Back to Message Board

Patrick, Walter, Annie and William O'Brien

Hello,

I have been researching my family for over thirty years without much to show for my efforts on the Irish side.Ancestry DNA states that Munster Province is the source of my Irish connections.

Can anyone with knowledge or experience comment on the accuracy of these statements? It would certainly help my research if I could concentrate on South Western Ireland for ancestry.

Regards, Mick O'Brien

NSW Australia

Research: William Sheridan O'Brien born New York City (probably) around 1900, parents stated as Patrick O'Brien and Annie Johnson

ShamusOBrien

2 replies

I would treat the DNA Ethnicity results as just interesting estimates - they are based on quite small samples of people and on assumptions that are not always correct.

The best use for these types of DNA tests is to look for matches with potential distant cousins etc and contact them to see what research they have established. Ancestry DNA system should already allow this. To increase the test coverage further you can upload your DNA data to GEDMatch, which is free. More people are testing the DNA for family-research all the time so increasing the chance of finding a match.

Have you located Patrick and Annie in US census records ? did they marry in the US ?

 

 

 

shanew147IrelandXO Volunteer

Thanks Shane...as I thought, clutching at straws...would have been a nice clue to concentrate on tho...

Already doing the GEDMATCH thing etc...the trouble is being inundated with close matches from the Maternal side (mainly from Ancestry because they use autosomnal)...no help at all! :-)

Have you located Patrick and Annie in US census records ? Yes, way back in 1987 living at Apt 5 201 East 73rd Street...but subsequent efforts to try and match that family with the tiny amount of information I have on William has not been conclusive....did they marry in the US ? maybe...that family census records said both born in Ireland

My 90 year old Father is resigned to never knowing...maybe I should move on as well :-(

ShamusOBrien

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.