Back to Message Board

Searching for Ancestors in Tyrone (Derryloran)

I don't have much to work with except for a close DNA match to an O'Neill from Cookstown, Tyrone. My family name is now Neal after many misspellings over the years by census takers and other government officials in America. It was probably Nill or O'Neill or possibly Neill inside Ireland. My relative by DNA is an O'Neill who now uses the Nill spelling. That is about all I have to work on, unfortunately. I haven't been able to get any help elsewhere.

IrelandXO member

4 replies

Dennis:

Welcome to Ireland Reaching Out!

Sorry for the delay in  responding. We received a tremendous amount of messages just before Christmas and our HQ staff are going back and identifying the messages where no response was provided. I'm a volunteer for IRO and also know a little bit about DNA. Can you provide any details on your ancestor that left Ireland? Which company did you test with?

O'Neill and variant surnames are very common in Ireland and actually in the mid-19th century Co. Tyrone had more O'Neills than any other county which will complicate any search efforts.

Roger McDonnell

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Hello, Roger! No problem with late response. I'm frankly not expecting to find out anything, but it would be brilliant if I did. Here's the information that matters: I have taken every conceivable Y and autosomal DNA test with Family Tree DNA. My kit number is 400441. I am also listed in the Y-DNA "Big Tree" on the Internet, where I occupy a unique branch with only one person - Dan O'Neill. He and I share almost identical DNA and have R-A5386 as our terminal SNP with R-S588 upstream. According to two of the projects on FTDNA, I am listed as Type 1A Irish, Uí Níall (at the "Royal House of O'Neill" project) and am also listed on the Cenel Eoghain project. Not many clues as to where my ancestor (John Neill, eventually corrupted to "Neil", "Neel" and "Neal" by various census takers and government officials in America. He was born circa 1715-1725, most likely 1719-20. Some John Neills/Neales fitting that birth year are listed in Armagh and Antrim, but no certainty of who they are. The area where John Neel/Néill/Neal settled in Pennsylvania bore names like "Balleymoney" and my 4th great grandfather (also named John) along with his brother William, later set up Antrim township in Pennsylvania. I'm convinced I'm on a fool's errand, as my research ends hopelessly at the Pennsylvania waterline and my Tyrone cousin can't find anything further back than his great-grandfather. If he could go back we might pick up the trail. Maybe. Probably not. Thanks for all your help!

IrelandXO member

Dennis:

You are really into DNA!

I've tested on Family Tree and Ancestry. I've taken the Y-111 test and autosomal on Family Tree. The autosomal has helped me break down one brick wall on my line and another brick wall on my wife's line so it is very helpful. The Y test has taken me back to the west coast of Mayo in the 1700s but my earliest known ancestor (gggf) is from east Mayo so I have not linked west to east Mayo.

One suggestion with your autosomal data. Are you familiar with Gedmatch? www.gedmatch.com  Gedmatch is a volunteer run site where you can upload your raw autosomal DNA data and see if you have matches with people who tested with 23 and Me or Ancestry (and uploaded their data to Gedmatch). It allows you to expand your potential match base.

All the best with your search for where your O'Neill ancestors came from in Northern Ireland. Hopefully as more Irish take DNA tests, you will find more info on your family.

Roger

Blizzard Bound Maryland

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Yes I'm on GEDMATCH using F400441 as my main reference. Haven't found anything solid there yet.

IrelandXO member

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.