Back to Message Board

O'Kief/Bateman

I've been trying to find information about my great-great-grandparents: John O'Kief from County Cork (b. 8-24-1818, Catholic) and Mary Bateman (b. 8-6-1824, to a wealthy Protestant family). I've traced them from Liverpool on the ship The West Point, which arrived in NYC on July 3, 1848. Mary had a twin sister, Susan, who left Liverpool with them. So far, I've found no birth o census records that correspond to any of the three. I would dearly lovely to find and visit the parish or general area where they were from. Help please! The family story is that Mary's father was landed gentry and from Scotland near the border with England. Her death records say she was born in Ireland though. Please help!

pkwerner

12 replies

Pkwerner:

Welcome to Ireland Reaching Out!

You would need to know the parents names of John and Mary in order to determine if there are church records available. John O'Keeffe would be a fairly common name and there were six Mary Batemans on Roots Ireland around 1824. There were no Susan Bateman records so I discounted the Mary records I located. Also, a good number of churches do not have records back to 1818-1824.

Have you consdiered autosomal DNA testing. Possibly you would match someone who has more info on the O'Keefes and Batemans.

Roger McDonnell

 

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Thanks much for your reply.  We've done some DNA testing but no promising matches so far.  I've also combed through all the records I've been able to find online.  My hope now is to find someone with a similar family story...two twin girls who ran away to America with an O'Keefe.  (We have every possible spelling of O'Keefe on my GGGrandfather's various US records--Kief, Keef, Keefe, etc.)  I even have my doubts that the girls' last name was Bateman (it may have been their mother's name) as apparently, they were panic-stricken that their father would track them down.  The family story goes that John "dropped the O in the ocean" as one way to avoid being followed.  In any case, I hope to visit Ireland later this year and would love suggestions on the Cork part of the trip as we are certain that John came from County Cork.  Best regards, Patty

pkwerner

Apart from the fact that your Mary was in the US in 1848, the family sounds very similar to mine.

Eliza/Elizabeth Bateman c.1821 was disowned for marrying a policeman, James Ryan b.1818. She had a sister, Mary or Mary Ann who visited during census in England in 1851. Eliza and James managed to buy property in a respected London suburb and had many heirlooms in the house according to my mother.

These Batemans of Cork intrigue me! Oh, and her grandaughter, my grandmother, was the god-daughter of the Earl of Carnarvon....

ozmcfall@yahoo.com

I am also looking for the Keefe/Batemans. John Keefe would be my 3xgreat grand father. I've uncovered about as much as you have pkwerner. You mentioned having had DNA done. My mother and I both have kits that should be arriving tomorrow. I have also heard the story of 'her' being a titled lady and running away with the lackey or something of that sort from my mother. I found a similar story on the other side of my tree (Davidson's-same generation) and wondered if my mom hadn't remembered correctly which side that story belonged to. Looks like it may be both. My Keefe tree is still in the early stages, but I'd be willing to put heads together if I find anything. We will be making a trip to Oshkosh next week to visit someone back in my mom's family that may have more information for us. This lady is in her 90s but we're hopiong she may have some tales to tell.

driftlessgirl@…

Driftlessgirl, we are most likely relatives as I believe there is a Davidson connected to our tree.  There are also Davidson headstones with other Keefes in the Winneconne Wi cemetery (near Oshkosh) where John and Mary Keefe are buried.  I have a good deal of information about John and Mary Keefe beginning with their boarding of the West Point in Liverpool in 1848, but little information before that.  I do have a picture and newspaper articles about John Keefe, also.  I will be curious to hear the outcome of your visit with relatives.  Let's try to connect by the fall (I will be out of touch till late August).  Best regards, Patty
 

pkwerner

Yes two Davidson brothers married both of John and Mary Keefe's girls. My line comes from George Blake Davidson and Mary Ellen Keefe. George's brother, Robert Bryden, married Mary Ellen's sister, Susan Keefe. I didn't know about the Bateman connection to Scotland! I mentioned to my mother about what you said about the Bateman's being a titled family in Scotland and apparently she had heard that as well and had written to Scotland at some point YEARS ago (before the internet) and they were unable to find a connection for her. All the records I've found on Mary Bateman show Ireland as her birthplace. I had been trying to research the Davidson's Scottish connection as George and Robert Bryden Davidson's grandfather is always listed as being from Scotland, but I can't pinpoint where exactly. It would be interesting to have another Scot tie by way of the Bateman's.

I was unable to find John Keefe on the 7/3/1848 Westpoint crossing. I just saw Mary and Susan Bateman. I'd love to see what you've been able to find. 

