Back to Message Board

McMahons of New York, USA

Hello all. name is Dow and I hope you may be able to help with some guidance. My sister-in-law's mother was a McMahon. She is planning a trip to Ireland this summer and I'm looking into that part of her family tree. I've learned from two marriage licenses and newspaper obituaries that her fifth generation family was:

John McMahon Birth: Ireland & Mary Flavin Birth: Ireland (according to two marriage license)Children:(1) Andrew J. McMahon (her great grandfather) b: 1869 in New York d: 16 Aug 1932 in Groton, Tompkins County, New York(2) Eleanor McMahon b: abt. 1875 in New York d: 28 Jan 1957(3) Patrick Michael McMahon b: 24 Jul 1875 d: 17 Nov 1948(4) Julia F. McMahon b: 1877 d: 17 Jun 1932 in Binghamton, Broome County, New York(5) Ellen D. McMahonBirth: 1880Death: 1932(6) Margaret Theresa McMahonBirth: 19 May 1886 in Binghamton, Broome County, New York(7) Anna L. McMahonBirth: Abt. 1889 in New YorkDeath: 21 Feb 1920 in Binghampton, New York (8) Elizabeth McMahon (9) John McMahonDeath: Bef. 1932

Thus far I have not found John or Mary on any emmigration / immigration records or confirmed on any census reports. While I continue searching; any information, suggestions or possible connections with John and Mary Flavin McMahon is most appreciated. Thank you!

IrelandXO member

8 replies

I had a look on www,rootsireland.ie/ for John McMahons born 1840 + - 5 years in all counties and got 336 matches! There are 25 for Mary Flavin for the same years.

Can you give an approximate birth year to narrow them down? 

I assume none of the US Censuses has a county of birth for either of them?

Col

 

ColCaffIrelandXO Volunteer

Thank you for looking!  Unfortunately the only information from the two wedding license was "John Mcmahon" and "Mary Flavin" both from "Ireland"; no age or County.  My due diligence; I've been looking for a John + Mary + Andrew J. on the 1870 and 1880 US Federal Census with nothing concrete.  And like your results, searching the immigration records is yielding quite a few John and Marys.  Maybe they arrived as a couple or maybe met and married over here?  And I've seen entries saying there are many spelling variations of Flavin.  My sister-in-law and my brother fly over at the end of July and will have a grand time even if I can't say, "Hey, spend some extra time in County ___."  :-)  

IrelandXO member

One other thought I've had is that while the 1917 marriage license for Julia F. McMahon gives their names and county of birth the obituary for Anna L. McMahon who died in the home of Julia and her husband Percy W. Singer listed her five sisters and three brothers but does not mention her parents.  That might mean they had died before 1920.  No "ah-ha!" moments at findagrave.com yet either.   

IrelandXO member

Bingo!  1900 US Federal Census Cortland County, New York in the household of her son John, as enumerated:  Mary McMahon born Aug 1840 age 59, widow, birthplace Ireland as were both her parents.  Date of immigration 1863, number of children 12, 11 living.  Two VERY important clues; Aug 1840 and 1863.  :-)   

IrelandXO member

There are 4 Mary Flavin baptisms in 1840 but 3 are before August leaving this one:

Name:Mary Ann FlahavanDate of Birth:
Date of Baptism:07-Nov-1840Address:
Parish/District:CAPPOQUINGender:
CountyCo. Waterford
Denomination:Roman Catholic
Father:Michael FlahavanMother:Catherine MulloneyOccupation:
Sponsor 1 /
Informant 1:Michael Clemens Sponsor 2 /
Informant 2:Margaret Coughlan 

A baptism 4 months after birth may be unusual but by no means impossible.

However the following looks promising - same parish:

 Name:John McMahonDate of Birth:
Date of Baptism:24-May-1833Address:
Parish/District:CAPPOQUINGender:
CountyCo. Waterford
Denomination:Roman Catholic
Father:Patrick McMahonMother:Mary PowerOccupation:
Sponsor 1 /
Informant 1:Mathew Beary Sponsor 2 /
Informant 2:Johanna Driscoll

Couldn't find a Waterford marriage for them.

Col

ColCaffIrelandXO Volunteer

This collaboration is fantastic.  I located Mary's obituary from Dec 19, 1917.  The seven daughters and three sons listed match with previous news articles BUT the significant puzzle piece was the mentioning of a BROTHER; "Michael Flavin of Brooklyn"!!  Of course my first thought was why couldn't his name be unique to the family and easier to trace like Rufus.  :-)  So between chores and other projects my newspaper, familysearch and ancestry accounts are getting a workout.  When I update my sister-in-law her responce has been "Wow!"  Ever grateful for the assist. 

IrelandXO member

BINGO!!

Name:Michael FlahavanDate of Birth:
Date of Baptism:04-Sep-1845Address:
Parish/District:CAPPOQUINGender:
CountyCo. Waterford
Denomination:Roman Catholic
Father:Michael FlahavanMother:Catherine MulloneyOccupation:
Sponsor 1 /
Informant 1:William HoganSponsor 2 /
Informant 2:Ellen Chearnle

Col

ColCaffIrelandXO Volunteer

It would seem I need to tell her to be sure County Waterford is on the itinerary and not to rush through Cappoquin.  :-)

IrelandXO member

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.