Back to Message Board

McGuire, Patrick and John, sons of James

Hello. My maternal great grandfather and his brother were born in Ireland and came to Philadelphia, PA., USA.

My great grandfather was Patrick McGuire, born 1827, according to his Naturalization Record and came here about 1857. His brother John McGuire, born 1838, joined him here and I don't know if they came at the same time.

John McGuire died young, due to a fall, in 1870. His brother Patrick signed the Death Certificate and the physician wrote in Ireland for the Country of Birth and he wrote in County Loude for the County of Birth. I have been told, and searched, and find that there is no county in Ireland called Loude. My guess is that Patrick told the physician the county and the doctor wrote what he heard. Maybe with his brogue or accent, Patrick said County Louth???

On that death certificate is lists John's father as James McGuire. No mother's name is listed. Patrick and John were farmers.

I am trying to find out if the county was most likely County Louth and I would love to find records for them, for instance, birth, death of James and wife, etc.

Thank you for any help or ideas you have.

Alice Marnell Galcik

joegalcik@cs.com

9 replies

Dear Alice

Welcome to Ireland Reaching Out!

I have had a look but couldn't locate any baptism for a Patrick born to a father James in Co. Louth between 1822-1832 but there is a possible baptism for a John born to a father James and a mother Mary Cunningham. You can see the baptism here in the parish of Collon - it is on the right hand side of the image but difficult to read. He was baptised on 07/05/1833 and sponsors recorded were Pat Carlan and Catherine Powderly.

There is a second John baptised in 1837 to a father James and a mother Mary Kirwan in the parish of Collon also. You can see his baptism here for 05/06/1837. Sponsors were Thomas Haligan and Bridget Reid.

However there is no way for me to know which is your family in Co. Louth or if they are an entirely different one. Did Patrick have any other siblings besides John? 

There are also about 40 McGuire entries on the Tithe Applotment Books in the 1830s:

http://titheapplotmentbooks.nationalarchives.ie/search/tab/results.jsp?…

Let me know if you have any further info that could verify or discount the above

Best wishes

Clare Doyle

Genealogy Support 

IrelandXO member

Good Morning: Dear Clare Doyle:   Thank you for your reply.  I appreciate you searching and am checking out the information on the two John McGuire's you gave me information on.  I don't know the names of any other siblings Patrick and John had.  I will search the Philadelphia area for the two names of the possible mothers of John McGuire that you found Baptism records for.  I will contact you with another question or information as I think of it.  I did however forget to mention that they were Catholic.  Thanks again and have a good day.  Alice Marnell Galcik

joegalcik@cs.com

Great Alice, keep in touch!

Best wishes

Clare

Genealogy Support 

IrelandXO member

Dear Clare Doyle:

MESSAGE:  MARNELL, JOHN, BORN IN QUEENS COUNTY, IRELAND IN 1832, AN RIC PENSIONER

 

I am hoping you can help me again or point me in the right direction.

I am searching for a bastism record for my paternal great grandfather, John Marnell, born in 1832 in Queens County, which I know is now Laois.  He married Mary Anne Kane in Armagh and I have that information from census records and relatives.    I have some information from census records in Ireland, a possible marriage record from Armagh and his RIC Records which I sent for and received with the help of Mr. John Herlihy.  I would like to find a baptism/birth record and hope it has the names of his parents.  I found a marriage record on Ancestry and the date corresponds to the marriage date on his RIC records and that date is 5/8/1866 in Armagh.  There is, I think, an error in transcription on the marriage record because it lists for the 3rd of August, 1866Tandragee, Armagh,  a James Marnill and a John Marnill and a Mary Ann Kane and a Mary Anne Kane.  I have a feeling the names were not very clear so they were transcribed both ways.  Possible?  Anyway, for the James Marnill, it lists Father as Rody Marnill and Spouse as Mary Anne Kane.  So, I think my great grandfather's father was Rody Marnell.  I did search a Baptism Record Book on Ancestry and found a John Marnell born 1837, Baptism: 8 of October, 1837 in Mountrath, Laois with parents Peter and Mary Marnell.  So maybe he (born 1837) is a different John Marnell.  Here is the information I have taken from his RIC records.

No. 17096

John Marnell

Age When Appointed:  21

Native County:  Queens

Religion:  Catholic

If Married, Date:  5/8/1866

Native County of Wife:  Armagh

Appointment Date:  17/5/1853, Re-Attested: 2/12/1856

County of Service:  Tyrone 10/9/1853; Londonderry; Antrim 1/11/1856

Pensioned:  1/2/1887

That is most of the information from his RIC Records. 

His 6 children that lived out of 13 (from census records) were

Joseph M. (my grandfather), Dennis Roderick, William, Edward, Catherine, Margaret

Most if not all of the children were born in County Antrim.  My father lived in Belfast.

I know I just gave you a lot of information.  I don't want to go with John's parents as Peter and Mary because the baptism date is 1837, not 1832, which is what he has on his RIC Record and the marriage record lists his father as Rody.

Any information you can give me regarding my great grandfather (John Marnell), his bastism date and name of parents would be greatly appreciated.

Clare:  I don't know if I should have started a completely new Message for this posting or it is ok here.  Please let me know for future postings.

Thank you and have a good evening.

Sincerely,  Alice Marnell Galcik

I found a Marriage Record on Ancestry for a John Marnill (WHICH I BELIEVE SHOULD BE MARNELL)

 

 

joegalcik@cs.com

Clare:

I posted Alice's message here into the other new message.

Roger

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Thanks Roger

Clare 

IrelandXO member

Dear Alice

I have had a look at the marriage between James and Mary and cannot say for sure if it the correct one. I wouldn't get too caught up on finding the exact spelling though as often times there is room for maneuver and the fact that the dates match with what you know is a good sign on that marriage record in Co. Down. The surname isn't terribly common and so finding anyone with that name on a record is a good enough basis to examine it more closely. You won't actually find a birth record for John as he was born prior to 1864 when civil registration began in Ireland. 

You do have to measure up the following.; the likelihood that there were two men of similar age and first name in the RIC from Laois at that time (yes, a possibility) the spread of the family name in the area (4 Marnell families from what I can see listed in the 19th Century Griffith's Valuation) and what other info you have that might substantiate this marriage as yours or help you tick it off the list as irrelevant. I think you are going to have to add it to the 'possible' pile and keep it in mind as you continue your research. 

There are 9 Marnell baptisms that I can find for the period 1827-1837 and only 2 for Laois one 05-Sep-1835 to Mick and a Mary Young and the other on 1 Oct 1837 to Peter and a Mary no surname. You might have an information gathering exercise on your hands here. If I were you I would collect all your possibilities and actually print them out and add notes as to what you know about the above baptisms on the off-chance that either one is relevant. Do the sponsors names mean anything for example? You can find them on rootsireland.ie or through Ancestry.com and the originals (though hard to read) on the National Library website register.nli.ie. Has there been any newspaper articles mentioning John either?

Best wishes

Clare 

Genealogy Support 

IrelandXO member

Hi Clare:  Thanks you for researching.  I will keep an open mind about the spelling of names, etc.  Yes, John Marnell does appear in newspaper articles regarding his constable activities.  I tried to reply to you in the last few days but I kept getting a "connection problem".  Thanks again and have a good day.

 

joegalcik@cs.com

Hi Alice

Sorry about that -- we have had a few technical issues, all is ok now again

Best wishes

Clare

Genealogy Support 

IrelandXO member

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.