Sharon,
Your Latimer being a military man of English descent seems very reasonable. I mentioned previously that Latimer was not a native Irish name. I probably also should have added that as the family were Church of Ireland (which is the Church of England, in Ireland) then that too points to English, or sometimes Scottish, origins. Most native Irish would be RC. Incomers tend to be Presbyterian or Church of Ireland. Like the Scots the Latimers probably arrived in the 1600s, either as part of the Plantation of Ireland or perhaps as part of later arrivals. Some of Cromwell’s army were granted land in Ireland in the mid 1600s for supporting him, for example.
So it looks as though your Latimer family probably originated in England and your Ransoms in Scotland. And you wonder what your forebears are. It’s all very much how you choose to perceive it. The Duke of Wellington (victor at Waterloo and then later Prime Minister) did not treat the Irish at all well. However he was born in Ireland and someone pointed out to the great Irish patriot, Daniel O’Connell, that Wellington was therefore as Irish as he was. O’Connell is reported to have said (in an after dinner speech on 1st October 1843): "The poor old Duke! What shall I say of him? To be sure he was born in Ireland, but being born in a stable does not make a man a horse." Source:
http://nwhyte.livejournal.com/1154775.html
So was Wellington Irish, English or what? Would his ethnic origins have troubled him? I leave that to you to decide. Ethnicity is a tricky subject. People sometimes get worked up about it. They want to know if they are Irish, Scottish, Viking or whatever. Like your husband, I am not quite sure why, but there’s no doubt there’s a lot of interest in it.
According to the London Times on 16th June 2019, Professor Mark Thomas from University College London said: “Ethnicity is a socially constructed category, not a genetic one. Genetic tests cannot assign an ethnicity unless people start to construct ethnicities on the basis of genetic tests. They can identify genetic clusters in modern populations and compare your genes to the different clusters but there’s very little ancestry inference in that. It doesn’t mean it’s where your genes come from.”
So that’s the first point, there’s no such thing as Irish DNA or any other ethnic group. There are just clusters. I think what the big testing companies do is take a group of volunteers from each country eg Ireland, Scotland, England, Denmark etc and test them. Then they use that data as a benchmark for others who send in their DNA sample. But many of those benchmark folk might easily have ancestors who came from all over the place. So the data cannot be very reliable for comparison purposes.
7000 years ago Ireland was empty. Nobody lived here at all. England and mainland Europe was inhabited, and had been for many hundreds of thousands of years. So everyone here today has ancestors who came from somewhere else - principally England or mainland Europe including Scandinavia. Since then folk have been going backwards and forward between Ireland and Britain and elsewhere for 7000 years.
They still do it today. I live in Co. Antrim and a fair number of people here have children who go to university in England and Scotland. Some of those students meet partners and settle there. Some have a couple of kids and then miss their “mammy” in Ireland and move back. That sort of internal migration, in a hundred different forms, has been going on, within these islands for 7000 years. A flight from Belfast to Glasgow takes 20 minutes. It’s that close. So what’s the ethnicity of a child born in Scotland to Irish and Scottish parents whose ancestors may have come from England or Wales. Or Norway. I certainly wouldn’t like to say.
Up in Ballycastle, on the north Antrim coast, we can clearly see the distilleries on the Scottish island of Islay 25 miles away. (They have helpfully painted them white). Famous ones like Laphroaig, Lagavulin and Ardbeg. The Mull of Kintyre in Scotland is also nearby, just 11 miles away off to the right. Again clearly visible. I have been over to Islay, on the ferry from Ballycastle. I walked around a graveyard there and found the same surnames as in graveyards here in Co. Antrim, the same Celtic crosses from 800AD celebrating the same monks and saints. These were clearly the same people. (The Irish Book of Kells, now in Trinity College Dublin, was created by monks in Iona in Scotland. They were inspired by an Irishman, St Columba who went to Iona in about 500 AD. But he in turn was inspired by that famous Irish priest St Patrick (who appears to have been born in Wales or Scotland). And so it goes on. Like a Russian doll, each time you investigate one there’s another within.
The third most common surname in Ireland is Walsh (or Welch & Welsh). It just means Welsh. Most people with that name are descended from Welsh people who settled in Ireland around the time of the Normans (1066 and all that). So are they Irish or Welsh? Discuss, as they say. And what does their DNA mean? Is it Welsh or Irish? And where did they come from to get to Wales? And so it goes on.
An anecdote that I sometime use involves what I think most people would agree is the most famous Irish song and tune in the world. Danny Boy. The tune is called the Londonderry air. You can’t get anything more Irish than Danny Boy, can you? Well the first thing you need to know is that the words were written in 1910 by an English solicitor from Manchester, called Fred Weatherly. He put his words to the tune. Where did the tune come from? Well, in 1851, Elizabeth Ross in Limavady, Co. Derry heard it being played in the street by an itinerant blind fiddler called Jimmy McCurry from Ballycastle, Co. Antrim. She wrote it down, and there’s a blue plaque on the wall of her house now to celebrate her helpful actions. But where did Jimmy McCurry get the tune from? Well, he said it was a very old tune he learned from his father, another fiddler who came from Portnahaven on Islay. The father had been over from Scotland on business in Ballycastle and met a girl there, and eventually settled in Ireland, in Myroe, Co Derry. So the most famous Irish song in the world has words by an Englishman to a tune that is probably Scottish. But it isn’t any the less Irish for all that. I tend to see ethnicity is a similar vein. I think it’s for you to decide what ethnicity you are most comfortable with. And leave it at that.
Just to show it’s not all made up, here’s blind Jimmy McCurry in the 1901 census:
http://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/pages/1901/Londonderry/Myroe/Myroe_Level/1523675/
Having told that anecdote I should also say that because people went back and forth between Ireland and Scotland all the time, the tune is just as likely to have been composed in Ireland and taken to Scotland by visiting fiddlers or someone who had moved there. And it just made its way back here again for Elizabeth Ross to write down. But that spoils the story, so we won’t go there.
Finally, I have attached a photo taken from near the Giants’ Causeway in Co. Antrim looking across at the Scottish coast (the Mull of Kintyre). Perhaps it demonstrates more powerfully than I can explain how close it is and so why the idea of people from there and people from here being distinct separate ethnic groups for DNA purposes is just daft.