I stumbled across this in searching for James Handy, born October 4, 1837. This is my husband's 2 X great grandfather. You said that you had a family Bible. May I ask what line that would have been passed down through? James and Sarah Jane Atkinson's son, Harrison, is my husband's great grandfather. Harrison had a son named James who is his grandfather. His father's name is Harrison, born in 1921. Harrison and my husband's mother, Dorothy were divorced when my husband was 7. He saw VERY little of him through most of his life. I have tried to pull together his father's side of the family together since the early 2000's.
Have you been to or seen the Handy Farm iin Cynthiana, KY where James and Sarah Jane were placed in the 1870 census? We went twice and viewed the town, a museum, and the farm but we have yet to make a connection. We are interested in finding out if there is any.