The name McNeill is fairly common around Larne and in Co Antrim generally. I looked at the 1851 census for Larne but did not see a household with Archibald as head, and Charles and Malcolm as sons. However the census is incomplete and so your family may be in the part that has been lost. I did note the following McNeill houses which had the names Archibald and Malcolm in them, though that might just be a coincidence:
Mill Brae, Larne
WM, McNEILLE, 51 ,Head, Married ,1822 , FARM SERVANT ,Antrim ,R/W
ELIZABETH McNEILLE, 50 ,Wife, Married ,1822 , SEXTON ,Antrim ,R/W
JANE McNEILLE, 20 ,Daughter,Unmarried ,, SEAMSTRESS ,Antrim ,R/W
Absent from Household 30th March 1851:
JOHN McNEILLE, 26 ,Son , BUTLER {England}
WILLIAM McNEILLE, 24 ,Son , GROOM {America}
ADAM McNEILLE, 22 ,Son , SAILOR {At Sea}
ARCHIE McNEILLE, 21 ,Son , SAILOR {At Sea}
ELIYN McNEILLE, 17 ,Daughter , HOUSE SERVANT {Antrim}
MARY McNEILLE, 14 ,Daughter , HOUSE SERVANT {Antrim}
MARGARET McNEILLE, 13 ,Daughter , HOUSE SERVANT {Antrim}
Curran & Drumalis townland:
MALCOLM McNEILL, 58 ,Head, Married ,1831 , LAND PROPRIETOR & FARMER , Antrim ,R/W
LUCIZA McNEILL, 45 ,Wife, Married ,1831 , GENTLEWOMAN ,Scotland ,R/W
ISABELLA McNEILL, 53 ,Sister,Unmarried ,, GENTLEWOMAN ,Antrim ,R/W
MARGARET McNEILL, 15 ,Daughter,Unmarried ,, AT SCHOOL ,Antrim ,R/W
DUNCAN McNEILL, 13 ,Son,Unmarried ,, AT SCHOOL ,Antrim ,R/W
HESTER McNEILL, 10 ,Daughter,Unmarried ,, AT SCHOOL ,Antrim ,R/W
JANE MONTGOMERY, 48 ,Sister,Widow , Married 1845 , GENTLEWOMAN , Antrim ,R/W
JANE MILLAR, 34 ,Servant,Unmarried ,, SERVANT ,Antrim ,R/W
MARGARET CLEMENTS, 18 ,Servant,Unmarried ,, SERVANT ,Antrim ,R/W
ELIZA McILWAINE, 18 ,Servant,Unmarried ,, SERVANT ,Antrim ,R/W
MARGARET MARTIN, 20 Unmarried ,, GOVERNESS ,Scotland ,R/W
ALEXANDER McNEILL, 8 ,Son,Unmarried ,, AT SCHOOL ,Scotland ,R/W
Absent from Household 30th March 1851:
MALCOLM McNEILL, Jr,, 18 ,Son , MERCHANT'S OFFICER {Liverpool}
JOHN McNEILL, 16 ,Son , SCHOOL {Wimbledon}
Died Since 6th June 1841:
JAMES McBRUTNEY, 24 ,Tutor , TUTOR , Inflammation , Autumn 1849
HELEN LUIZA McNEILL, 6 ,Daughter , NONE , Whooping Cough , Spring 1851
PRONI has some probate absracts that relate ot people named Archibald McNeill eg
The Will of Archibald M'Neill late of Killyglen County Antrim of no occupation deceased who died 20 July 1868 at same place was proved at Belfast by the oaths of John M'Neill and James M'Neill both of Blackcave (Larne) in said County Farmers the Executors.
Letters of Administration (with the Will annexed) of the personal estate of Archibald M'Neill late of Isbawn County Antrim Farmer who died 13 March 1891 at same place were granted at Belfast to Daniel M'Neill of Isbawn Farmer a Legatee.
(The above will is on-line and mentions a son Charles.
Probate of the Will of Archibald M'Neill late of Carnlough County Antrim Farmer who died 11 December 1880 granted at Belfast to Esther M'Neill the Widow and William M'Galliard Farmer.
Do you know exactly where your family lived and what denomination they were? That may enable you to search the relevant church records.
There were around 70 people named McNeill in the town in the 1911 census.