Check the US censuses in the 20th century to see when they arrved in the US. If they came at different times, they might have married in the US. New Jersey has marriage records from that time period. You would at least get Sarah's maiden name from the marriage record and likely the parents' names of both.
Also, if they did emigrate in the 20th century 1905 or later, the ship passenger list will give their birth place, person they are going to see (and relationship and address) and nearest relative back at home. Also, see if Thomas became a citizen. That is also a question on the census. Naturalization records may contain more useful info if he was naturalized in the 20th century.
Reports on the census of the year of arrival do tend to vary over time. Try using the date from the earliest census--closest to the time of arrival.
Nora in Connecticut