Hello Joan,
I recently learned that PERHAPS David Roche (husband of Johanna Kiely) was possibly 1st cousin to my great grandfather David Roche who emigrated to New York. After 20 years, I could find no information on him, his origins, his family.
I have been looking for the source of my mysterious Roches for many years, and recently, I have had someone from MYHeritage contact me, as we are DNA matches.
In fact, he even mentioned the surname West in his first message to me.
I would be MOST anxious to learn parentage of the David Roche who married Johanna Kiely, as this may hopefully lead to the parents of my David Roche.
Also, my contact has told me that Winifred Roche, and her sister Mary, plus perhaps another sister and brother emigrated to New Zealand.
This contact has information on descent line for Winifred Roche and possibly her sister Mary.
Regarding Edmond Roche: Edmond Roche was witness to David and Johanna's marriage in 1846 AND godfather to their daughter Johanna. It is possible he is the Edmond Roche who fathered daughter Catherine with Honora Flynn in 1830.
I also see you have son James being born 1856, whilst I have him in 1850.
There are numerous David Roches in Monagea (Monagay), so I am at a loss to find the source of mine.
If you find out parents of your David Roche, I would appreciate it if you let me know.
Thank you
CB Weisbrot