Back to Message Board

The roots of the Davidson family in Ireland

I took a DNA test to determine my ancestry and discovered that I am 40% Irish. The DNA haplogroup of my father's lineage is R1b1b2a1a2f which was linked with the Ui Neill and King Niall of the Nine Hostages. I am now trying to determine how the Davidson (my surname)family line is linked to King Niall and the Ui Neill of Ireland. If anyone has any knowledge of this link or can point me in the right direction to discover this link I would appreciate the help. Thanks in advance!

IrelandXO member

9 replies

Hi Guitar George (he knows all the chords- Dire Straits Sultans of Swing)

There are 3938 Davidson birth/baptism records on www.rootsireland.ie/

The earliest are 1650's & 1660's in counties Derry, Antrim & Down

If you would like to post the details of what you know - Davidson garndparents' or greatgrandparents' names and birthdates & birthplaces we could try to find a line going back to one of these early Davidsons

I'm afraid all of us of Irish extraction go back to Niall 

Col

 

ColCaffIrelandXO Volunteer

Niall of the Nine Hostages isn’t around to give a DNA sample. So common sense suggests that claiming DNA links with him may be based on weak or poor science. In addition some sources suggest he was mythical anyway, so I’d be very sceptical about evidence apparently linking your family to that background.

Elwyn, IrelandXO Volunteer ☘IrelandXO Volunteer

Hi,

Interesting about King Niall, as I have an article written by Nicholas Wade of the New York Times (Jan 18, 2006) that hints that science may prove that Niall was not a myth and may have actually existed. I guess more scientific investigation will eventually prove or disprove the existence of King Niall. As for my relatives, my great-grandfather was Charles E. Davidson born in 1854 in Appomatax County Virginia and his wife (my great-grandmother) was named Esther (born in 1859). I am not sure of my relatives before him and which of the Davidson family migrated from Ireland. I cannot seem to find written  records past my great-grandfather.  Is R1b1b2a1a2f2 haplogroup common among Irish? The DNA test I took states that it is specific to Ui Neill and Dalcassian Royal families between 1,500 and 4,500 years ago in nortwest Ireland. Any information on this would be appreciated!

Thanks,

George (yes, I know all the chords, lol)

 

IrelandXO member

George,

The thing about using DNA evidence effectively is that you need to have a verified sample from an ancestor to make a reasonable claim to be descended from that person. So if someone had found Niall of the 9 Hostages skeleton and extracted a DNA sample, then I’d be sympathetic to possible evidence that someone else was related to him. But since there is no body and no such DNA sample, then that can’t be the case. And so claims to be descended from him don’t have much scientific credibility, as far as I am concerned. A horoscope potentially has about the same evidential value.

Anyway, moving to consider the Davidsons ancestry, I looked at the 1901 Irish census. There were 2192 Davidson and 1314 Davison entries. So approx. 3500 people of that name. Just 195 of those were RC. The rest were Presbyterian, Church of Ireland and other Protestant denominations.  Presbyterians made up the majority with around 1600. So what that indicates is that the vast majority were descendants of Plantation settlers. The majority having come from Scotland, and some possibly from England. Hardly any would have been native Irish. The few that were RC were probably by-products of mixed marriages, or possibly descendants of RC settlers from Scotland.

You can use this site to see where the surname was prevalent in Ireland in the 1850s:

http://www.irishtimes.com/ancestor/surname/

You’ll see that it was almost exclusively found in the counties of Ulster, where the Plantation settlers were most predominant. The site states that they were a Scottish clan that settled in the 1700s (ie in the Plantation).  Personally I’d query the claim to be from a clan since most of the Plantation settlers were from the Scottish Lowlands where they did not have clans, but I would certainly agree that Scotland was where most came from.

Going much further back, it’s quite possible that some of them had ancestors that moved from Ireland to Scotland. Indeed there has been regular movement back and forth since humans first arrived permanently in Ireland (c 10,000 years ago). The Sea was their freeway and it’s a very short journey, just 13 miles at the closest point between Scotland & Ireland. So some mix of DNA wouldn’t be too surprising but that was all before people had surnames (ie around the 1300s). And in any case much of the population of Britain and Ireland appear to share the same Brythonic origins, so you would expect to find the same DNA markers in peoples in both Britain and Ireland. So dangerous to extrapolate too much from that.

