Back to Message Board

Mobility of families in the early-to-mid-1800s

I wonder whether anyone can help me with a very general question. I am trying to identify four of my great-grandparents, whose names are known. They were born around 1825-35, from around the counties of Limerick, Waterford, Tipperary and Cork.

With improved access to parish records, the problem has become, not too little information, but too much. I have observed that, where I can confirm family names on my Irish branches, the traditional naming patterns work on 8 out of 12 known instances. So, that is a tentative way of refining some avenues of exploration. And I wonder also if there might be any relevance of baptismal sponsors in revealing family connections.

But here is my question:

If a couple is going to marry then their paths must cross at some point. At what separation by place of birth does it become improbable that two people are likely to meet? In other words, how mobile was the Irish population in the early to mid-1800s? To give a specific example, if two people married in Rathkeale in 1855 then how far away should I be looking for their likely places of origin? Next townland? Next parish? Within the same county?

I know the question is impossible, and I know that gulfs can be bridged depending on circumstances (myself and my wife for example). But, I feel there ought to be some way of applying a rough-and-ready territorial filter, in line with custom and practise at the time, so that possibilities can be reduced to varying degrees of probabilities.

Any advice would be gratefully received!

Chris Power

2 replies

Chris:

Welcome back!

A couple years ago I would have responded that the couple was likely from the same parish or perhaps a neighboring parish. However, based on information from DNA matches, I think that they were more mobile than you would think. For example, my McDonnell great-great grandfather was married in 1837 in East Mayo so I assumed they were there for generations, however, Y-DNA has shown that in the late 1700s the McDonnells were lived in the most western part of Mayo. So either my great-great grandfather or his father moved sixty miles east to the other end of Mayo. I also have a Brennan line that moved fifty miles north from Leitrim into Donegal at some point in the early 1800s.

Also, you need to consider where in a county an event occurred to see if you need to consider looking  at bordering counties. Rathkeale is in the middle of Limerick but if the marriage occured in Abbeyfeale, you would need to also look at bordering parishes in Kerry and Cork.

Roger McDonnell

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Thanks Roger - I'm sure you're right, but not really what I was hoping to hear! With names like Daly/Healy/Keeffe/Power I have far too many possibilities. Even applying naming patterns to the parents I'm still left with too many to focus in on. But what you say does lend credance to another instance that has bothered me. My grandfather's parents were Maurice Power and Sara Cunningham. There is only one recorded marriage - in Portlaw, County Waterford - with three children born there. But my grandfather seems to have been born a year later in Nenagh, County Tipperary. The chronological sequence fits, and there are no other couples recorded with those names, but it bothered me to explain such an abrupt relocation. But I surmise from what you would have said formerly that the most likely pairings are from within the same or a neighbouring parish.

Chris

Chris Power

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.