Back to Message Board

McArthur or McCarter or McCarters - possibly from Dublin

Help with locating these people in Ireland would be welcome. The information I have comes from Scottish records.

1. John McArthur orMcCarters (born in Ireland between 1813 and 1819) m. Margaret Fletcher (born in Ireland between 1819 and 1821). They married in 1840 in Scotland. Margaret Fletcher was the daughter of Joseph Fletcher and Elizabeth Sloane. The name McArthur seems originally in Ireland to have been McCarters or McCarter and this usage pesisted for some time in Scotland. Family lore has it that John McArthur/McCarters came from Dublin where he had been a publican. This would fit with his profession being given in early Scottish returns as Spirit Merchant.

2.John McCarters/McArthur and Margaret Fletcher had a son, Joseph, born in 1842 in Scotland. In 1866 he married Helen McMillan, who had been born in Irleand in 1843. Helen McMillan's parents were John McMillan (son of John McMillan and Helen Burke) and Isabella Purdie (daughter of John Purdie and ?). Bothe John McMillan and Isabella Purdie were born in Ireland (about 1798 and 1810, respectively) and presumably married in Ireland about 1828 . Their many children were born in Ireland apart from the youngest, which would put the date of their emigration from Ireland to Scotland between 1847 and 1851,

GordonMcKechnie

2 replies

Dear Gordon

Welcome to Ireland Reaching Out! 

Do you know the family's religion? Surviving records for the various denominations exist in Dublin and if you knew which denomination it would narrow the search somewhat.It is good that you think you might know John's profession as you could search the likes of Find My Past to see if he is mentioned in any Trade or other directories. You could also search HERE for free to see if the McCarthur name or variants of the spelling is listed in Dublin City in the mid 1820s.

The majority of surviving parish records for Church of Ireland and Roman Catholic denominations are indexed online at irishgenealogy.ie. A search between 1810-25 found that a John McCarthur was baptised in St. James's Church of Ireland in 1819 (the day and month are not legible but you can see the digitised image here). This could be your John. Parents are listed as Peter and Catherine McArthur. This seems to be the only baptism for the variants of the surname during this period for a child named John. A search of marriages for a McCathur did not locate any marriages. Neither could I locate a Church of Ireland baptism for a Margaret Fletcher (assuming Margaret as not Roman Catholic) or for any of their children despite a wider search for county Dublin too. It could be that the records of these baptisms no longer exist or have yet to be indexed.  

Although the 1851 Census was mostly destroyed there are some surviving fragments that show the head of household but no one by the name of McCarthur/McArthur/McCarter. As I say above, a search of Find My Past might provide additional info. 

There are a couple of weak possibilities in relation to the baptism of John McMillan but assuming he too was not Roman Catholic and born in Dublin rules these out. The 1851 Census does not seem to list any Purdie family. There does not seem to be any record of the baptisms of the children of John and Isabella in Ireland, or at least none surviving/available. 

I hope this is of some help to you.

Best wishes

Clare Doyle

Genealogy Support 

 

IrelandXO member

Thank you, Clare. That's interesting and gives me some leads to work on. I shall also see if I can track down Peter and /or Catherine McArthur in the Scottish records. If John McArthur was born in 1819 in Dublin and married in 1840 in Scotland, it may be that he went to Scotland with his parents. This in turn might mean that Margaret Fletcher and Helen McMillan (and their families), while born in Ireland according to Scottish records, might have come from elsewhere in Ireland than Dublin. I do not know what denomination any of these people were, but in Scotland their records are Church of Scotland.

GordonMcKechnie

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.