If you ask me, the clear evidence from the censuses points to most Davidsons in Ireland being of Scottish plantation background. If your DNA test says you are 40% Irish then that could be a non Davidson element, or perhaps a reflection on the quality of the size of sample that the testing company used to obtain the result. And there’s always the potential unknown non paternal event to queer any DNA test results.

You ask whether the R1b1b2a1a2f2 haplogroup is common amongst the Irish. I don’t know the answer to that. Possibly someone with greater experience of DNA testing may be able to answer your question. What I do know is that compared with the USA and other countries comparatively few Irish people have been DNA tested so any comments on its apparent frequency need to be considered in that context.

 

 

Elwyn, IrelandXO Volunteer ☘IrelandXO Volunteer

Thanks Elwyn, I will keep searching!

IrelandXO member

Hi,

I am posting an article on King Niall that I found. There shows possible  evidence he did exist!

3 million people in the world are descended from one Irish High King

James O'Shea @irishcentral

December 02,2015 01:00 AM

Millions of Irish Americans, especially those in New York, may be directly descended from Niall of the Nine Hostages, the most prolific warrior in Irish history.

A team of geneticists at Trinity College Dublin led by Professor Dan Bradley have discovered that as many as 3 million men worldwide may be descendants of the Irish warlord, who was who was the Irish “High King” at Tara, the ancient center of Ireland from A.D. 379 to A.D. 405.

Harvard Prof. Henry Louis Gates Jr., who made headlines when he was arrested by an Irish police officer while trying to break into his own locked home, is also a descendent of Niall of the Nine Hostages — and is related to the cop who booked him!

The story of Niall of the Nine Hostages is already the stuff of legend, which has been passed on to countless Irish schoolchildren over the years.

The supposedly fearless leader battled the English, the Scots, the French and even the Romans, and struck fear into the heart of his enemies. His dynasty lasted for centuries, continuing up until the Elizabethan conquest of Ireland at the end of the 16th century.

Legend has it that it was Niall of the Nine Hostages who on a raid in Wales, captured a young slave, and brought him to Ireland. That slave would later escape, and go to become Ireland’s patron saint, St. Patrick.

But one story not told to most Irish elementary schoolchildren was Niall’s prolificacy.

When it came to the bedroom, it seems that Niall of the Nine Hostages was even more fearless and energetic than he was on the battlefield.

This warlord was responsible for the very common Irish surname Oneill  (“Ui Neill” in Gaelic) – which literally means ‘descendant son of Niall' – also the name of Irish pubs all over the world.

The researchers also found that as many as one in 12 men in Ireland have the same DNA as the Irish king and in Ireland’s northwest, that figure rises to one in five.

"We sampled 60 people with these names and found the strongest association was with them,” Bradley told the London Independent. “Before this, everything was mythology, but now there does seem to have been a single male ancestor of this group of powerful dynasties."

"In many countries, powerful men historically have more children, and it's not that hard to believe that it happened in Ireland too.

"We estimate there are maybe two to three million descendants in the modern age, with a concentration in Ireland, obviously. Then there are Scotland and New York  - you find the particular chromosome in reasonable frequency in New Yorkers of European descent.”

That means that around one in 50 New Yorkers who have European roots – with surnames such as O'Connor, Flynn, Egan, Hynes, O'Reilly and Quinn – have the same genetic signature as Niall of the Nine Hostages, Bradley said.

Which prompted Peter Quinn, the renowned Irish-American author from the Bronx, to tell the New York Times, "I hope this means that I inherit a castle in Ireland."

So Niall joins Thomas Jefferson and Genghis Khan as one of the major historical figures when it comes to DNA.

Jefferson, the third president of the U.S., slept with one of his slaves, a woman called Sally Hemings, and fathered a child with her. A 1998 study found that Jefferson has an extremely rare DNA type, his Y chromosome belonging to just 1 percent of the population.

