Back to Message Board

Searching for Mannion - O'Toole Ancestral Homes

My paternal great grandmother was Catherine O'Toole Geehan (1837-1869). Her parents were Patrick O'Toole and Bridget Mannion (also spelled Manion and Manyon). The O'Toole's were said to come from Connemara, and research shows that they most likely were from Lettermore Island or vicinity. There are also O'Toole's in Lewisburgh, Mayo that are listed as cousins on some ship documents, but I can't confirm any of that yet. The Mannions and Burkes were said to come from inland Galway.

It is the Mannion family I think came from the Oughterard and Boyounagh area. Catherine O'Toole's mother's parents were John Mannion and Catherine Burke. I have found a Griffith's Valuation from 1857 that reads:

Occupier: Bridget Toole

Lessor: Sir St. George Gore Bt

County: Galway Barony: Ballymoe Parish: Boyounagh Townland: Loughpark

OS Page Numbers: 6

On that same page in the Loughpark designation are listed John Mannion (twice), Honoria Burke and a Margaret Burke. In the StonePark designation there is a Thomas Mannion listed, and at the bottom of the page in the Stonetown designation is listed an Andrew Mannion.

Since Patrick O'Toole supposedly died around 1855-1860, I am wondering if Bridget Mannion O'Toole left the Connemara area and moved back to be by her people. Her four children that I know of, James, Thomas, Mary, and Catherine, had all gone to America by then.

There is another document found on ancestry.com for a Bridget O'Toole, Ireland Civil Registration Deaths Index giving these statistics:

Name: Bridget O'Toole

Est. birth year: 1809

Date of Registration: 1864 Death age: 55

Registration district: Oughterard Volume 9 Page283

FHL Film Number 101582

Other than Bridget's name being listed as the mother on James, Thomas, and Catherine's marriage registration in Roxbury, Massachusetts, these are the only civil records I have found that somewhat match where Bridget Mannion O'Toole may have lived and died.

I have quite a bit of documentation on her four children who came to America in the famine years.

James O'Toole (1828-1889) m. Ellen Donahoe in the Boston area and eventually became a successful farmer in Neosho Rapids, Kansas.

Thomas O'Toole (1833-1885) m.Margaret Tympany and left the Boston area to also become a successful farmer in Sacramento, California.

Mary O'Toole (1835-1919) m.Timothy Kelly that she supposedly knew in Ireland. They went first to Maine and eventually joined the James O'Toole family and farmed in Kansas.

Catherine O'Toole (1837-1869) m. Patrick J Geehan from Dranagh, Carlow, left Boston and moved to Belle Plaine, Minnesota. She had six children (the two oldest, Ann and Mary, died a month apart in 1863 of probably diphtheria) and died in February of 1869. Patrick remarried six months later to Alice Dermody, but for some reason gave his youngest child, age two, to his sister and brother-in-law to raise. That little tot, Bridget Geehan Koreski (1867-1951)was my grandmother.

Besides the usual Irish names of Patrick, James, Thomas, Michael, our family has Henry and Arthur as family names. I used the 1901 and 1911 Irish Census to see if there were any O'Toole's with these names and I found them on Lettermore Island. We are coming to Ireland July 1-21 on a family heritage tour, so I hope to narrow down the Galway ancestors to a few areas so we can enjoy our time in Galway City as well.

Any help given would be most appreciated.

Thank you,

Karen Helland

karen ann

7 replies

Karen:

Just to clarify, Oughterard and Boyounagh are not close geograpically. Boyounagh parish is in northeast Co. Galway and Oughterard is in West Galway. The 1864 death record would be for a different person than the one shown in the Griffiths you listed.

If you want to get a copy of the 1864 death record from the General Register Office let me know and I can forward instructions. Costs around 4 euros.

Roger McDonnell

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Dear Roger McDonnell,

Thank you for your email. And yes, I would like to get a copy of the death record mentioned. Please send me the instructions on how to do this.

Thanks again for your assistance.

Karen

karenhh66@comcast.net

 

karen ann

Karen:

Go to this link for GRO  https://www.welfare.ie/en/Pages/Apply-for-Certificates.aspx

Print out the death form, fill out the form to the best of your ability, include the info from your death index record: year of death, registration district and the volume and page number. This info allows the GRO staff to go right to the record. Make sure you just ask for a copy. You have to use snail mail to send the request to GRO in Co. Roscommon ( address is provided when you print out the form and their instructions). However, you can ask the GRO to e-mail the copy back to you. I provide a credit card number and never had any problems.I usually get my copies back in two weeks. 

The death record shows the date of death, cause of death, where the deceased lived and the name of the informant and sometimes the relationship of the informant to the deceased.

