Back to Message Board

The Search for Old Peter Redmond

In 1873 an Irishman named Peter Redmond arrived in New York aboard a ship called India and was registered at Castle Garden, the predecessor to Ellis Island. According to the passenger list he was thirty-five years old and born in 1838, and this birth yearis confirmed in several other documents,in Scotland, a note contradicted in other documents. There are many Peter Redmonds. However i have not been able to find one born in Scotland in the 1800's. And i have only found one born in Ireland in 1838. This Peter was born in Wexford. His father's name was James.

A Peter Redmond, son of James, married a woman named Margaret Doyle, daughter of John, in 1867. This Peter, however, was born in1839 according to the Ireland marriages record. Could he be the same Peter as the one born in 1838 and who arrived in New York in 1873? If so, he took a second wife, although she does not appear to have taken Peter's name, so i can't confirm they married. Her name was Jane Crawford. She may have been the Irish born daughter of Jane Crawford of Ireland. However i've found records saying separately that a Jane Crawford of the same age was born in Ireland and Rochester New York.

Peter Redmond and Jane were in Rochester New York. They had two sons. The eldest, James Redmond, was born in Rochester. Peter Redmond, the second son born in 1869, moved with his parents to Detroit Michigan. There, according to census records,Peter worked as a patrolman. His death records indicate he rose to the rank of detective before he died in 1914. His other accomplishment was having three children with Alida Leonard: Aubrey, Mildred, and my grandfather Arthur.

With the notable exception of a 1910 census document, both old Peter and Jane are listed in several documents as born in Ireland. The odd 1910 census document lists Peter as born in Scotland and Janein Bermuda. Another mystery is i am unable to find any notice of Peter or Jane's death. But in 1904 there is a Peter Redmond, born in 1838, registered in Wexford Ireland. Is it the same Peter born 1838 who landed in New York in 1873? He returned to Ireland? Was Jane still with him? What ever happened to Margaret Doyle, assuming Peter Redmond who married Margaret and born in 1839 was the same man born in 1838, who immigrated to the United States, fathered two children (that led to me) and returned to the shores of Ireland?

Can anyone help with any of this?

IrelandXO member

11 replies

Descendants of Peter Redmond:

Welcome to Ireland Reaching Out!

Not to complicate your research but I located two other Peter Redmond baptismal records in 1838 in Wexford (see below) and there are at least three records in 1839. Ages in the 19th century were not as exact as they are now.

I think the key piece of info would be his 1914 death certificate and hopefully parents names are listed.

Have you considered autosomal DNA testing?

Roger McDonnell

First name(s)PeterLast nameRedmondBirth year1838Birth date29 Aug 1838Baptism year1838Baptism date30 Aug 1838ParishWexfordDioceseFernsCountyWexfordCountryIrelandFather's first name(s)JohnFather's last nameRedmondMother's first name(s)CatherineMother's last nameMorganRepositoryNational Library of IrelandNational Library of Ireland linkhttp://registers.nli.ie//registers/vtls000634138#page/1/mode/1upRegisterBaptism

First name(s)PeterLast nameRedmondBirth year-Baptism year1838Baptism date18 Nov 1838ParishEnniscorthyDioceseFernsCountyWexfordCountryIrelandFather's first name(s)EdwardFather's last nameRedmondMother's first name(s)EllenMother's last nameCronleyRepositoryNational Library of IrelandNational Library of Ireland linkhttp://registers.nli.ie//registers/vtls000634060#page/1/mode/1upRegisterBaptism

 

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Hi Roger

Thank you for your impressively quick response.  I will have to research autosomal DNA testing.  In the meantime i'm going to take a look at the records you made available.  There are three names that keep coming up in my family for  three generations:  James, Peter, and Ann.  Anyway, congratulations.  You have been extremely successful "thickening the plot" by locating a second Peter Redmond born in 1838 in Wexford.  

IrelandXO member

The 1914 death certificate for Detective Peter lists Peter Redmond (old Peter) and Jane Crawford as parents.  I can't find a death certificate in the United States for old Peter who is the one who was born in Ireland.  i don't think he vanished because, and i could be wrong, i think the family prospered;  one son, James, was a street car motorman and the other, Peter, was a police detective in Detroit Michigan.  Unless old Peter was some kind of methuseleh he would have passed before his children.  He would have been 76 in 1914, when Peter died and twenty years older than that when James died, 1934.  That's plenty old for the early 1900's.

Detective Peter married Alita (Anna) Leonard in Detroit in 1890.  Old Peter and Jane are listed as detective Peter's parents.  However i can't tell whether or not they were actually present for the ceremony.  I can't find any references to them in the census documents.  There is no record of their deaths in Detroit Michigan or Rochester. New York.  In 1890 old Peter would have been 62.  That's advanced years for the late 1800's.So i doubt he would have headed back to Ireland after that point.  Also, i think it would have been painful to leave children and grandchildren behind to return to the old country.  Who knows?

 

 

IrelandXO member

There is a Peter Redmond, born 1838, who passed in Oct-Dec 1904 in Wexford England.  It's most likely the Peter Redmond born 1838 who never left Wexford.  If that is the case, then it's as if old Peter simply vanished from the face of the earth without a trace...

