Back to Message Board

Looking for MacDougall/Dougall/Dougal

Looking for details on Samuel MacDougall who emigrated to America by 1768. Different lines of the family have different information about his roots, as follows:

One branch of the family says he came directly from Scotland to America in the 1760s. Another branch says the his family left Scotland several generations earlier and spent time in Ireland before heading to America. This branch is silent on the arrival time frame. One branch says he was born in 1744 (that's primarily those who believe he immigrated directly from Scotland); the other branch puts his birth in the mid-1720s. Most believe that the surname was MacDougall, with the Mac dropped at some point, but others feel that Mac was never part of the name. The name appears as Dougall and Dougal (one vs. 2 L's at the end) over the years since, though the use of 2 L's has been typical for the last 100 years or so. There are differences of opinion on the port at which Samuel arrived, with Baltimore and Philadelphia being mentioned. To my knowledge, no one has been able to document any of these theories about Samuel's arrival in America. And assuming that the Scotland to Ireland path is the correct one, no one has been able to determine what part of Ireland the family came from, although we are aware of more typical immigration paths.

I have documentation to prove the following: About 1767-68, he enrolled at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia. By that time, Mac was not part of his surname. He graduated in 1770. By about 1773 or 1774, he was a minister at a Presbyterian church in south central Pennsylvania. It was Cumberland County then, and within 10 years after his arrival, Cumberland split and his area was named Frankin County, which is still the case. He married Sarah Wilson of what was probably Lancaster County in Pennsylvania in 1774. They had 8 children before Samuel died in 1790. He remained in Franklin County, serving at the same church - Upper Path Valley Presbyterian in Spring Run, Pennsylvania - until his death and is buried in the church cemetery. His children, with one exception, stayed in Franklin County; one son, David, lived in Butler County in western Pennsylvania. The next generation, Samuel's grandchildren, did begin moving west, with my direct ancestor from that generation (another Samuel Dougall, the son of the first Samuel's eldest child, James) settling about 20 miles from Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, where many descendants still live. The family is fairly well documented from that point on.

I would be grateful for any information that you can provide. Many thanks,

Cindy in Maryland

IrelandXO member

1 reply

Cindy,

The Mc/Mac & O? prefixes in Irish names are not regarded as an integral part of the name, and are often omitted. Consequently it is common to see regular changes. Also, the concept of a single ?correct? spelling of a surname is not one that would have been recognised in Ireland or Scotland in the 1600s and 1700s and I wouldn?t worry about whether the name had one ?l? or two. The spelling will have varied according to the whim of the person recording the information. It can also have varied for grammatical reasons too, if gaelic were being spoken, depending on what case was being used.

From the surname, the dates of migration (ie 18th century) and the fact that Samuel ended up as a Presbyterian Minister, you have fairly clear evidence of Scottish origins. I can?t say though whether he came directly from Scotland or whether the family was in Ireland for a generation or two.

What is well documented is that in the 1600s some 100,000 Scots settled in Ireland (mainly in the counties of Ulster) as a part of the plantation of Ireland. (That would represent about 10% of the entire population of Scotland at that time). Some came in the 1500s, but the major migration started around 1606. There was a particularly significant rush in the 1690s due to famine in Scotland. They migrated to Ireland because of overpopulation in Scotland, increasing rents there and the opportunity of cheaper land in Ireland. In many cases they accompanied major land owners in Scotland who had been given land in Ireland by the Crown, in return for undertaking work to build key buildings and organize local defence forces etc.

During the 1700s, the new settlers faced a series of difficulties in Ireland. Rents rose, the linen industry underwent a slump and there were a series of bad harvests. In addition Presbyterians (and Catholics and others who were not members of the Church of Ireland) were discriminated against by legislation which prevented them from holding significant posts in government, and which also attempted to restrict their right to practice their religion. So for all of these reasons, many of the new settlers descendants often decided to move on. Principally to the USA though they went elsewhere too, especially after the War of Independence. So over a period of 100 years, some 200,000 Ulster Scots, as they are known in Ireland, left Ireland and moved to the USA and what is now Canada. So Samuel?s arrival in the USA fits perfectly with that well established migration. But that doesn?t prove he came from Ireland. He could just as easily have come directly from Scotland, as many did.

The first major problem you face in Ireland is that there are very few records for the 1700s, and if you don?t know where in Ireland your ancestor may have lived, then it?s the proverbial needle in a haystack. Early Presbyterians in Ireland weren?t very good at keeping record of baptism and marriages. Or if they did keep them, they weren?t very good at looking after them. As a consequence, whilst there were several hundred Presbyterian churches in Ireland in the 1700s, today there are only a handful with any records for the 1700s. Perhaps less than 20. You could search those records in the hopes that you are lucky and Samuel is recorded there. (You would need some idea of what his parents names were to be sure of finding the right record). Such records as do exist for Presbyterian churches in Ireland are held in PRONI (the public record office) in Belfast and in the Presbyterian Historical Association, also in Belfast. Their early records are not on-line and a personal visit is generally required to view them.

Save for the major landholders, no records were kept of the settlers who moved from Scotland to Ireland in the 1600s. Similarly no records were routinely kept of people who left Ireland in the 1700s.

Elwyn

Ahoghill AntrimIrelandXO Volunteer

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.