Cheryl:
Welcome to Ireland Reaching Out!
This Irish Times web site http://www.irishtimes.com/ancestor/surname/ will show you where the surname McConahy and its many variants were found in mid-19th century. The more common spelling is McConaghywhich is an Ulster surname primarily found in Co. Antrim.
I took a quick look at Roots Ireland from 1841-1851 and there were around ten John McConaghy or variant spelling baptismal records. In addition there were likely other John McConahy records not on Roots because the records for those churches are no longer available.
You will need to search for a death record or obituary which might show the names of John's parents. With that information, we can determine if any of the ten records is for your ancestor.
Roger McDonnell