 

Peter Redmond, "Ireland Civil Registration Indexes, 1845-1958"

url
https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:FTFJ-157

IrelandXO member

So I'm confused. Your original message had old Peter in the 1910 census right? Was that in Detroit? So he would have died after 1910.

With the notable exception of a 1910 census document, both old Peter and Jane are listed in several documents as born in Ireland.  The odd 1910 census document lists Peter as born in Scotland and Jane in Bermuda.  

Was old Peter a carpenter?

Roger

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

 

Census of 1900 shows Detective Peter Redmond

 

 

 

Event Type
Census

Event Year
1900

Event Place
Detroit city Ward 13, Wayne, Michigan, United States

Gender
Male

Age
31

Marital Status
Married

Race
White

Race (Original)
W

Relationship to Head of Household
Head

Relationship to Head of Household (Original)
Head

Years Married
10

Birth Date
Jul 1869

Birthplace
New York

Marriage Year (Estimated)
1890

Father's Birthplace
Ireland

Mother's Birthplace
Ireland

Detroit city Ward 13, Wayne, Michigan, United States

 

 

Notice no children listed.

 

 

 

 

IrelandXO member

Old Peter is mentioned in both census as the father of head of household detective Peter.

 

10 years later the census looks like below and includes an 11 year old child, which does not make sense because that child should have shown up on the census in 1900 as a one year old:

 

Name  Peter Redmond

Event Type Census

Event Date 1910

Event Place Cleveland Ward 10, Cuyahoga, Ohio, United States

Gender Male

Age 41

Marital Status  Married

Race White

Race (Original)White

Relationship to Head of Household  Head

Relationship to Head of Household (Original)Head

Birth Year (Estimated)1869

Birthplace Michigan

Father's Birthplace  Scotland

Mother's Birthplace   Bermuda

 

 

IrelandXO member

I don't think i have definitive documention on old Peter's profession.  The guy is a ghost.  I have a passenger list that includes a Peter Redmond.  Is he old Peter?  The birthdate 1838 is right, but the boat docked in 1873 and James was born in Rochester New York in 1865 and detective Peter three years later.  So now i'm questioning the passenger list.  But if you look at the 1910 census that mentions old Peter coming from Scotland, seems like too much of a coincidence.

 

Event Type Immigration

Event Date 1873

Event Place  New York City, New York, United States

Gender Male

Age  35

Birth Year (Estimated)1838

Birthplace   ScotlandShip

Name          India

IrelandXO member

In the Detroit City Directories there was a Peter E. Redmond carpenter listed after Peter the detective. Could have been another Peter Redmond and no connection to your family.

Roger

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Will work on the question of the carpenter.  When Det. Peter moved to Ohio he is listed on the 1910 Ohio census as a laborer.  So maybe he had some carpentry skills, but check out what i found to day.  Det. Peter was a hero cop.  His shooting was front page news in 1904.  I found three more links to articles that i think were written as memorials.  So this has been a really fruitful exercise for me.  My grandfather never spoke about his family.  Now i feel like i've been given a glimpse into my great grandfather's life.

 

Patrolman Peter Redmond Seriously Injured

https://www.newspapers.com/image/118611535/?terms=peter%2BRedmond

 

Found three archived articles about detective Peter Redmond in the Detroit free press

 

Detroit Free Press from Detroit, Michigan on December 29, 1912 ...

https://www.newspapers.com/newspage/119067313/

1.      

Detroit Free Press (Detroit, Michigan), Sunday, December 29, 1912, Page 19. ... Precinct Detective Peter Redmond, one of ttie most popular oill-ccrs on the ...

Detroit Free Press from Detroit, Michigan on February 14, 1912 ...

https://www.newspapers.com/newspage/118926345/

Detroit Free Press (Detroit, Michigan), Wednesday, February 14, 1912, Page 5. ... whom was deputed the tank of taking Detective Peter Redmond to the county ...

Detroit Free Press from Detroit, Michigan on March 17, 1914 · ...

https://www.newspapers.com/newspage/119489744/

Mar 17, 2016 - Detroit Free Press (Detroit, Michigan), Tuesday, March 17, 1914, Page 5. ... WhileDetective Kolb, with a John Doe warrant in his pocket, sought George ... Ten years ago Peter Redmondas a valued member or Detroit'i Police ..

 

IrelandXO member

Note

 

Detroit Free Press from Detroit, Michigan on ... - Newspapers.com
https://www.newspapers.com/newspage/118611535/

Detroit Free Press (Detroit, Michigan), Sunday, December 4, 1904, Page 1. ... FRAUD BIG BOUND Patrolman Peter Redmond is Seriously Wounded. ALLEGED ...

Detroit Free Press from Detroit, Michigan on ... - Newspapers.com
https://www.newspapers.com/newspage/118611551/

Detroit Free Press (Detroit, Michigan), Sunday, December 4, 1904, Page 3. ... Patrolmen Herman C. Schnabel and Peter Redmond, went directly to Newten's ...

Detroit Free Press from Detroit, Michigan · Page 5 - Newspapers.com
https://www.newspapers.com/newspage/118630108/

Detroit Free Press (Detroit, Michigan), Sunday, June 11, 1905, Page 5. ... FAILED TO Locate the bullet which entered the lungs of Patrolman Peter Redmond, ...

 

 

IrelandXO member

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.