Back to Message Board

John McCorkell was born 1803

In Melbourne Australia he had Templemore inserted in his leadlight front door and told everyone that is where hewas born. He married Elizabeth Holmes born 1808 in the townland Scotland in the Donaghmore Prebyterian Church on the 14thFebruary 1839.Elizabeth`s mother wasMaryThompson of Raphoe.On the marriage record John`s Townland is Munellan but think it should be Mullennan in the parish of Templemore 3 miles SW of Derry town where in 1831/32 ValuationSurveywe have anAndrewMcCorkell living.

The children of the marriage are :

MaryJane c1839 Died in Ireland

MargaretJuly 1841 born Ireland or Scotland

The family of 3 left Greenock in Scotland on the Robert Benn and arrived 26thJanuary 1842 at Melbourne, however there was Jane McCorkell born 1817 Donegal accompanying them who died at Kyneton Australia with a no info deathcertificate.Their first born in Australia was christenedAndrew who died at birth. Were they following the Scottish rule of naming children after their parents?

John McCorkell died 28thDecember 1898 in Carlton Australia with a no info death certificatemadeout by the undertaker,but told all about the 3 McCorkell brothers rowing a boat from Scotland to Ireland in the 1792, a descendant of one became the shipping magnate .

Can you help me find John McCorkell`s birth place and parents?

IrelandXO member

9 replies

Welcome!

I have asked a volunteer to take a look at this - he is currently on holiday but will be back to you next week with whatever assistance he can give.

Best wishes

Clare Doyle

Genealogy Support 

IrelandXO member

Tradition was to marry in the bride’s church, so it’s likely that Elizabeth attended Donaghmore Presbyterian church but it might not necessarily be John’s (though it could be).

You may struggle to find any earlier records for her though as Donaghmore Presbyterian has no baptisms earlier than 1835, though their marriages start in 1819. Carnone Presbyterian church isn’t too far away but it has no baptisms earlier than 1834 and marriages only start in 1846.

Presbyterian churches generally don’t keep burial records, so unless the family has a gravestone, it may be difficult to find where they are buried.

As far as Monellan is concerned, I’d somehow expect it to be the one in Donaghmore (the bride’s parish) than Mullenan in Co Derry. People tended to marry near to where they lived. Most courting was done on foot and in a farming community there was rarely time to court someone who lived 30 miles away. That’s a lot of walking. Though it did happen of course. (I note too that Jane McCorkell who accompanied your family was born in Co Donegal, not Co Londonderry, suggesting that the family were from Donegal). The townland of Scotland is just north of Castlefinn and Monellan is south of Stranorlar, so they are only a few miles apart.

Where a townland is recorded in marriage records and is outside the parish or immediate area where the marriage took place, the Minister would tend to put some additional information eg “Monellan, parish of Templemore.” Whereas if it was local then he’d just put the townland name.

Unfortunately the tithe applotment records for Monellan, in Co Donegal have not survived, so we can’t say whether there was a McCorkell household listed there in there 1830s. Bear in mind though that the tithes don’t list everyone in the area, just those with land (the tithes were compiled for land tax purposes). So farm labourers, servants etc weren’t listed. So there could be other McCorkell households in the area that wouldn’t be in the tithes.

I looked at Griffiths Valuation for Monellan, Donaghmore, in 1857. There were no McCorkell households listed then.

http://www.askaboutireland.ie/griffith-valuation/index.xml?action=nameSearch

Likewise there are none there in the 1901 census:

http://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/pages/1901/Donegal/Gleneely/Monellan/

Scotland & Ireland both used the same naming pattern for children (though there are many families that didn’t use it that strictly or indeed at all).

The story about 3 brothers rowing a boat from Scotland to Ireland is perfectly feasible. The distance is only about 13 miles across at the narrowest point and has been rowed and swum many times. People went back and forth all the time (and still do).

The majority of the Scottish settlers in Co Donegal and surrounding counties are descendants of folk who moved to Ireland in the 1600s, as part of the Plantation of Ulster. People did arrive in the 1700s but mostly they were leaving by that time. I looked at the Muster Rolls for the Raphoe area c 1630. (Muster Rolls listed all adult men capable of bearing arms, in case of an attack by the native Irish). There’s an Andrew McCorkill listed on Lady Cunningham’s estate in Raphoe. He had a sword and a pike, indicating he was slightly better off. (The poorer just had a sword or no arms at all). 2 other McCorkills lived in the area too. So there were McCorkills there since the 1630s anyway.

