Hello Roger,
First, let thank you for your prompt and diligent reply to my inquiry. I am overwhelmed by the kindness and generosity of all who participate in “Ireland Reaching Out” to help locate information on Irish ancestors. This site is truly a blessing.
The information you have found concerning the possible birth and parentage of my paternal grandfather, Joseph John Grady, is an important lead, but I am troubled by the 12-year discrepancy. Although I am aware that dates and ages are often the least reliable genealogical data, a birth date of 1856 would be difficult to reconcile with every other date I have regarding my grandfather, including : the March 4, 1892, Massachusetts Registry of Marriages that listed both he and Margaret as age 24 on their marriage; the U.S. census data for 1900, 1910 and 1930 that generally agree with a birth in 1868; and, an age of 64 listed on his death certificate in June 1936. But I will seek out additional information on Joseph, John and Mary (Delany) Gready of Co. Laois to see if any other connections arise. I am seeking, but presently don’t have, any immigration or naturalization information on Joseph and Margaret that would hopefully provide me better identification of their locational origins.
With regard to the information you uncovered about Margaret Warren, I can confirm that I have the same suspicions.
I too had seen the information on Timothy Warren and Johanna Kiley that you found in www.irishgenealogy.ie and it does look promising. The countering information that I have is, again from the Massachusetts Registry of of their marriage that lists (only) the first names of the bride and groom’s parents as Timothy and “Catharine” for Margaret Warren. Also, Margaret’s death certificate lists her maiden name as “McGillicuddy” (no first name of mother was listed) as provided by her husband, Joseph, at the time of her death. Anything is possible, but these seem to be reliable sources.
Also, I had my DNA tested last year and so far only one potential relative with more than a fraction of a percent of DNA similarity has been found. That person has “Warren” family ancestors and my digging into genealogical data suggests that the connection may be through an “Edward Warren” reportedly born in Ireland circa 1870 to Timothy and Johanna. This makes me wonder then if Timothy could have been widowed and remarried, over a relatively short timespan, to have two contemporaneous children with different mothers, that is, Catharine for Margaret and Johanna for Edward (or Edmund)? Do you know if there any church records in Co, Laois that might reveal such possibilities (death, burial, remarriage)?
Thank you again Roger for your help. It is not only useful, but encouraging me to keep searching harder to shine some light down the dark corridors of time.
Gratefully,
Stephen Grady