Back to Message Board

My long search for Charles M. O'Brien

My great-great grandfather Charles M. O'Brien left no record of WHERE in Ireland he was from, and we are not even sure when he came to the USA.

What we know:

Charles M. O'Brien (we don't know what the M stood for) likely born 29 September 1848 in Ireland.

His parents were said to be Charles O'Brien and Mary Hammond. There is no indication they came to the US. This information was given at the time of his death in 1929 so we do not know how accurate it might be.

He was in Connecticut by 1875 for that is when his first child was born. I personally believe he came in the early 1870s as I've not been able to find a likely candidate in the US census for that year.

He was married to Mary Elizabeth Cassidy (b. 1852 presumably in Ireland, d. 1893). His first three children were Joseph, Frances, and Charles M. Jr (my great grandfather). After Mary died he married Martha Birmingham and had two daughters, Catherine and Gertrude. While the second family inherited all of Charles' possessions, they do not seem to hold any knowledge of where in Ireland he was from.

Charles was a horseshoer in Connecticut; I was once told the story by a grandson of the second marriage that he was in training for the ministry else when an accident left him deaf in one ear. We cannot verify this story. To the best of our knowledge he was a Roman Catholic the entire time he was in Connecticut.

There seems to be some possibility that he was a cousin of a Michael O'Brien who is known to have been a native of Garnmore, parish of Dualla, Tipperary, who was in the US by 1861. Michael's brothers are known to be Stephen, Thomas, John, James and he had a sister Mary. I've not yet been able to verify this yet, it is based on a possibly DNA connection with someone who has two O'Brien lines but whose research is poorly documented.

Charles M. O'Brien (senior) died in 1929 and is buried in New Haven Connecticut. There was some estrangement in the familiy; his son Charles M. O'Brien (junior) died in 1928 of delerium tremens and his daughter Evelyn (my grandmother) never talked about her parents or grandparents as far as anyone recalls.

Over several decades I've tried to find more about where Charles came from, and I spent quite awhile working with Griffith's and the Tithe books cataloging the locations of O'Briens and Hammonds to see where it was likely that an O'Brien/Hammond marriage might have been. Tipperary and Limerick seem most likely. I've been to Dublin and searched, but with such little location information it really has proved impossible.

I'd be grateful for anything that can help link my Charles M. O'Brien to a place in Ireland. Thank you for reading this.

ersmoot

6 replies

Hi Elizabeth

There is a baptism record of Elizabeth Cassidy 7 March 1852 on www.rootsireland.ie/

Parish is St Paul's Arran Quay R C county Dublin; parents Thomas Cassidy and Jane Rogers

I couldn't find a marriage record fo her + Charles O'Brien however.

I couldn't find a marriage record of Charles O + Mary Hammond either or a birth/baptism record for young Charles.

I noticed on ancestry that a public member tree has a JOHN O'Brien married to a Mary Hammond.

www.irishgenealogy.ie/ (free site) has a couple of O'Brien baptism records including a Charles O'Brien 1845 St Andrew R C Dublin but the parents are not Charles & Mary!

rootsireland has quite a few baptisms of Charles O'Brien around 1848 but none with the parents you have.

There is 1 in Tipperary parish is LORRHA; neither Garnmore or Dualla was in the list of parishes in Tipperary North.

Col

 

 

ColCaffIrelandXO Volunteer

Thank you so much for this Col, I'll check out those leads - will report back here when I make progress!

Regards,

Elizabeth

ersmoot

Elizabeth,

I read your query with great interest. I was unable to find a Charles M in the local baptismal records of my parish of Boherlahan-Dualla. But if you google Tipperary Heritage Unit you will get access to a site that has access to all the baptismal and marriage records of the archdiocese of Cashel and Emly. There is a charge for the search.

Garranmore is a townland in the parish of Boherlahan-Dualla, which is located north of the town of Cashel, Co. Tipperary and in the heart of the archdiocese. In the 1830s, there were three Brien/ Bryan families living in the townland. Only one survived the Great Famine of 1845-50 and descendants of that family only died out in the townland in the 1950s. According to local lore, the two other Brien families emigrated to America sometime between late 1848 and mid 1850. They were known as the Little and the Big Briens, most likely to do with the size of their farms. The ruins of their dwellings were only removed in living memory. If you have information on the descendants of these families I would be interested as my parish produces an annual historical journal.

I can forward you the names of the Brien families in Garranmore if you so desire.

Best of luck with your research and I hope that this reply points you in the right direction.

Paddy 

  

IrelandXO member

Elizabeth:

I, too, am hitting brick walls with my O'Brien ancestor.  However, I have read with great interest your biography of your great-great-grandfather and I am hoping mine is related to him.

I see your post was nearly two years ago and I hope you have had success in breaking down the wall.  My ancestor is Stephen O'Brien, my great-great-grandfather.  When you wrote that your Charles could possibly be a cousin of Michael O'Brien who lived in New Haven, Conn. and that Michael's brothers were Stephen, Thomas, John, James and Mary, I was stunned.    My Stephen O'Brien was naturalized in New Haven, Conn.in 1869.  His children's names are James, John, Thomas, Charles and Mary, all names that you have listed including your great-great-grandfather.  My ancestor Stephen's son James O'Brien had Matthew as his middle name, so I wonder if that could have been the middle name of your Charles M. O'Brien.

Like you, I have been unable to locate where in Ireland my Stephen O'Brien lived, but after reading your post, I am hoping that my ancestor and yours are cousins.

I hope you read this so that we possibly can share information.

Please reply is you wish.

Regards,

Cindy O'Brien Lee

 

cindyobrien

Hello Cindy, thanks for writing.

I've made almost no progress on the O'Briens, and haven't really worked on it at all in the past few years due to too much other work and family things going on!  I thought I had made a good contact but we couldn't figure out where the connection might be.

But what I will do is try to take a look at this and see if I can make it fit, maybe when I have some time over Christmas? 

If you are on Facebook please friend me there (under Betsy Rohaly Smoot) and I can send you message with my email - if not, will figure something out!

 

Elizabeth

ersmoot

Hello Betsy:

Thanks for writing back.  I will friend you on Facebook.  Your post renewed my conviction that I am making progress.  Our family names have too many similarities to ignore, plus, my gg-grandfather lived in New Haven, Conn. so I am sure we are related.  I am going to continue to pursue this connection with you and together perhaps we can find the one big answer we both are looking for.....where did our ancestors come from?

I look forward to continuing to communicate with you and hopefully, we will break down that wall.

Regards,

Cindy O'Brien Lee

cindyobrien

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.