Back to Message Board

Please help! with Sorting through all the Bridget Phillips of Botinny, Cloonmore

This is my first try to use this web board. I am searching for clarity. My great-grandmother was raised in Botinny, Cloonmore, Mayo. Her name was Winnie or Winifred (Winefred) Phillips. She moved to Chicago and was married to Patrick Owens also from the Botinny area. I am looking for info on both of them. Here is my difficulty with Winnie's research. I know her mother's name was Bridget but I find 5 Bridgets in the 1901 irish census in Botinny. One Bridget Phillips was a widow raising a grandson so I know it's not her.

Another Bridget Phillips was married to John Phillips and the other Bridget Phillips was married to John Phillips Martin. Both families had a young daughter named Winnie Phillips in their households.

In 1901 Winnie Phillips Martin was 13 and Winnie Phillips was 8. My grandfather is 99 yrs old and cannot remember his grandparents names in Ireland, though he has been there many times....I'm close, but I can't believe there were 2 families in such a small townland with the same father and mother names and the same daughter names. However, it seems to be true and I'm sure everyone is cousins, but I would like to know which Bridget & John Phillips are my great great grandparents. Also Winnie's date of birth is listed in many different decades in my ancestry.com research and the church records are still confusing because I'm not sure of her exact birthdate and if I could clarify the maiden names of some of these Bridgets I might be able to sort it out! Please help with any info on the Phillips of Botinny if you can! Thankyou! Here is the ireland national archive link!

http://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/search/results.jsp?searchMoreVisible=&census_year=1901&surname=Phillips&firstname=Bridget&county19011911=Mayo&county1821=&county1831=&county1841=&county1851=&parish=&ward=&barony=&townland=Botinny&houseNumber=&ded=&age=&sex=F&search=Search&ageInMonths=&relationToHead=&religion=&education=&occupation=&marriageStatus=&yearsMarried=&birthplace=&nativeCountry=&language=&deafdumb=&causeOfDeath=&yearOfDeath=&familiesNumber=&malesNumber=&femalesNumber=&maleServNumber=&femaleServNumber=&estChurchNumber=&romanCatNumber=&presbNumber=&protNumber=&marriageYears=&childrenBorn=&childrenLiving=

Meaghan

IrelandXO member

5 replies

Meaghan:

Welcome to Ireland Reaching Out!

When an area in Ireland had head of households with the same first name and surname, the census record sometimes showed the father's name of the head of household. So in the case of John Phillips Martin what that means is that John Phillips had a father named Martin. I also noticed that the other family in question was John Phillips Pat which means his name was John Phillips and his father's name was Pat.

The short answer to your question is that the 8 year old Winnie is your great-grandmother. Here is the civil birth record for your Winnie. https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/birth_retur…

The Bridget married to John Phillips (Martin) was actually his second wife. Here is an 1892 marriage record for John Phillips from Botinny and Bridget Gallagher from Lecarrow. Note the father of John was shown as Martin.

https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/marriage_re…

As further evidence, you will note that the 1901 census reocrd for John Phillips (Martin) has a one year old James in the record. I looked up the birth record and his parents were John Phillips and Bridget Gallagher from Botinny.

https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/birth_retur…

Let me know if you have any questions.

I will also send your message to someone local to see if they have any other observations.

Let us know if you need help with Patrick Owens.

Roger McDonnell

 

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Dear Roger,

Thankyou for being so helpful and for the file references. I can only view the first birth record, the others are so pixelated it seems to be a file error, hopefully temporary. I really want to see the other two files to help me understand the logic of how you determined John Phillips Pat as Winnie's father. It must be based on the 2nd marriage issue for the other couple, but I can't read the files properly to see this.

The reason I had guessed the other family of John Phillips Martin for me, was because on all Winnie's subsequent Chicago census forms it said she was "born about 1887-88."  The birth of 1888 makes sense with the John Phillips Martin as the father....because then she would have been 13 in 1901... as listed in the Phillips Martin family census) but honestly, it seems like they got the dates wrong all the time on people's birthdates in both country's censuses (is this because the census takers just guessed how old people were and didn't always ask..? )

This has been a harrowing process of elimination, get this: (There is one record in Chicago where her birth date numbers are transposed to "born about 1878" and that information first led me down a completely wrong path on the Ballaghaderreen/ Kilcomen parish baptism archives to another Winey Phillips born March 17, 1878 to John & Bridget Phillips in Castelmore & Kilcolmen & Roscommon & Sligo & Mayo)

Yes! I would love some help on my great grandfather Patrick Owens of the Botinny area as well:) I was told his mother was a local midwife who had some training. If you are asking a local, I'd also like to know who the famous "Champion Phillips" was that the old people used to talk about...supposedly a champion fiddle player from the family and Botinny.

IrelandXO member

Dear Roger,

I can see both records now thank you! So let me know what you think....I noticed that in the details of the birth record for James Phillips 1899, that Winnifred Phillips (James's older sister or father's mother, or father's sister?)  is listed as "Present at Birth" and also some tiny writing saying "her + mam?" It would make sense for a 12 or 13 year old sister or stepdaughter to be present to help at a birth. But what does that little writing mean?

I noticed that based on the marriage certificate, that assuming all children were born in wedlock, that Bridget Phillips Gallagher is probably only the mother of the last two children born in the family. In 1901, her children would have been the youngest two: Bridget who was 4 years old in 1901 and James listed as 1 years old (born Oct 21st 1899). Annie is questionable at 8 years old...but I'm sure the older childer Martin 12, Winnie 13, and Mary 15 were born of the previous wife of John Phillips Martin. Is there some way to find the marriage certificate of his first wife? If I know her name then I can see if she gave birth to Winnie.

 I'm still curious as to why you think the 8 year old Winnie in 1901 is my great grandmother.? Are you certain? I was leaning toward the Phillips Martin family. Maybe if I can find the baptismal certificates...? I don't really know how to tell, until I see documentation of her exact birthdate in the US that matches the birthdate in Ireland or the parents names.

Patrick Owens left home at 17 as far as I know, because he wasn't the oldest brother, and he would not inherit the farm, and when he was very young around 12, he left for awhile to work in the coal mines in Wales or England as a stable boy. But I know his mother was a landholder with a farm in the area and that she was supposedly a midwife with formal training. I also feel strongly that he may have changed his own first name in the US so that he would not be found after participating in Irish nationalist groups.....this is based on family rumors, but maybe he did not change his name....

One last question I have is that I am searching for an understanding of the name Vivian? Is this a nickname for Winnifred in Ireland? Or could there have been a Vivian Phillips in the area? Perhaps there is a way to see middle names or confirmation names? Sometimes I find Winnifred Phillips name listed as Vivian in the US, which I also find very strange.

IrelandXO member

Meaghan:

Some partial returns. Below are First, the civil birth record for the older Winifred with parents John Phillips and Agnes Brett. Second, the death record of Atty Phillips husband John Phillips from Botinny. I think John may have said Aggie and they heard Atty? Just a guess. Third, located Martin's birth reocrd and the mother was Agnes Brett. Fourth, Anne's birth record with mother Bridget Gallagher. I guess Bridget had Anne nine months after the marriage. More to come as I find records.

Roger

Winifred birth  

https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/birth_retur…

Atty death

https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/deaths_retu…

Martin

https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/birth_retur…

December 20, 1892

https://civilrecords.irishgenealogy.ie/churchrecords/images/birth_retur…

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.