Bill:
Thank you so much for keeping on this! I am sorry to say that I had missed your post above where you mention the Galway Historical Society. So, as yet, I have not checked into that. But be sure that I will now!
Regarding this 1911 Census family of Prendergasts: surely they like the same Christian names! William, John, Kate, Matthew and Ann all appear as grand-children of this John Prendergast, POSSIBLY of Galway (or Mayo) of before 1847. But, of course, they're common in a lot of families!
One possible way to approach this is to find some living descendents of these Prendergasts and see if anyone has family history of an emigrant to the US named John in the 1840s. But that of course has about a much chance as finding a needle in a haystack, when one has several haystacks to choose from!
As I think I said, this emigrant John MAY have married a woman born in Massachusetts after he arrived. But his son John (grandfather to my father and present at his baptism), was very closely associated in Chicago with a family of McFaddens from Mayo. We haven't located their source in Mayo yet either, but this great-grandfather John (born in Maine in 1847....which was part of Massachusetts until 1820) married a McFadden daughter, in Chicago, who was born in Mayo.
(An interesting historical sidelight it that it was the Massachusetts Militia's lack of facility in defending their Maine hinterland from the British depredations in the War of 1812 that led the people of Maine to move for separate statehood! I would be surprised if their Irish constituency, which existed even then, weren't enthusiastic supporters of that!)
It seems typical of the immigrant generation of Irish that they RARELY wrote down their origin in Ireland beyond, sometimes, citing the County, the exception perhaps being those from the larger cities. I suppose I can understand why, because, at this remove in time as space at least, many Americans do seem much at a loss to know where, in Ireland, even the Counties are located! I imagine it wasn't too much different in the 19th C.!
I'm perhaps closer to finding out where the McFaddens originated, and I may have to pin that down and then see what Prendergast families might have been close. But this Stripe location would surely seem to fit in some ways!
All such citations as you've sent are of much interest. WIth regard to the census finding you've posted: the table is cut off on the right after "Occupation" and I can't seem to expand it. Did you find this online at a site for which you could share the link? That way I might be able to look at the "original", as it were, of what you've posted. (maybe I'll find that it's at the Galway Historical Society that you've given me above...not yet checked!)
If you like, and if it's convenient, we can communicate by direct email, rather than this forum. My email address is:
nesika42@earthlink.net
Again, Many Thanks and Sincere Regards,
Bill Prendergast