Mcfrankel,
The Scottish marriage certificate says: 31st December 1874 at St Mungo’s Chapel, Dundee after banns according to the forms of the Roman Catholic Church. Robert Black, yarn bleacher, bachelor 26, Claverhouse Mains, James Black general labourer (dcd); Mary Coning (?) prev. Black, ms Price.
Ann Logan, power loom weaver, spinster, 23, 15 Victoria St, Dundee; Thomas Logan, Factory night watchman, Betsy Logan ms McGrath. Witnesses Paul McPherson & Rose Smith.
So the marriage cert tells us that Robert’s father was dead by December 1874 and that his mother Mary was still alive and had remarried. I cannot quite make out her new married name. Something like Coning though I don’t think that’s quite right. Both Ann’s parents were still alive. The Black & Logan families appear to have been RC. That’s important to know when searching Irish records.
I can see a death for Betsy Logan in Dundee in 1891 aged 70. (You should get her parents names from that certificate). I see Betsy in the 1881 census, apparently living alone (judging by the indexes). In 1871 she’s in a house in Dundee St Andrew (which is indexed under Angus) with Thomas b c 1815 and 5 children (one of whom is Ann aged 20). If you have a look at that census, it should tell you which of the children were born in Scotland and which in Ireland. That’ll then tell you roughly when the family moved to Scotland, and as I mentioned in my previous post if any children were born in Scotland in the years 1855 or 1861 onwards, the birth certificate should tell you where and when the parents married. (Sadly that information was omitted for the years 1856 – 1860).
I have had a look at the Irish RC marriage indexes on Ancestry but don’t see a marriage between Thomas Logan & Betsy McGrath listed. So possibly they married in a parish that doesn’t have records for the 1840s or early 1850s. Finding a Scottish birth certificate with their marriage details, if there is one, may be the easiest way forward.
I looked for Robert Black plus parent(s) in the 1871 Scottish census. All I found was a Robert aged 22 in Strathmartine. Living in a house with mixed surnames, suggesting it was a lodging house. No other Blacks. So possibly he didn’t go to Scotland with his parents. Perhaps he went on his own and lodged till he married.
I searched for his birth in Ireland in the RC parish records but did not locate it. Likewise his parents marriage.
It would obviously be good if we could get Robert Black’s mothers last married name. It should be on his death certificate if you can locate that. I did search for a death in Scotland for a Mary Black previously Price, and there wasn’t one, so that tends to confirm she didn’t make it to Scotland. Or she didn’t die there anyway. (Scottish death certificates should contain all previous names, so I can search for her without knowing her final surname). Robert seems to have been alive in 1911, as I see him and Ann in St Andrew, Dundee in the census, together with what I assume is their dau Mary Ann aged 33. Possible death for Ann in St Andrew 1920 aged 71. That will tell you whether Robert died before or after her. (Or you may already know where and when he died).
If you can give me Mary Black (nee Price) last married name from Robert’s death certificate, I can try to find her death in Ireland post 1874 and also her 2nd marriage which I think must also have been in Ireland.