Elwyn, IrelandXO Volunteer ☘IrelandXO Volunteer

Thompson,

Clare has forwarded me your reply to my post above. Here are a few comments on your reply:

You say you cannot understand why the parents names are not on the marriage records, for the Holmes were prominent people. The explanation is that it wasn’t the practice to record parents names on Presbyterian marriage records prior to April 1845. It’s as simple as that. Even after 1845 it was only the fathers' names that were recorded.

You ask why your ancestor had Templemore above his house name. I obviously can’t say for certain. If it’s the name of his parish of birth, I find that a bit surprising. I have never heard anyone name their house after a parish before. A townland, a local hill or a farm, yes, but not a parish. Also the McCorkell’s appear to have been Presbyterian, and in Ireland Presbyterians don’t use the parish system. (They have presbyteries which are groups of churches). Why name your house after the local civil parish? That wouldn’t have any sentimental association for most people, let alone a Presbyterian. I would somehow be surprised if this use of Templemore is related directly to the parish where he originated. Perhaps it was the name of a farm where he lived?

Having said that, I acknowledge there were McCorkill families farming in Templemore parish, Co Londonderry. There were 8 farms there in the tithe applotment records from the 1830s. See:

http://www.irishgenealogyhub.com/derry/tithe-applotments/templemore-parish.php#.V6hFtBR9eg0

Perhaps you should get a  researcher to go through the surviving Templemore church records in PRONI to see if you can find your ancestor's baptism.

You ask about the spellings of the townlands. They vary all the time. Each writer’s whim. Griffiths clerks tried to standardize the spellings but you’ll still find variations today.

Good luck with your research anyway.

Elwyn, IrelandXO Volunteer ☘IrelandXO Volunteer

 

I had a look at the actual marriage entry for the Holmes=McCorkell marriage. The exact wording is “Elizabeth daughter of the late Charles Holmes of Scotland to John McCorkell of Munellan, parish of Monreagh (near Derry). Feb 14th 1839”. MIC1P/27 at PRONI.

So as I mentioned previously, the Minister did record that the groom was not from the Donaghmore area, as was the custom of the time.

Monreagh Presbyterian church unfortunately only has baptism and marriage records from 1845 onwards, so if that's where John was baptised or where Mary Jane and Margaret were also baptised, no records have survived.

 

Elwyn, IrelandXO Volunteer ☘IrelandXO Volunteer

Elwyn    I cannot get a parish of Monreagh or a townland named Munellen  .  Can you help    Laurie

PS . Did you get my thanks email message for it does not appear .  

 

IrelandXO member

Elwyn     My sincere thanks for your help especilly the extra words which did not appear on the copy I bought from the church  . It seems I have come to the end of my research and time to say I tried .  Also I would like to send a warm thankyou to all Ireland Reaching out volunteers for you are angels to us in far off lands     Laurie Thompson  

I had a look at the actual marriage entry for the Holmes=McCorkell marriage. The exact wording is “Elizabeth daughter of the late Charles Holmes of Scotland to John McCorkell of Munellan, parish of Monreagh (near Derry). Feb 14th 1839”. MIC1P/27 at PRONI.

So as I mentioned previously, the Minister did record that the groom was not from the Donaghmore area, as was the custom of the time.

Monreagh Presbyterian church unfortunately only has baptism and marriage records from 1845 onwards, so if that's where John was baptised or where Mary Jane and Margaret were also baptised, no records have survived.

 

Elwyn

IrelandXO member

Thompson,

You are  right that there isn’t a parish of Monreagh. There is however a place called Monreagh, near Derry. It’s actually in the parish of Taughboyne. There’s Monreagh Presbyterian church there together with Ballylennon (1st & 2nd) and St Johnston Presbyterian churches. They are close to Carrigans and St Johnston, a few miles south of Derry City, just across the Co Donegal border.

http://www.stjohnstonandcarrigans.com/monreaghchurch.htm

I have attached a copy of the actual Church register for your marriage so you can see the wording yourself. Not sure about the townland but it could be on either side of the border.

Elwyn, IrelandXO Volunteer ☘IrelandXO Volunteer

Elwyn   My warm thanks  for your patience  and wisdom  . This information gives me a clearerr picture of Where my John McCorkell was born  . I now have to re read my past research to see if anything jumps out  . Thankyou for the photos of the churches .   with best regards  and a verse I will close      Laurie Thompson Australia  

 

May your troubles be less . May your blessings be more 

May nothing but happiness come through your door 

IrelandXO member

Thompson,

I discovered from another post that there is a Monreagh Ulster-Scots Society. You might want to get in touch with them to see if they have any record of your family;

You can call direct 00353 74 91 40708.

Or e-mail office@monreagh.net

You can also make contact via facebook. facebook.monreagh.net

Elwyn, IrelandXO Volunteer ☘IrelandXO Volunteer

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.