Joe:
Welcome to Ireland Reaching Out!
I searched on two different data bases for baptismal records for the Cooney children but did not find any records.
I also looked at the Griffiths Valuation data from the mid-19th century and there were 22 Peter Cooney records throughout Ireland. Assuming your Peter was leasing land, he is likely one of the records below.
You may also want to consider autosomal DNA testing.
Roger McDonnell
SourceSurnameFirst NameTownlandParishCounty
GriffithCooneyPeterCrocknahattinBailieboroughCo. Cavan
GriffithCooneyPeterCarrickamaddooKillinkereCo. Cavan
GriffithCooneyPeterDrumbinnisKnockbrideCo. Cavan
GriffithCooneyPeterGlasdrummanKnockbrideCo. Cavan
GriffithCooneyPeterCarrickacromanLarahCo. Cavan
GriffithCooneyPeterBogeskyLaveyCo. Cavan
GriffithCooneyPeterKnockaniraKilloneCo. Clare
GriffithCooneyPeterT/derry/dark LaneTemplemoreCo. Derry
GriffithCooneyPeterGoldenbridge, S.St. JamesCo. Dublin
GriffithCooneyPeterCircular-RoadSt. JamesCo. Dublin
GriffithCooneyPeterSandymount Cottage-Park AvenueDonnybrookCo. Dublin
GriffithCooneyPeterRathfarnhamRathfarnhamCo. Dublin
GriffithCooneyPeterCorraunAghaboeCo. Laois
GriffithCooneyPeterNewton MonasterboiceMonasterboiceCo. Louth
GriffithCooneyPeterCarrickardKilmactrannyCo. Sligo
GriffithCooneyPeterSheeanmoreSkreenCo. Sligo
GriffithCooneyPeterBanagherKillucanCo. Westmeath
GriffithCooneyPeterT/moate Dublin RoadKilmanaghanCo. Westmeath
GriffithCooneyPeterOulartMeelnaghCo. Wexford
GriffithCooneyPeterMerchants' Quay Ward Circular RoadDublin CityCo. Dublin
GriffithCooneyPeterGallaghKillosolanCo. Galway
GriffithCooneyPeterMagheranappanConvoyCo. Donegal