been coincidence. She might have been a neighbour with midwifery experience, called in to help with the birth. As well as parents I've noticed grandparents, aunts and uncles as informants on birth registrations in this decade. Then there are those with no relationship specified at registration, stated qualification being  "Present at birth". 

 

questor37@gmail.com

Is Knockmahon in a copper mining area? I wonder if John may have gone to Wales or Cornwall to work in a coal or tin or copper mines? Not far to go from Waterford.  Welsh and Cornish miners moved up to Northern England when there were fluctuations in different types of mining. Cumberland and Westmorland  -  slate and lead mines; coal in the rest of Northern England. 

questor37@gmail.com

Roger, thank you for confirming you also see Maurice's birthdate as the 14th, and for providing the baptism info.

Maggie, I also noticed the discrepancy in the birthdate and baptism date.  You noted that you have seen baptisms occur prior to the baby's birth, so I suppose this could be possible in this case.  In the US, I know that in the 19th century, clergy used to travel to different areas and one would need to get weddings and baptisms performed when the clergy was in town.  Thus, some children may not have been baptized until they were 4 or maybe even 6 months old, occasionally even older.  Could this have been the same situation here...knowing that the clergy was in town now and wouldn't be back until quite a while after Maurice was due to be born, his parents decided to have him baptized prior to birth?  This would also explain why the date of birth section was left blank.  But now that I'm setting this forth, how would they know what name to put on the baptism records, as in those days, they didn't know the gender of the baby until it was born...

Interestingly, in my aunt's notes for Maurice, she found him in the 1880 US census living as a boarder with John and Bridget Mahoney (nee Crow).  Could this Bridget be the same as the Brigid noted on the baptism records?  My aunt indicated she could possibly be John's older sister or an aunt, but was unable to be determined.

Thank you for the explanation for the "Present at Birth" indication...I thought that would mean the person was in the room during the birth, probably helping to birth the baby, which is why I figured it would have been Ellen's mother.

I don't think John was a miner, as the birth record for Maurice indicates he was a Laborer, and like on another entry on that page, his occupation would have stated miner if that were the case. ;)

Wonderful help from both of you...thank you so much!

Mary Grogan

To expand on the baptism date seeming to pre-date Maurice's birth. I haven't looked at the image in the baptism register. The date may have been incorrectly transcribed in the information which Roger found.  You would need to scrutinise it for yourself and look at other baptisms on the page in case the priest made a mistake.

If the date of baptism of an Irish baby seems to have been before the date of his birth on civil registration records then the birthdate on the civil record was probably wrong. Baptism was the priority. A baby in those days of high infant mortality would have been baptised soon after birth. The less important matter of telling the authorities that your family had increased could wait until it was convenient for someone to go into the town where the registry office was. That might be on market-day if they lived some distance away. Most people in country areas would have been too busy in August saving the hay or digging potatoes or some other vital work on a farm to spare time visiting town. The family workforce would have been minus one with the new mother out of action. Young men may have been away working in Britain. There was a fine for late registration of birth. Some people gave a wrong birthdate to avoid a fine. Some informants may have genuinely forgotten the correct date by the time they went to the registry office. Some fathers may have gone to the regisrty office via a pub (bar) and memory may have been clouded by an excess of porter, especially if it was the first son.   Maurice was born only 4 years after start of civil registration. People were still getting used to the procedure.  Some families didn't get around to registering their babies at all.

One of my great-grandfathers registered the birth of his wife's nephew in 1864, a few months after civil registration began. My great-grandparents were the child's godparents. When registering the birth GGF gave as his qualification as informant "Sponsor". GGF and his brother-in-law leased the same piece of land and lived in neighbouring cottages. GGF may have had cattle or pigs to buy or sell at market that day so it suited him to go to town. 

Re. John & Bridget Mahoney (nee Crowe). It's possible that she was John's sister or a cousin. Bridget is such a common name. It's not unusual to have families with cousins of the same name. (My own family has several duplicates including me.)  In arranged marriages there was a practice of a brother and sister in a family marrying a sister and brother from another family to save each set of parents having to provide a dowry for their daughter.

The Brigid Crowe who was Maurice's godmother might have been John's sister, or sister-in-law or cousin. What age were the John & Bridget Mahoney on 1880 census?

 

 

 

questor37@gmail.com

Maggie, I must thank you, once again, for providing this very helpful information.  And I have to say, I am loving your "history" lessons...it is really making things come to "life" for me!

I have also been thinking maybe Maurice's birthdate was in July instead of August.  Others on that page were born in July, so maybe his was filled out in August, so the person filling it out (priest?) accidentally wrote August instead of July.

I know what you mean about passing down the same names in a family...like you, my name is also scattered throughout my ancestors, along with my mom's.  My first AND middle name is the same as my maternal great-grandmother.

I was actually looking at my DNA results last night and found someone who has John and Bridget Mahoney (nee Crow) on their tree!  I need to contact them! :)

I would need to look back at the 1880 census to see ages of John and Bridget Mahoney.

Mary Grogan

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.