Your three week trip sounds great. My wife and I were in Ireland last September for two weeks. We have been over seven times and rent a car and drive from place to place. You see much more that way. Connemara is a beautiful area but very haunting at times because of the harsh landscape and lack of any sign of civilization. You will really enjoy Galway City and maybe you have been there before. Make sure you visit the Cathedral of Our Lady Assumed and St. Nicholas.

Roger

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Thank you so much, Roger! I will get this out tomorrow. And yes, I have been to Galway City once and only for two days. My husband and I did a Rick Steves bus tour of Ireland in 2012 to get the lay of the land all over the island. I knew I wanted to come back sometime to look at ancestral places, so the tour was great for acclimating us to the roads, etc. My husband and son will share the driving. We were surprised at the cost of insurance for them and the price of renting the seven passenger van. Oh well, there is no other way to get to out-of-the-way places like Lettermore Island where we'll be going. And hiring a driver is just too expensive, so we will wing it on our own. It should be a trip our grandsons talk about always :)

Incidentally, Seattle is a sister city of Galway, and I met the Mayor of Galway, Donal Lyons, at a Mass for peace on March 13 when he was here for the St. Patrick's Day weekend festivities. Nice man and lovely wife. I think they enjoyed our festival and even the weather cooperated with a sunny day for the parade.

Your last name is the same as one of my lifelong friends, Margaret McDonnell Parker. She and I went all the way through Catholic school together, grades 1-12. She married one of our classmates, Jon Parker, and they are still living in the area, retired, and I see them often. Her grandfather came from somewhere in Tipperary by the Rock of Cashel. He apparently took the family money out of a jar, left and never came back. Two generations later she found the village and told them who she was. The people in the pub remembered what he did and scolded her about it! I hope my great grandfather in Carlow wasn't a black sheep so I can avoid a similar "homecoming" :)

Thanks again for your help, Karen

karen ann

Thank you so much, Roger! I will get this out tomorrow. And yes, I have been to Galway City once and only for two days. My husband and I did a Rick Steves bus tour of Ireland in 2012 to get the lay of the land all over the island. I knew I wanted to come back sometime to look at ancestral places, so the tour was great for acclimating us to the roads, etc. My husband and son will share the driving. We were surprised at the cost of insurance for them and the price of renting the seven passenger van. Oh well, there is no other way to get to out-of-the-way places like Lettermore Island where we'll be going. And hiring a driver is just too expensive, so we will wing it on our own. It should be a trip our grandsons talk about always :)

Incidentally, Seattle is a sister city of Galway, and I met the Mayor of Galway, Donal Lyons, at a Mass for peace on March 13 when he was here for the St. Patrick's Day weekend festivities. Nice man and lovely wife. I think they enjoyed our festival and even the weather cooperated with a sunny day for the parade.

Your last name is the same as one of my lifelong friends, Margaret McDonnell Parker. She and I went all the way through Catholic school together, grades 1-12. She married one of our classmates, Jon Parker, and they are still living in the area, retired, and I see them often. Her grandfather came from somewhere in Tipperary by the Rock of Cashel. He apparently took the family money out of a jar, left and never came back. Two generations later she found the village and told them who she was. The people in the pub remembered what he did and scolded her about it! I hope my great grandfather in Carlow wasn't a black sheep so I can avoid a similar "homecoming" :)

Thanks again for your help, Karen

karen ann

Well a lot has happened since I wrote that note above. This Bridget Mannion O'Toole is not my 2nd great grandmother. I will have to look again, probably in the Rosmuc area. My DNA matches keep zeroing in on Lettermore Island and the surrounding area. I thought it must be just O'Toole DNA matches, but just last week, I was contacted by Michael Curley from Eastern Galway who is one of the administrators of a online and Facebook group called Mannion by DNA. I had matched with a couple of people whose ancestors were Mannions from East Galway and he was inviting me to join the group. I did, and as soon as I entered my GEDmatch Kit number, Boom!! I had many new cousins from this group. And it seems one of the East Galway Mannions relocated to Rosmuc in the mid 1700's. That would make more sense for these being my most recent Mannion people and make them more likely to have married with the O'Tooles who were prevalent in that area in the 18th and 19th centuries. So now I will be able to better figure out just who and where the O'Toole/Mannion/Burke ancestors hail from. It's a very exciting development! I didn't know I had that much Mannion bloodline in me to show up, but in the crazy, capricious way that DNA is shuffled around from one generation to the next, I seem to have received more than my share of Mannion ancestry.

I can't wait to get back to Ireland and pursue all of the new places of my family's origin.

karen ann

Karen Ann:

Thanks for the feedback. DNA testing can be very helpful. My wife and I have both tested on Ancestry and Family Tree and are on Gedmatch. We have made some good discoveries. We figured our where one of my wife's great-grandmothers came from in Co. Waterford and visited the area last month when we were in Ireland. All the best! Let us know if you need more assistance.

Roger

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.