A 2003 study found that 8 percent of all Mongolian males are the descendents of Genghis Khan, sharing with him the same Y chromosome. His son had as many as 40 sons, and his grandson, as many as 22. The Khan family may have as many as 16 million descendants in Asia today.

IrelandXO member

Hi George & Elwyn

The Hubbard public member tree on ancestry which has Charles's father as Scott Hammer Davidson born 1829 Virginia. The record is unsourced. C's mother's name is unknown.

Have you checked US census, birth or marriage records for Scott?

Will have a look at my dna info later as I need to do battle with the local golf course now

Col

ColCaffIrelandXO Volunteer

George I'm not sure if this answers your question but

Facts:  The founder of the R1b lineage lived over 35,000 years ago prior to the end of the last Ice Age in southern Europe and Iberia.  Members of Haplogroup R1b are believed to be descendants of Cro-Magnon people, the first modern humans to enter Europe.  Cro-Magnons lived from about 35,000 to 10,000 years ago in the Upper Paleolithis period of the Pleistocene.

When the ice sheets retracted at the end of the ice age, descendents of the R1b lineage migrated throughout western Europe.  Today, Haplogroup R1b is found predominantly in western Europe, including England, Ireland, and parts of Spain and Portugal.  It is especially concentrated in the west of Ireland where it can approach 100% of the population.

Col

ColCaffIrelandXO Volunteer

Hi,

I found this article about R1b1b2a1a2f(2) DNA:

 

This subclade within R-L21 is defined by the presence of the marker M222. It is particularly associated with male lines which are Irish or Scottish, but especially northern Irish. In this case, the relatively high frequency of this specific subclade among the population of certain counties in northwestern Ireland may be due to positive social selection, as it is suggested to have been the Y-chromosome haplogroup of the Uí Néill dynastic kindred of ancient Ireland. However it is not restricted to the Uí Néill as it is also associated with the closely related Connachta dynasties, called the Uí Briúin and Uí Fiachrach. M222 is also found as a substantial proportion of the population of Scotland which may indicate substantial settlement from northern Ireland or at least links to it. Those areas settled by large numbers of Irish and Scottish emigrants such as North America have a substantial percentage of M222.

From Moffat DNA Project (familytreedna):

Irish 1 - Members of this cluster are descendants of the semi-mythical Irish King, Niall of the Nine Hostages or one of his male relatives. Niall is thought to have lived in the late 4th and early 5th centuries. His prolific descendants ruled Ulster and Leinster between the 6th and 10th centuries A.D. This cluster shares a common ancestor with the Irish 2 cluster between 4,500 and 1,500 years ago. Members of this cluster share a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) marker at M222. The subclade is formally known as R1b1b2a1a2f2 and is especially associated with Scottish and Irish populations. It is likely to have entered Scotland through the Dalriadic migrations of the 6th to 8th Centuries A.D. (see Irish 2 below). Both clusters share the L21 SNP mutation that defines their common subclade.

Irish 2 – A member of this cluster completed extensive SNP testing of his haplotype in late 2009 confirming that members of this cluster have the R-L21 mutation that characterises haplogroup R1b1b2a1a2f. Members of this cluster share a common ancestor with the Ui Neill and Dalcassian Royal Families between 1,500 and 4,500 years ago in northwest Ireland, where these haplotypes are most prevalent. By ancient times, these Irish tribes had become a distinctly Celtic cluster of Iron Age farmers. They were known by Ptolemy, in the 2nd Century A.D. as the Voluntii. Modern scholars call them the Ulaid. By the 5th Century A.D., they had merged with surrounding tribes into a cluster called the Scotti, the people who gave their name to the modern nation of Scotland. Between the 6th and 8th Centuries A.D., this tribe established a kingdom on the west coast of Scotland called Dalriada. They eventually merged with the Picts to form the Kingdom of Alba, the precursor to medieval Scotland. It is very likely that members of this cluster came to Scotland between 500 and 700 A.D. from the region of Ulster, Ireland.

- George

 

IrelandXO member

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.