Back to Message Board

Kelly And Carroll Families

Looking for help to determine where in Ireland my Catholic great grandparents were born and their mothers and grandmothers maiden names.

I have limited information from New York City death certificates.

Great grandfather William Kelly died 07 MAY 1890 Manhattan NYC Age 41 (born about 1849 in Ireland), about 32 years in USA, parents John and Bridget Kelly.

The key piece of information I have is that William has a younger brother John born in 1852 (date from 1900 census).

Best match in 1870 census for Manhattan NYC is Kelly family consisting of Bridget age 55, Michael 24, William 22 and John 18.

Best match in ship records is from August 1860 Mich Kelly 16, Wm Kelly 11 and Jno Kelly 7. No parents just the 3 boys.

I don't know if my Kelly family actually has a brother Michael. I don't know when or if the parents John and Bridget Kelly made it to the USA.

Great grandmother Catherine Carroll died 05 DEC 1884 Manhattan NYC Age 32 (born about 1852 in Ireland), about 20 years in USA, parents John and Mary Carroll.

No information about siblings.

1880 census says Catherine born in Ireland.

Best match in 1870 census is Carroll family in Brooklyn NYC showing parents born in Ireland and daughter Catherine born in New York.

Can't find a good match in ship records for my Carroll family.

I'll take any close or possible information on both families that is available.

I have DNA tested (FTDNA and Ancestry) and don't have enough Kelly/Carroll family information to match my family tree with the family trees of my Irish DNA matches.

IrelandXO member

2 replies

JBirk:

Welcome to Ireland Reaching Out!

Unfortunate that you don't have the maiden name for the mother's of Catherine and William. Roots Ireland has 13 Catherine Carroll baptismal records from 1847-1857 with parents John and Mary. There are a good number of RC parishes which do not have record back to 1850 and also Roots does not have records for all counties. Carroll is a very common surname not as common as Kelly but still very common.

There are seven William Kelly baptismal records between 1844-1854 with parents John and Bridget. The same caveats about Roots Ireland are applicable.

It is good that you have tested your DNA. Eventually you should have a breakthru based on my own personal experience. You may want to look into Gedmatch www.gedmatch.com ; Gedmatch is a volunteer run site where you can load your raw DNA data from one of your two tests and see if you match someone who tested with another company and also loaded their data to Gedmatch. It expands your matching pool.

Roger McDonnell

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Roger, thanks for checking.

Kelly and Carroll are much too common surnames as there are a plethora of Kellys and Carrolls in New York.

In the 1870 New York census there are 50 William Kellys born 1847 to 1851, 149 John Kellys born 1850 to 1854  and 44 Catherine/Katherine Carrolls born 1850 to 1854.

I have no choice but to wait for unknown 3rd cousins to DNA test and for Findmypast to digitize the Archdiocese of New York records.

I have had my DNA at GEDmatch for one year.

JBirk

 

IrelandXO member

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.