Hi again Roger!
What a small world:)
You will be happy to know that my DNA results led to a breakthrough! I heard from a distant cousin on the Madden side about 12 hours after I had posted this message and she led me to a breakthrough on John Madden's family and their records. He was actually baptized Michael Madden as he was his father's oldest son, but went by John.
His parent were Michael Madden and Margarita Silk. They had 8 children:
John, my GGGgrandfather, born 22 Jul 1840 Clontuskert, Galway, died 27 Feb 1874 in Scott Co. Iowa.
Bridget (1834-1862)
Annie (1841-unknown)
Margaret (1843-unknown)
Thomas (1846-1916)
Jacob (1849-1854)
Patrick (1850-unknown)
William (1852-1931)
Do you know how I might find more about John's father, Michael, or his mother and the Silk family? I've attached John/Michael's baptismal record and a handwritten family tree.