You don’t say what denomination the Creighton family were. If Church of Ireland (Episcopalian) the principal Downpatrick church records start in 1733 for baptisms, 1701 for marriages & 1718 for burials. The Cathedral only has records from the 1860s and there is also a church at Hollymount but it’s early records were lost in the 1922 fire in Dublin. Neither of the 2 Presbyterian churches in the town have any records for the early 1800s. The RC records start in 1851.
This site has a couple of mentions for Creighton in the parish of Down that might refer to your family. A Mary A(nne) Creighton married John McGarry in the Church of Ireland on 7.4.1833. A Robert Creighton is in the flax growers list for 1796 as having more than 1 acre of land.
http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.ancestry.com/%7Erosdavies/
http://www.failteromhat.com/flax/down.php
There is a record of a James Creighton, farmer of Grangicam, who died around 1831. Probate on his estate was granted that year. The probate file was lost in the 1922 fire, and all we know now is that probate was granted in 1831.
If the family were farmers, they would normally be in the tithe applotment records. The tithes for the parish of Down in 1833 list 4 Creighton farms. 3 are in the townland of Grangecam, and 1 in Marshalstown. The 3 in Grangecam are occupied by Ann, Richard & Samuel. Ann is likely to be a widow. So she might be Ann Ennis (but there’s no certainty about that).
http://www.irishgenealogyhub.com/down/tithe-applotment-books/down-parish.php#.WNHK0xR2ug0
Looking at Griffiths Valuation for 1863 I see a Richard Crayton in Grangicam. He had plot 13 which was a 10 acre farm. His was the only Creighton farm in the townland at that time. That farm today looks to be on the Old Course Rd, near the junction with Ballystrew Rd. The Valuation revision books show Richard left around 1867 (my guess would be that he died around then) when he was replaced as tenant by Robert Straney.
There were no Creighton families in Marshallstown by 1901 either.
http://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/pages/1901/Down/Downpatrick/Marshalstown/
I would check the Down Church of Ireland records to see if your family are listed. Ideally also with a townland. (Not all early baptism records have townlands). There’s a copy of the records in PRONI, the public record office, in Belfast. A personal visit is required to view them.
I had a look at the 1901 census for Co. Down (the earliest surviving complete Irish census). There were 85 Creightons listed, many in Belfast. I couldn’t see any in the Downpatrick area though. They seem to have died out.