Yesterday we mailed out our Ancestry DNA tests so if you are registered with them maybe we'll be popping up on your radar shortly. I'll try and remember to pop back here later in the fall. 

driftlessgirl@…

Hey Patty! Just touching base. My mom and I both got DNA back from Ancestry.com and we have also uploaded it to Gedmatch. We met with relatives as I mentioned in my earlier posts. The only references we found in regard to the Keefe/Batemans were some photos. Not much in the way of information prior to their immigration. Kinda bummed. Had any luck on your end?

driftlessgirl@…

Hi again!  Sorry I haven't been back in touch...lots happening in our house.  I would love to trade all the notes I have with you and wonder how we could do that.  I live in Madison WI.  Any chance of meeting somewhere?  Of course, I'd need to get a little more organized first.  I have a full write-up that I did several years ago for my children, and I have notes and letters from my grandmother (Amanda Rose Keefe, daughter of John Keefe and Katherine Holzknecht).  Let me know if there might be a way to meet, and please do send me your name!

pkwerner

Hi Patty. No worries! I was doing some DNA stuff on Ancestry and after noticing I've had no matches back to the Keefe's it made me recall our conversation here. I'd love to meet up. I just moved from the Madison area actually. I'm now in Viola, 2hrs West of Madison on Hwy 14, but go to Madison every other weekend for my kids to visit their dad so I can definitely meet up with you there. Here is my email. (just ignore the spaces and of course replace 'dot' with the .com) We can swap contact info through email and set something up. My mother Joan Doll ( great granddaughter of Mary Ellen Keefe) would love to come as well. 

Kelly Marshall

d r i f t l e s s g i r l @ g m a i l d o t c o m

driftlessgirl@…

Patty & Kelly,

My mother was Rogene Schissler Hantke, daughter of Edith Keefe Schissler. Edith's father was Thomas Martin Keefe, son of John Keefe and Mary Bateman. For years, I've been stuck in the same place you are. The story that made it's way to me from my mother is that "Lady Mary Bateman" was disinherited because she ran off with the gardener. I don't have any tidbit of a clue that moves us further.

Kelly, your mother popped up as a DNA match from my Ancestry.com test, and we've been in contact. If/when I get any information, I'll be sure to pass it on to byou both.

 

-- Jonathan Hantke

 

IrelandXO member

Hello Jonathan! 

Nice to know we have another who is on the hunt with us! I am still plugging away on these three. I was able to find John Keefe's death certificate, which I posted to Ancestry. All I got from that was that his father's name was John Keefe from Ireland. The mother's information was blank. Not much help there. I just got the form to request Mary Bateman's death cert. Not sure if it will give any information on her parents or not. I'm tempted to get her sister Susan Bateman's as well.

After meeting with Patty, she informed me about a Susan Norris who was buried in the Keefe plot in Winneconne Cemetery. There is also record of a Thomas Norris being buried next to her but there is no headstone. The marker reads 'Aunt Susan'. Robert Keefe b.1867 was the younger brother of Thomas Martin Keefe that your family line stems from. Census records show Robert as head of the houshold when John and Mary were getting up there in age. If you see the 1880 census, Susan Norris is either living with them or next door as a border. Funny though, I haven't been able to find her on any other census prior to that. She is listed as 'widowed' in 1880. According to Winneconne Cemetery, the Susan buried there died 9.20.1887.  We are convinced this is Mary's sister Susan who came with them from Ireland. 

I have been working the Bateman angle by way of DNA as well. I am matching to a group of Batemans in Mansfield, Piatt County Illinois. I've recently been in contact with a man named Jim Bateman. He is 85. He says his grandfather was from County Cork. He also says there were two separate Bateman families in Mansfield, IL. One group who came from Canada, the other from somewhere out east coast. Due to other DNA matches from Ancestry, it looks like Jim and I are connected to the group that came from Cork to Canada then to IL. Jim did not know his grandfather and since it was quite a while ago that he saw the birth certificate, he said he'd need to check and see if it had any more information. I'm really hoping Mary's death certificate will help shed some light as well.

It doesn't look like I showed up as a match for you on Ancestry. My email is driftlessgirl@gmail.com Please do stay in contact! 

Kelly

 

driftlessgirl@…

Hi Jonathan, I’m headed to Ireland in about two weeks and will be meeting with several people who’ve been helping me with both Keefes and Batemans.  If you send me your email, I’ll put you in my list of Keefe cousins and will send a few pictures! Best regards, Patty W., granddaughter of Amanda Keefe 

pkwerner

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.