Hello Jonathan!
Nice to know we have another who is on the hunt with us! I am still plugging away on these three. I was able to find John Keefe's death certificate, which I posted to Ancestry. All I got from that was that his father's name was John Keefe from Ireland. The mother's information was blank. Not much help there. I just got the form to request Mary Bateman's death cert. Not sure if it will give any information on her parents or not. I'm tempted to get her sister Susan Bateman's as well.
After meeting with Patty, she informed me about a Susan Norris who was buried in the Keefe plot in Winneconne Cemetery. There is also record of a Thomas Norris being buried next to her but there is no headstone. The marker reads 'Aunt Susan'. Robert Keefe b.1867 was the younger brother of Thomas Martin Keefe that your family line stems from. Census records show Robert as head of the houshold when John and Mary were getting up there in age. If you see the 1880 census, Susan Norris is either living with them or next door as a border. Funny though, I haven't been able to find her on any other census prior to that. She is listed as 'widowed' in 1880. According to Winneconne Cemetery, the Susan buried there died 9.20.1887. We are convinced this is Mary's sister Susan who came with them from Ireland.
I have been working the Bateman angle by way of DNA as well. I am matching to a group of Batemans in Mansfield, Piatt County Illinois. I've recently been in contact with a man named Jim Bateman. He is 85. He says his grandfather was from County Cork. He also says there were two separate Bateman families in Mansfield, IL. One group who came from Canada, the other from somewhere out east coast. Due to other DNA matches from Ancestry, it looks like Jim and I are connected to the group that came from Cork to Canada then to IL. Jim did not know his grandfather and since it was quite a while ago that he saw the birth certificate, he said he'd need to check and see if it had any more information. I'm really hoping Mary's death certificate will help shed some light as well.
It doesn't look like I showed up as a match for you on Ancestry. My email is driftlessgirl@gmail.com Please do stay in contact!
Kelly